BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 1 · Week 21 of 33

Episode 20

With All Your Heart

Exodus 14–15: The Sea, the Bitter Water, and a Test of the Will

90-minute session Exodus 14:1–14; Exodus 14:15–22; Exodus 15:1–18; Exodus 15:22–27; Deuteronomy 8:1–5

For group discussion. Listen to episode 20 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Through the Sea 20 min
  3. What Kind of Test? 25 min
  4. Bitter Water and Twelve Springs 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 1 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 -1 Introduction What Is BEMA?
2 1 Genesis 1–11 Trust the Story
3 2 Genesis 1–11 Knowing When to Say “Enough”
4 3 Genesis 1–11 Master the Beast
5 4 Genesis 1–11 His Bow in the Clouds
6 5 Genesis 1–11 A Misplaced Curse
7 6 Genesis 1–11 A Tale of a Tower
8 7 Genesis 1–11 The Preface
9 8 Genesis 11–50 Buried in a Genealogy
10 9 Genesis 11–50 Letting Go
11 10 Genesis 11–50 Walking the Blood Path
12 11 Genesis 11–50 Here I Am
13 12 Genesis 11–50 A Mission Realized
14 13 Genesis 11–50 Grappling with God, Part 1
15 14 Genesis 11–50 Grappling with God, Part 2
16 15 Genesis 11–50 Into the Pit
17 16 Genesis 11–50 Out of the Pit
18 17 Exodus A God Who Hears the Cry
19 18 Exodus A Tale of Two Kingdoms
20 19 Exodus A Strengthened Heart
21 20 Exodus With All Your Heart
22 21 Exodus With All Your Soul & “Very”
23 22 Exodus Under the Chuppah
24 23 Exodus Falling on Joyful Faces
25 24 Exodus Creating a Space
26 25 Leviticus A Kingdom of What?
27 26 Images of the Desert Shepherd
28 27 Images of the Desert Rotem and Acacia
29 28 Images of the Desert Ar'ar and Tamarisk
30 29 Images of the Desert Wadi and En Gedi
31 30 Numbers Lead with Your Voice
32 31 Deuteronomy Remember Where You Came From
33 32 Capstone Session 1 Capstone

Last week: God pursued Pharaoh’s heart through the plagues until Pharaoh saw clearly and chose to resist. Then God invited Israel to become his bechor (firstborn), born again through a bloody doorway to be the message, not just carry it.1

This week: Israel crosses the sea and begins a forty-day journey to Sinai, where God will test them three times. The first test, at the bitter waters of Marah, is a test of the heart.2

About This Session

The episode opens with a review of empire and shalom: if empire is about fear, shalom is about trust; if empire is about coercion, shalom is about invitation.3 Then Israel heads south toward the sea, apparently lost, and Pharaoh gives chase. On the far shore the people call on the name of the Lord together for the first time. Marty draws on a Jewish teaching he calls the “threefold coming of the kingdom”: the finger of God works, people call him Lord, and people respond in obedience.4

The heart of the episode is the idea of testing. In Hebrew thought, God’s tests are not pass or fail. They are a way for God to yada (know intimately, by experience) what is in his people’s hearts, and a chance for them to learn something from him. At Marah the water is bitter, a word that also means “rebellious,” and a midrash says the “law and statute” God gave there was that the weak and marginalized drink first. Just around the corner wait twelve springs and seventy palm trees.5 Some of this touches how our traditions talk about faith and obedience, and how we read the details of the sea crossing. The questions invite description and curiosity rather than debate.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a test you once took (a school exam, a job review, a driving test). How did being tested feel, and what did you assume the person testing you wanted?

Through the Sea 20 min

Israel’s rescue begins with what looks like a wrong turn.

Read Exodus 14:1–14 aloud.

Q1: The notes explain that God has Israel camp between Migdol and the sea so that Pharaoh will think they are wandering around in the desert. When Pharaoh’s army appears, the people turn on Moses and ask why he brought them out to the desert to die instead of leaving them to serve the Egyptians. Moses tells them to stand firm and see God deliver them.6 What do you notice about the people’s fear, about what they remember of Egypt, and about how Moses answers them?

Q2: Optional The notes say “Red Sea” is better translated “Sea of Reeds” (Yam Suph). They add that there are about nineteen respected opinions on the location of Sinai and about as many on the crossing, and BEMA will not try to decide. The 2024 notes also observe that Exodus 14 tells the story in more historical language (an east wind, Moses’ staff) while the song in Exodus 15 uses poetic language (God’s nostrils, his right hand).7 Glance at Exodus 15:6–10. How does it help to have the same event told in two different registers, and how do you usually hold questions about where and how it happened?

Read Exodus 14:15–22 aloud.

Q3: The notes describe the “threefold coming of the kingdom.” The finger of God works (after one plague the magicians told Pharaoh this was “the finger of God,” and it moves again on the sea’s western beach). The people call him Lord (on the eastern beach, the first time they do so as a people). The people respond in obedience (at Sinai). The sages argued that calling on the Lord is not enough without obedience, and Marty believes Jesus taught the same idea when he spoke of casting out demons “by the finger of G-d” and of those who say “Lord Lord.” The notes observe that some people live righteously without calling God Lord, and many call him Lord without obeying.8 Our traditions place different weight on faith, confession and obedience. Which of the three ingredients comes most naturally to you or your tradition, and which tends to go missing?

What Kind of Test? 25 min

A Hebrew test is less an exam than an invitation to be known.

Q4: The notes explain that the Hebrew idea of testing (nasah) is not pass or fail. The 2024 notes compare it to testing strips in a hot tub, which measure where things are in order to know what is needed next rather than to give a grade. God tests his people to yada what is in their hearts, an intimate, experiential knowing rather than a cerebral one.9 Compare this with the test you described in the opening. What changes when the one testing you wants to know you rather than grade you?

