BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 1 · Week 15 of 33

Episode 14

Grappling with God, Part 2

Genesis 32–35: A Night of Wrestling, a New Name and a Change Still Unfinished

90-minute session Genesis 32:3–32; Genesis 33:1–17; Genesis 35:1–20

For group discussion. Listen to episode 14 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Wrestling at the Jabbok 30 min
  3. The Turning Point That Wasn’t 35 min
  4. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 1 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 -1 Introduction What Is BEMA?
2 1 Genesis 1–11 Trust the Story
3 2 Genesis 1–11 Knowing When to Say “Enough”
4 3 Genesis 1–11 Master the Beast
5 4 Genesis 1–11 His Bow in the Clouds
6 5 Genesis 1–11 A Misplaced Curse
7 6 Genesis 1–11 A Tale of a Tower
8 7 Genesis 1–11 The Preface
9 8 Genesis 11–50 Buried in a Genealogy
10 9 Genesis 11–50 Letting Go
11 10 Genesis 11–50 Walking the Blood Path
12 11 Genesis 11–50 Here I Am
13 12 Genesis 11–50 A Mission Realized
14 13 Genesis 11–50 Grappling with God, Part 1
15 14 Genesis 11–50 Grappling with God, Part 2
16 15 Genesis 11–50 Into the Pit
17 16 Genesis 11–50 Out of the Pit
18 17 Exodus A God Who Hears the Cry
19 18 Exodus A Tale of Two Kingdoms
20 19 Exodus A Strengthened Heart
21 20 Exodus With All Your Heart
22 21 Exodus With All Your Soul & “Very”
23 22 Exodus Under the Chuppah
24 23 Exodus Falling on Joyful Faces
25 24 Exodus Creating a Space
26 25 Leviticus A Kingdom of What?
27 26 Images of the Desert Shepherd
28 27 Images of the Desert Rotem and Acacia
29 28 Images of the Desert Ar'ar and Tamarisk
30 29 Images of the Desert Wadi and En Gedi
31 30 Numbers Lead with Your Voice
32 31 Deuteronomy Remember Where You Came From
33 32 Capstone Session 1 Capstone

Last week: Jacob, the “overreacher,” took the birthright and the blessing, met God in a nowhere place called Bethel, and met his match in Laban. The notes suggested God prefers a fire in the belly to apathy.1

This week: On his way home to face Esau, Jacob wrestles through the night and comes away limping, with a new name. The episode calls wrestling with God a defining mark of God’s people, and then shows that one night did not finish Jacob’s transformation.2

About This Session

The episode covers Genesis 32–35. Jacob, afraid of Esau, arranges his family in a defensive line, then spends a night wrestling a figure the text calls “a man.” He demands a blessing, is asked his name, and is renamed Israel. The notes treat this as a major premise of BEMA: God chooses people who are willing to wrestle with him, and questions are part of faith rather than a threat to it.

The chapters that follow are messy. Jacob tells Esau he will meet him in Seir but settles in Sukkoth instead. His daughter Dinah is assaulted and his sons take violent revenge on Shechem. God renames him a second time at Bethel, and Rachel dies giving birth to Benjamin. The notes see in all this a transformation that is real but not linear. Churches differ in how welcome questions and doubts have felt, so this week invites us to describe our experience rather than judge anyone’s tradition.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: What is a name or nickname you have been called (by family, friends or yourself), and what did it say about who people thought you were?

Wrestling at the Jabbok 30 min

The night before he meets Esau, Jacob wrestles a stranger and will not let go.

Read Genesis 32:22–32 aloud.

Q1: The notes point out that the text says Jacob wrestles with “a man,” and that Jacob speaks of wrestling with God only when he remembers back. They also note that Jacob asks a stranger for a blessing, which says a lot about the power of words in this culture.3 Walking through the passage again, what details do you notice about the wrestler, what Jacob asks for, and what he carries away from the fight?

Q2: The notes explain that in Hebrew culture names communicate essence and identity, not just labels, and that name changes typically come from someone with authority. Before Jacob receives a new name he must say his old one, “heel holder,” and the question “What is your name?” forces him to confront who he really is.4 Why might it matter that Jacob has to say his own name out loud before he receives a new one?

Q3: Optional The notes ask whether Jacob wrestled with God literally or figuratively wrestled with God through his life. The hosts also discuss other readings of the wrestler, including “the spirit of Esau.”5 How do these different readings change what you think Jacob was really wrestling with that night?

Q4: The notes call this a major premise for BEMA: “G-d chooses people who are willing to wrestle with him.” They also suggest that churches which discourage questions can miss the biblical model of faith.6 Our traditions have handled questions in different ways, and many of us have experienced more than one. Thinking about your own story, where did you learn whether wrestling with God was welcome, and what is one question you are wrestling with now (if you are willing to share it)?

The Turning Point That Wasn’t 35 min

After the wrestling match, Jacob’s story keeps going, and not in a straight line.

Read Genesis 33:12–17 aloud.

