BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 2 · Week 6 of 40

Episode 38

A Donkey Herder to Lead Us

1 Samuel 8–16: A King Like the Nations, or a Shepherd from the Fields?

90-minute session Deuteronomy 17:14–15; 1 Samuel 8:1–20; 1 Samuel 9:1–4; 1 Samuel 16:1–13

For group discussion. Listen to episode 38 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. A King Like the Nations 25 min
  3. A Donkey Herder 15 min
  4. The Youngest Son 25 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 2 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeBookFocus
1 33 Introduction Session 2 Intro
2 34 Joshua The Hardest Story in the Bible (for me)
3 35 Joshua Crossroads of the Earth
4 36 Judges The Redemption Cycle
5 37 Ruth A Love Story
6 38 Samuel A Donkey Herder to Lead Us
7 39 Samuel A King After God’s Own Heart
8 40 Kings & Chronicles One Story, Two Sources
9 41 Kings & Chronicles The Story Behind the Story
10 42 Elijah & Elisha The Fire of Elijah
11 43 Elijah & Elisha Go in Peace
12 44 Psalms Our Harps in the Trees
13 45 Proverbs & Ecclesiastes Wisdom and Meaning
14 46 Song of Songs Song of Sexuality
15 47 The Prophets The Lord’s Mouthpiece
16 48 Amos Plumb Line
17 49 Hosea Garden
18 50 Micah Judge
19 51 Isaiah Vineyard
20 52 Jonah Potential
21 53 Nahum Diyn
22 54 Zephaniah T'shuvah
23 55 Isaiah Woe
24 56 Jeremiah Weeping
25 57 Lamentations Lament and Hope
26 58 Habakkuk Watchtower
27 59 Obadiah Petra
28 60 Joel Locusts
29 61 Ezekiel Strength
30 62 Daniel Son of Man
31 63 Job Perspective
32 64 Isaiah Servant
33 65 Isaiah Hope
34 66 Ezra/Nehemiah Passionate Leadership
35 67 Haggai Build!
36 68 Zechariah Apocalyptic Literature
37 69 Malachi Q&A
38 70 Esther Esther — Purim
39 71 The Prophets The Prophetic Table
40 72 Capstone Session 2 Capstone

Last week: In the dark days of the judges, Ruth and Boaz showed covenant love in practice, and a Moabite widow became the great-grandmother of David.

This week: Israel asks for a king. The episode sets Israel’s first two kings side by side and asks what each one reveals about God’s people and about how God chooses.

About This Session

The episode opens at the end of Judges, where the story of the Levite’s concubine mirrors Sodom and Gomorrah. The hosts see a shift here from the “redemption cycle” to the “anti-story”: Israel is no longer struggling to follow God but working against his purposes.1 Asking for a king was not wrong in itself, since Deuteronomy 17 anticipated it. The problem was Israel’s motive: they wanted to be “like all the other nations” and wanted a king to fight their battles.2

God gives them Saul, tall and impressive, but first met as a donkey herder who cannot find his donkeys, from the tribe of Benjamin. Then God chooses David, the youngest of eight, a shepherd from Judah.3 The episode names the difference between them with the Hebrew phrase kiddush HaShem, “hallowing the name,” and gives two reasons God keeps choosing people from the bottom of the heap.4 This is a short episode, so the guide gives extra time to reading the texts together.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think back to a time when you badly wanted to be like everyone else: to dress like them, have what they had, or do what they did. What was driving that desire, and how do you see it now?

A King Like the Nations 25 min

Israel’s request was anticipated, but their reasons gave them away.

Read Deuteronomy 17:14–15 aloud, then 1 Samuel 8:1–20.

Q1: If you did the preparation, share the reasons you found. The notes say “The issue wasn’t asking for a king per se,” because Deuteronomy anticipated the request. The problem was Israel’s specific language in 1 Samuel 8, wanting to be “like all the other nations” and wanting a king to “go out before us and fight our battles.”5 Compare the two passages. What does Deuteronomy require of a king, and what does Israel actually ask for?

Q2: The notes call the second statement “particularly egregious because throughout their history, they’ve been told repeatedly that the Lord goes before them to fight their battles.” They add that Israel had “lost the plot of being different - of being a kingdom of priests whose very existence causes the nations to ask, ‘What’s different about your God?’”6 Remember the crossroads of the earth from three weeks ago. Why would wanting to look like the nations undercut the very reason God placed Israel where he did?

Q3: Optional The notes point out that Eli’s sons were corrupt, that Samuel’s sons also turned out wicked, and that Israel used this corruption as leverage: “The corruption of spiritual leadership becomes the excuse for abandoning their distinctive calling.”7 The notes recall a warning from Bible college: “Take care of your home life well because who knows how far that gets passed on to your disciples and people after you?”8 Where have you seen failures in leadership become an excuse for something else?

Q4: The notes describe the calling to “be distinctively holy while engaged with the world - different enough that people notice and ask questions.”9 In what part of your life are you most tempted to want what “all the other nations” have, and what would it look like there to be different enough that someone might ask about your God?

A Donkey Herder 15 min

God gives Israel exactly what they asked for, with a message tucked inside.

Read 1 Samuel 9:1–4 aloud.