Read Deuteronomy 8:1–5 aloud.

Q5: The rabbis go back to Deuteronomy 8:1–5 to show that Marah was a test of the heart, asking whether the people would willingly wait on every word from God. The notes say a test carries two gifts: one we give to God, showing him what is in our hearts and our willingness to obey (“Not to be perfect but he gets to experience where you are in your growth”), and one God gives to us, a new lesson.10 What do you notice in this passage about what God was looking for in the desert, and about the comparison to a father and son?

Q6: Optional The notes explain that when Hebrew says “heart” (levav), it means the will. Worship comes from the will, so to the Jewish mind worship and obedience are connected: willingly obeying God is itself an act of worship, because you are submitting your will to his desire.11 If worship lives in the will, where in your week might your most real worship be happening, and where might it be missing?

Bitter Water and Twelve Springs 20 min

The first test on the road to Sinai turns out to be about community.

Read Exodus 15:22–27 aloud.

Q7: The notes point out that Moses had spent forty years as a shepherd in this region and likely led the people to this well expecting good water. When it was bitter, the place was named Marah, but the rabbis hear more than bitterness: to be marah is to be defiantly, stubbornly rebellious. Moses throws in a piece of wood (not his staff), the water becomes drinkable, and God gives “a law and a ruling.” The rabbis then ask what that law and statute actually were, since what follows does not really read like one.12 What do you notice in these verses, and what seems to be missing from verse 25?

Q8: Optional The 2024 notes say that visitors to the Sinai wilderness come away with more sympathy for the Israelites’ complaints, since the heat off the canyon walls can feel like “baking in an oven.” The notes encourage us to approach these characters with humility rather than condescension.13 How does that change the way you hear the people’s grumbling, and what complaints of your own might deserve the same humility?

Q9: The midrash says the law and statute given at Marah was this: when they went to drink from the well, they had to let the lame, the elderly, the sick and the marginalized go first. The midrash teaches that every test in the desert is meant to teach some aspect of community, how obedience shapes a people’s life together. Right around the corner were twelve springs, one for each tribe, and seventy palm trees, another communal number. Had they waited on God’s word, there was enough for everyone.14 Who in your community most needs to “drink first,” and what would letting them go first actually cost you this week?

Closing 15 min

Israel walks out of Egypt into what looks like a dead end, and God makes a way through the sea. On the far shore they call him Lord as a people, but the kingdom will not fully come until they also respond in obedience. So God begins to test them, not to grade them but to know their hearts and teach them. At Marah the first lesson is about the will and about community: let the weak drink first, and trust that there is enough. Twelve springs and seventy palm trees were waiting just around the corner.15

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one way you could let someone else “drink first” before we meet again?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 21 — With All Your Soul & “Very” (36:09): The second and third tests on the way to Sinai examine the soul (nephesh, the whole self) and the “very” (meod, all your strength and resources). The episode looks at the people demanding that God prove himself, the water from the rock at Horeb where God stands before Moses and takes the blow, and the battle with Amalek under Moses’ raised staff. It connects all three tests to the Shema.16

What to bring next week:

  • Read Exodus 17:1–16 and Deuteronomy 6:4–5. Note any word or idea from the Shema that you can see at work in Exodus 17.
  • Think of one “if God would just…” condition you have been tempted to set, and be ready to share it if you are comfortable.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “A Strengthened Heart.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 19. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/19. God pursues Pharaoh’s heart, and Israel is invited to be born again as God’s bechor and to be the message. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with co-host Reed Dent. “With All Your Heart.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 20. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/20. After crossing the sea, God takes Israel on a forty-day journey to Sinai with three tests, the first at Marah testing their heart. ↩

  3. Ep. 20 notes. The review of empire and shalom in the original notes. ↩

  4. Ep. 20 notes. The route toward the sea, the people calling on the Lord on the eastern beach, and the three ingredients of the threefold coming of the kingdom. ↩

  5. Ep. 20 notes. Testing as yada with two gifts, Marah as “bitter” and “rebellious,” the midrash on the law and statute, and the twelve springs and seventy palm trees. ↩

  6. Ep. 20 notes. The camp between Migdol and the sea, the people’s anger at Exodus 14:10, and Moses’ answer. ↩

  7. Ep. 20 notes. “Sea of Reeds” (Yam Suph), the many opinions on locations, and the historiographic and poetic accounts in Exodus 14 and 15. ↩

  8. Ep. 20 notes. The threefold coming of the kingdom, the sages’ insistence on obedience, the sayings Marty attributes to Jesus, and the contemporary observation about missing elements. ↩

  9. Ep. 20 notes. Testing (nasah) as not pass or fail, the hot tub testing strips, and yada as intimate knowing. ↩

  10. Ep. 20 notes. The rabbis’ use of Deuteronomy 8:1–5 and the two gifts of a test; the quotation is from the original notes. ↩

  11. Ep. 20 notes. Levav as the will, and the connection between worship and obedience. ↩

  12. Ep. 20 notes. Moses’ forty years in the region, the meaning of marah, the wood that was not his staff, and the rabbis’ question about the law and statute. ↩

  13. Ep. 20 notes. The desert heat described as “baking in an oven” and the call to approach the Israelites with humility. ↩

  14. Ep. 20 notes. The midrash on letting the weak drink first, the teaching that every desert test concerns community, and the meaning of twelve and seventy. ↩

  15. Ep. 20 notes. The personal summaries on the crossing, testing as relationship, and provision following the lesson at Marah. ↩

  16. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “With All Your Soul & ‘Very’.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 21. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/21. The episode covers the tests of nephesh and meod, the rock at Horeb, the battle with Amalek, and the Shema. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.