BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 1 · Week 31 of 33

Episode 30

Lead with Your Voice

Numbers 20: Why Moses Stopped Short of the Land

90-minute session Exodus 17:1–7; Numbers 20:1–13, 29; Numbers 22:21–31

For group discussion. Listen to episode 30 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Two Rocks, Two Stories 30 min
  3. Stick Power and Voice Power 30 min
  4. Closing 20 min

Where We Are

The Session 1 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 -1 Introduction What Is BEMA?
2 1 Genesis 1–11 Trust the Story
3 2 Genesis 1–11 Knowing When to Say “Enough”
4 3 Genesis 1–11 Master the Beast
5 4 Genesis 1–11 His Bow in the Clouds
6 5 Genesis 1–11 A Misplaced Curse
7 6 Genesis 1–11 A Tale of a Tower
8 7 Genesis 1–11 The Preface
9 8 Genesis 11–50 Buried in a Genealogy
10 9 Genesis 11–50 Letting Go
11 10 Genesis 11–50 Walking the Blood Path
12 11 Genesis 11–50 Here I Am
13 12 Genesis 11–50 A Mission Realized
14 13 Genesis 11–50 Grappling with God, Part 1
15 14 Genesis 11–50 Grappling with God, Part 2
16 15 Genesis 11–50 Into the Pit
17 16 Genesis 11–50 Out of the Pit
18 17 Exodus A God Who Hears the Cry
19 18 Exodus A Tale of Two Kingdoms
20 19 Exodus A Strengthened Heart
21 20 Exodus With All Your Heart
22 21 Exodus With All Your Soul & “Very”
23 22 Exodus Under the Chuppah
24 23 Exodus Falling on Joyful Faces
25 24 Exodus Creating a Space
26 25 Leviticus A Kingdom of What?
27 26 Images of the Desert Shepherd
28 27 Images of the Desert Rotem and Acacia
29 28 Images of the Desert Ar'ar and Tamarisk
30 29 Images of the Desert Wadi and En Gedi
31 30 Numbers Lead with Your Voice
32 31 Deuteronomy Remember Where You Came From
33 32 Capstone Session 1 Capstone

Last week: In the wadis we learned to follow the guide’s voice around the next bend. At En Gedi we learned that God is our living water and wants living water to flow through us to others, and the wadi floods taught us that wisdom is about where we build.1

This week: Back to the story in Numbers. Moses strikes the rock and is told he will not lead the people into the land, and the desert’s lesson about the shepherd’s voice helps explain why.2

About This Session

Why was Moses kept out of the Promised Land? The familiar answers (he hit the rock twice, he did not follow the instructions exactly, he took the credit) are, in Marty and Brent’s view, inadequate when examined closely. The episode reads Numbers 20 against its deliberate twin, the water from the rock in Exodus 17, and against the BEMA framework of two competing narratives: Empire, which rules by force, fear and the “stick,” and Shalom, which leads by invitation, trust and the “voice.”

Moses spent forty years in Pharaoh’s household and forty years shepherding in the desert before he led Israel. In Numbers 20, the episode suggests, he reverts to Empire’s methods. Two Hebrew words carry the argument: nakah, “to strike to kill,” and paniym, “before” or “in front of,” which describes where God and the people stand in relation to the rock. The death of Miriam at the start of the chapter, with no public mourning recorded, may help explain Moses’ state of mind, and the story of Balaam’s donkey, which soon follows, drives home the contrast between stick and voice.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a coach, teacher, boss or parent you would have followed anywhere. What did they do (or not do) that made you want to follow them?

Two Rocks, Two Stories 30 min

Numbers 20 is written to be read alongside Exodus 17.

Read Exodus 17:1–7 and Numbers 20:1–13 aloud, with a different reader for each.

Q1: The notes say the Numbers 20 story is deliberately linked to Exodus 17 through specific Hebrew phrases and narrative parallels.3 Compare the two stories. What does God tell Moses to do each time? Where does God stand, where do the people stand, and what does Moses say and do? List as many similarities and differences as you can find.

Q2: Optional The notes name three traditional explanations for Moses’ punishment: striking the rock twice, not following instructions, and taking credit. The episode calls them inadequate when examined closely.4 Which explanation were you taught, if any, and what did it leave you satisfied or unsatisfied with? (Our traditions may have taught this story differently; the point is to describe, not to defend.)

Q3: In Exodus 17, God told Moses to nakah (“strike to kill”) the rock while God stood paniym, “in front of” him, between Moses and the rock. God was taking the blow for the people.5 (We met this scene in Week 22.6) In Numbers 20, the notes suggest, Moses places the people in front of the rock, reversing the lesson, and strikes twice; they even raise the possibility that he directed violence toward the people rather than taking it upon himself.7 The notes also read God’s verdict as Moses failing to show God as kadosh (“holy”), meaning fundamentally different from other gods: marked by love, mercy and restoration rather than violence.8 What do you make of this reading? If it is right, what exactly did the people see about God when Moses struck the rock?

Q4: The notes draw a principle from the story: leaders are called to demonstrate God’s character through their methods, not just to accomplish right outcomes through wrong means.9 When have you seen a good result reached by a harmful method, in your own life or around you? What did that method say about the God we claim to represent?

Stick Power and Voice Power 30 min

Moses learned two ways of leading, and under pressure the older one came back.