Q5: The notes observe that it is common to believe the wrestling match is the turning point in Jacob’s story. “However, Jacob decieves Esau when he says they’ll meet in Seir but instead, Jacob goes and settles in Sukkoth.”7 What do you notice in this passage about how Jacob speaks to Esau and what he actually does?

Read Genesis 35:1–15 aloud.

Q6: The notes point out two things about this return to Bethel. Abraham and Isaac built altars and “called on the name of the Lord,” but the text does not say Jacob did. And God changes Jacob’s name a second time, which raises the question: hadn’t God already changed it?8 The notes offer a possible answer: “Israel means Conquored G-d but it can just as easily mean G-d Conquored.” At the Jabbok, Jacob won; the second time, perhaps God finally takes hold of Jacob’s life.9 What do you make of this two-step renaming, and how does it change the way you read the night at the Jabbok?

Read Genesis 35:16–20 aloud.

Q7: Optional The notes compare this scene to earlier moments in Genesis (Adam and Eve, and Noah leaving the ark) where “be fruitful and increase in number” is followed by tragedy. As Rachel dies she names her son Ben-Oni, which the notes translate “son of my trouble,” but Jacob names him Benjamin, “son of my right hand.” The notes also say Jacob later takes responsibility for Rachel’s death because of the oath he swore when Laban searched for his stolen idols.10 What do you notice about the two names, and what might it mean that one version of the notes sees Jacob’s deeper change beginning only after this loss?11

Q8: The notes describe spiritual transformation as messy and non-linear: Jacob does not become perfect after his encounter with God.12 Think of a time when you believed something was your turning point (a decision, an experience, a commitment) and then found old patterns coming back. What did you learn about how God changes people?

Closing 15 min

Jacob limps away from the Jabbok with a blessing and a new name, but the next chapters show him still bargaining, still avoiding his brother, and still building altars without calling on God’s name. God renames him a second time, and the notes wonder whether this time God is the one who wins. Israel, the name God’s people will carry, comes from a man who wrestled with God. The episode suggests that the wrestling, the questions and the slow, uneven change are not failures of faith but part of what faith looks like.13

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one thing you are still wrestling with God about, or one thing you sense God is still wrestling out of you?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 15 — Into the Pit (55:51): The story turns to Jacob’s sons in Genesis 37–40. Joseph receives a second coat that marks him as the chosen heir, shares his dreams in ways that provoke his brothers, and ends up in a pit, in Potiphar’s house and in prison. The episode challenges the “heroic Joseph” many of us learned, and traces a Hebrew word for “recognize” that exposes a family pattern of deception.14

What to bring next week:

  • Read Genesis 37 and Genesis 38, and mark every time clothing or the word “recognize” (some translations say “examine” or “identify”) appears.
  • Think about how Joseph was presented to you as a child, and bring one word that sums up that picture.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with co-host Reed Dent. “Grappling with God, Part 1.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 13. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/13. Jacob the “overreacher,” the birthright and blessing, Bethel, Laban, and God’s preference for fire over apathy. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with co-host Reed Dent. “Grappling with God, Part 2.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 14. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/14. The episode covers Genesis 32–35, treating wrestling with God as defining for God’s people and Jacob’s transformation as incomplete. ↩

  3. Ep. 14 notes. The text says Jacob wrestles with a man, Jacob speaks of wrestling with God only in hindsight, and his request for a blessing reflects the power of words. ↩

  4. Ep. 14 notes. Names communicate essence and identity, name changes come from someone with authority, and Jacob must confess his name before receiving a new one. ↩

  5. Ep. 14 notes. The literal or figurative question and the hosts’ discussion of the wrestler possibly representing “the spirit of Esau.” ↩

  6. Ep. 14 notes. God chooses people willing to wrestle with him, a major premise for BEMA, and churches that discourage questions miss the biblical model. ↩

  7. Ep. 14 notes. Jacob tells Esau they will meet in Seir but settles in Sukkoth. ↩

  8. Ep. 14 notes. Jacob builds an altar without calling on the name of the Lord, and God renames him again in Genesis 35:10. ↩

  9. Ep. 14 notes. “Israel” can mean “conquered God” or “God conquered,” suggesting Jacob won the first time and God the second. ↩

  10. Ep. 14 notes. The “be fruitful and increase” pattern followed by tragedy, the names Ben-Oni and Benjamin, and Jacob’s later sense of responsibility for Rachel’s death because of his oath to Laban. ↩

  11. Ep. 14 notes. The 2017 study notes suggest that genuine transformation begins only after Jacob loses Rachel. ↩

  12. Ep. 14 notes. Spiritual transformation is messy and non-linear; Jacob does not become perfect after his encounter with God. ↩

  13. Ep. 14 notes. The name “Israel” comes from Jacob’s struggle, and questions and doubts are presented as part of faith. ↩

  14. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Into the Pit.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 15. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/15. Joseph’s second coat, his dreams, the challenge to the heroic Joseph, and the pattern of nakar (“recognize”). ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.