Q5: What is Saul doing when we first meet him, and how is it going? The notes say “Donkeys in Hebrew culture represent stubbornness and stiff-neckedness,” and “Israel needs a shepherd (for sheep), not a donkey herder.”10 What do you think the narrator is saying about Israel by introducing their first king this way?

Q6: Optional The notes add two more details. Saul comes from Benjamin, whose horrific story at the end of Judges was still fresh, and the “stench of that story is still present in the nostrils of Israel.”11 His impressive appearance recalls Jeremiah’s ar’ar bush in the desert, “something that looks impressive but has no substance.”12 What does the Benjamin connection add to the picture of Saul?

Q7: The ar’ar bush “represents trusting in human strength rather than God.”13 Where are you most tempted to trust what looks impressive on the outside: in leaders you follow, in your own image, or in the things you build?

The Youngest Son 25 min

Samuel goes down the line of impressive brothers, and God chooses the one who was not invited.

Read 1 Samuel 16:1–13 aloud.

Q8: The notes compare this scene to Cinderella: Samuel goes down the line of impressive older brothers “like the stepsisters trying on the glass slipper,” but the one chosen is “working in the fields, smelling like sheep, overlooked by his own father.”14 As you listen, what details show how overlooked David was, even by his own family?

Q9: The notes trace a pattern of God “choosing from the bottom” (Jacob over Esau, Ephraim over Manasseh, slaves rescued from the strongest empire, David over his brothers, Ruth in the royal line) and give two reasons for it.15 First, clarity of source: “When the least succeeds, no one is confused about whose strength is on display.” Second, memory and humility: “People from the bottom remember their story better.”16 Which of these two reasons speaks more to you, and why?

Q10: Optional The notes describe kiddush HaShem (“hallowing the name”) as David’s key trait: he wants to hallow God’s name, be about God’s project, and do things God’s way, while Saul wants “to hallow his own name, build his own reputation, pursue his own project, and do things his way.”17 The notes connect this to the Lord’s Prayer: “Hallowed be Your name.”18 What does it look like in ordinary life to hallow God’s name rather than your own?

Q11: The notes say David could remember “what it’s like to be the last born of eight sons, to smell like sheep, to be overlooked by his own father,” and that “Those who forget where they came from often begin ‘hallowing their own name’ like Saul.”19 What is the humble place you came from, your own version of smelling like sheep, and what helps you remember it?

Closing 15 min

By the end of Judges, Israel had moved from struggling to follow God to living out the anti-story. When they asked for a king, the request itself was anticipated, but their reasons revealed that they wanted to be like everyone else and wanted someone other than God to fight their battles. God gave them a tall, impressive donkey herder from Benjamin. Then he sent Samuel to a family where the youngest son was not even called in from the fields, and chose him. God keeps choosing from the bottom, so that no one mistakes whose strength is at work and so that the ones he chooses remember where they came from.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one way you could hallow God’s name, not your own, this week?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 39 — A King After God’s Own Heart (45:20): David and Goliath in the Valley of Elah. The episode looks past the familiar underdog story to the strategic geography, Saul’s forty days of paralysis, the symbolism of Goliath’s numbers, and the challenge to “throw your stone.” It closes with what made David a man after God’s own heart, and hints at where he would later fall.

What to bring next week: Read 1 Samuel 17 in full. Write down every number the chapter mentions and every reason David gives for going to fight.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “A Donkey Herder to Lead Us.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 38. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/38. The end of Judges marks a shift from the redemption cycle to the anti-story. ↩

  2. Ep. 38 notes. Israel’s request for a king was anticipated in Deuteronomy 17, but their motivation was the problem. ↩

  3. Ep. 38 notes. The contrast between Saul and David in occupation, tribe and appearance. ↩

  4. Ep. 38 notes. Kiddush HaShem as the difference between David and Saul, and two reasons God chooses from the bottom. ↩

  5. Ep. 38 notes. The problem with Israel’s specific language in 1 Samuel 8. ↩

  6. Ep. 38 notes. Asking for a king to fight their battles rejected God’s leadership and abandoned their distinctiveness. ↩

  7. Ep. 38 notes. The corruption of the priesthood under Eli and Samuel’s sons as Israel’s excuse. ↩

  8. Ep. 38 notes. The Bible college warning to pastors about home life. ↩

  9. Ep. 38 notes. The crossroads principle of being distinctively holy while engaged with the world. ↩

  10. Ep. 38 notes. The symbolism of Saul as a donkey herder. ↩

  11. Ep. 38 notes. Saul’s tribe of Benjamin and the lingering memory of Judges 19–21. ↩

  12. Ep. 38 notes. Saul’s appearance recalls Jeremiah’s ar’ar bush. ↩

  13. Ep. 38 notes. The ar’ar bush represents trusting human strength rather than God. ↩

  14. Ep. 38 notes. The Cinderella story structure of David’s anointing. ↩

  15. Ep. 38 notes. God’s recurring pattern of choosing from the bottom. ↩

  16. Ep. 38 notes. The two reasons for the pattern: clarity of source, and memory and humility. ↩

  17. Ep. 38 notes. Kiddush HaShem as David’s defining trait in contrast to Saul. ↩

  18. Ep. 38 notes. The connection between kiddush HaShem and the Lord’s Prayer. ↩

  19. Ep. 38 notes. David’s humble memory and the danger of forgetting where we came from. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.