Q5: The notes divide Moses’ life into three forty-year phases: raised in Pharaoh’s household, learning Empire’s methods while keeping God’s heart for the oppressed; shaped as a shepherd in the desert, learning God’s ways; and leading Israel, with ongoing lessons in using God’s authority rather than Pharaoh’s methods.10 Three weeks ago we heard that a shepherd leads with the voice and never with the stick.11 Where do you see each phase of Moses’ life showing up in Numbers 20?

Read Numbers 20:1 and 20:29 aloud.

Q6: Optional The notes point to Miriam’s death at the start of the chapter, with no public mourning recorded, in contrast with the mourning for Aaron at its end. They suggest grief may have shaped Moses’ emotional state, and that this may be a “test of the soul,” with Moses essentially saying, “these people don’t deserve water unless they properly mourn my sister.”12 What do you notice about how the two deaths are reported? How does the possibility of unprocessed grief change the way you feel about Moses here?

Read Numbers 22:21–31 aloud.

Q7: Soon after this story comes Balaam, a prophet beating his donkey with a stick until God opens the donkey’s mouth. The notes read it as God using voice when humans will not, and connect it with Jesus saying that if the people kept quiet, the stones would cry out.13 Why might Numbers place this story so close to Moses striking the rock? What is the storyteller trying to make us see?

Q8: The notes say anyone in authority, whether employer, teacher or parent, faces the choice between Empire and Shalom methods, and that the way we use authority tells one narrative or the other.14 Where do you hold some authority, at home, at work, at church or among friends? What does reaching for the stick look like for you when you are tired or grieving, and what would leading with your voice look like there this week?

Closing 20 min

Moses learned leadership in two schools: forty years in Pharaoh’s house and forty years following sheep in the desert. At Massah, God stood before the rock and took the blow for the people; at Meribah, under the weight of grief and frustration, Moses struck in anger and showed the people a god who uses the stick. The episode suggests this is why he could not lead them into the land: the land could not be established through the narrative of force and fear. How we lead matters as much as where we lead people.15

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: where is one place this week where you want to put down the stick and use your voice?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 31 — Remember Where You Came From (43:08): We reach Deuteronomy, Moses’ final teaching before Israel enters the land. Its words for “remember” (zakar) and “do not forget” (shakach) appear again and again, and the repeated phrase “Remember that you were slaves in Egypt” becomes the reason for caring for the foreigner, the orphan and the widow. The episode ends with Moses’ epitaph, which speaks of his intimacy with God rather than his failure.16

What to bring next week:

  • Read Deuteronomy 24:17–22 and Deuteronomy 34:1–12.
  • Bring one story, from your own life or your family’s, of a time you were the newcomer, the outsider or the one in need.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with Elle Grover Fricks. “Images of the Desert — Wadi and En Gedi.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 29. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/29. Wadis teach following the guide’s voice, God is living water who calls us to be living water, and the parable of the builders concerns location. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Lead with Your Voice.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 30. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/30. The episode examines why Moses was denied entry to the land after striking the rock in Numbers 20. ↩

  3. Ep. 30 notes. Numbers 20 is deliberately linked to Exodus 17 through specific Hebrew phrases and narrative parallels. ↩

  4. Ep. 30 notes. The traditional explanations (hitting the rock twice, not following instructions, taking credit) are described as inadequate when examined closely. ↩

  5. Ep. 30 notes. Nakah means “to strike to kill,” and in Exodus 17 God stood paniym, between Moses and the rock, taking the blow for the people. ↩

  6. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “With All Your Soul & ‘Very.’” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 21. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/21. At Horeb, God stands between Moses and the rock, showing his willingness to take the blow on behalf of his people. ↩

  7. Ep. 30 notes. In Numbers 20 Moses positioned the people between himself and the rock, reversing the lesson, and the notes raise the possibility that he directed violence toward the people when he struck twice. ↩

  8. Ep. 30 notes. God’s holiness (kadosh) means he is fundamentally different from other gods, characterized by love, mercy and restoration rather than violence. ↩

  9. Ep. 30 notes. Leaders are called to demonstrate God’s character through their methodology, not just accomplish right outcomes through wrong means. ↩

  10. Ep. 30 notes. Moses’ leadership journey is divided into three forty-year phases. ↩

  11. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with co-host Elle Grover Fricks. “Images of the Desert — Shepherd.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 26. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/26. Shepherds lead with their voice and never with the stick, unlike Pharaoh’s rule by the stick. ↩

  12. Ep. 30 notes. Miriam’s death and the lack of public mourning (in contrast with Aaron’s) may have shaped Moses’ state, and the notes suggest a “test of the soul.” ↩

  13. Ep. 30 notes. The Balaam story follows, with God opening a donkey’s mouth while the prophet beats it with a stick, and the notes connect it with Jesus’ words about the stones crying out. ↩

  14. Ep. 30 notes. Employers, teachers, parents and others in authority face the choice between Empire and Shalom methods, and using authority tells one narrative or the other. ↩

  15. Ep. 30 notes. The summary describes Moses reverting to Empire methods in frustration and grief and God refusing to establish the land through the narrative of force and fear. ↩

  16. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Remember Where You Came From.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 31. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/31. The episode explores zakar and shakach in Deuteronomy, the call to care for the foreigner, orphan and widow, and Moses’ “face to face” epitaph. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.