BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 2 · Week 9 of 40

Episode 41

The Story Behind the Story

David, Solomon, and the Census: Empire Comes Before the Fall

90-minute session 1 Chronicles 17:1–6; 2 Samuel 24:1–3; 1 Chronicles 21:1–3; Deuteronomy 17:14–20; 2 Chronicles 1:14–17; 1 Kings 12:1–15

For group discussion. Listen to episode 41 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Two Tellings of David 25 min
  3. The Mirror Passages 15 min
  4. Solomon and the Price of Empire 25 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 2 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeBookFocus
1 33 Introduction Session 2 Intro
2 34 Joshua The Hardest Story in the Bible (for me)
3 35 Joshua Crossroads of the Earth
4 36 Judges The Redemption Cycle
5 37 Ruth A Love Story
6 38 Samuel A Donkey Herder to Lead Us
7 39 Samuel A King After God’s Own Heart
8 40 Kings & Chronicles One Story, Two Sources
9 41 Kings & Chronicles The Story Behind the Story
10 42 Elijah & Elisha The Fire of Elijah
11 43 Elijah & Elisha Go in Peace
12 44 Psalms Our Harps in the Trees
13 45 Proverbs & Ecclesiastes Wisdom and Meaning
14 46 Song of Songs Song of Sexuality
15 47 The Prophets The Lord’s Mouthpiece
16 48 Amos Plumb Line
17 49 Hosea Garden
18 50 Micah Judge
19 51 Isaiah Vineyard
20 52 Jonah Potential
21 53 Nahum Diyn
22 54 Zephaniah T'shuvah
23 55 Isaiah Woe
24 56 Jeremiah Weeping
25 57 Lamentations Lament and Hope
26 58 Habakkuk Watchtower
27 59 Obadiah Petra
28 60 Joel Locusts
29 61 Ezekiel Strength
30 62 Daniel Son of Man
31 63 Job Perspective
32 64 Isaiah Servant
33 65 Isaiah Hope
34 66 Ezra/Nehemiah Passionate Leadership
35 67 Haggai Build!
36 68 Zechariah Apocalyptic Literature
37 69 Malachi Q&A
38 70 Esther Esther — Purim
39 71 The Prophets The Prophetic Table
40 72 Capstone Session 2 Capstone

Last week: Two sources tell the history of Israel’s kings: Samuel/Kings, “agenda-driven headlines from Israel,” and Chronicles, a “documentary perspective from Judah” written centuries later. Both are accurate, and both are prophetic history meant to move us.

This week: We put the two sources side by side for David and Solomon and discover that they disagree about where the story turned. That disagreement is the point.

About This Session

Samuel/Kings tells the story with an agenda of “Immorality and Idolatry”: David’s sin with Bathsheba and Solomon’s many wives are the turning points. Chronicles, written with centuries of hindsight, has an agenda of “Empire and Injustice.” It leaves out Bathsheba altogether and points instead to David’s wish to build God a temple, to Solomon breaking the kingship laws of Deuteronomy 17, and to the forced labor that made Solomon “a new Pharaoh.”

The episode’s big claim is that lust for Empire leads to moral failure, not the other way around. It does not set the two sources against each other; both are inspired and true. Many of us learned these stories mainly as lessons in personal morality, so this session invites us to hold that lesson alongside a second one about the systems and ambitions we live inside.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a good intention of yours, at work, at church, or at home, that grew into something bigger or heavier than you first planned. How did that happen?

Two Tellings of David 25 min

Chronicles tells David’s story without the scene most of us know best.

Q1: The notes summarize each source’s agenda in a phrase: Samuel/Kings, “Immorality and Idolatry”; Chronicles, “Empire and Injustice.” In Samuel/Kings, the Bathsheba incident is “the definitive turning point,” but Chronicles has “No mention of the Bathsheba incident at all.”1 What is your first reaction to a biblical writer leaving out the story many of us were taught most often? Why might a writer with centuries of hindsight make that choice?

Read 1 Chronicles 17:1–6 aloud.

Q2: In Chronicles the turning point is this request. The notes put David’s reasoning this way: “Why should I live in a palace of cedar while my Lord lives in a tent?” They paraphrase God’s reply as “I like my tent, thank you very much” and “When did I ever ask for a house?” The tent “signifies mobility and presence with the people,” while a fixed temple “implies a fixed, institutionalized God.”2 As you listened, what did you notice about what God says he has and has not done? What does God seem to value about the tent?

Q3: The episode’s central claim is that “lust for Empire leads to moral failure, not vice versa.” After the temple request, the notes say, David “shifts from kiddush hashem to conquest and accumulation.”3 (Kiddush hashem means hallowing God’s name.) Many of us learned David’s fall mainly as a story about one sin. How does reversing the order, Empire first and moral failure second, change the way you think about how good people go wrong?

Q4: Optional The notes observe that “Empire thinking is harder to identify than moral failures because it often comes with good intentions,” since “David genuinely wanted to honor God with a temple.”4 Where might a good intention in your own life, or in a community you love, be quietly building something God never asked for?

The Mirror Passages 15 min

Two accounts of the same census, with one striking difference.

Read 2 Samuel 24:1–3 aloud, then read 1 Chronicles 21:1–3 aloud.

Q5: If you compared these passages this week, share what you found. Listen especially for who incites David, what Joab says, and the order of the place names. The notes point out that in Samuel “The anger of the LORD burned against Israel, and he incited David,” while in Chronicles “Satan rose up against Israel and incited David,” and Joab asks, “Why should he bring guilt on Israel?” Even the geography flips: “Dan to Beersheba” in Samuel, “Beersheba to Dan” in Chronicles.5 What does each version seem most concerned about?

Q6: Optional The notes resolve the tension with “Both/And Thinking”: “Personal morality matters AND systemic justice matters.”6 Every tradition, and every person, tends to lean toward one of these. Which emphasis comes more naturally to you, and what would it take for you to hold both together?

Solomon and the Price of Empire 25 min

The chronicler builds Solomon’s story to echo a warning Moses gave long before.

Read Deuteronomy 17:14–20 aloud, then read 2 Chronicles 1:14–17 aloud.

Q7: The notes say the first chapter of 2 Chronicles “deliberately shows Solomon breaking every kingship law from Deuteronomy 17”: accumulating horses, importing horses from Egypt (“you are not to go back that way again”), taking many wives, and amassing silver and gold.7 Which of the warnings in Deuteronomy did you hear echoed in the Chronicles passage? Why might the chronicler open Solomon’s reign this way?

Read 1 Kings 12:1–15 aloud.

Q8: When Solomon dies, the people beg his son to “loosen the yoke.” The notes conclude that “Building an Empire always comes at a price - paid by the oppressed,” and that Solomon “becomes a new Pharaoh, using slave labor for his building projects.”8 Rehoboam chooses the advice to double down.9 How does a people who were once slaves in Egypt end up running forced labor within a few generations? What makes that slide so hard to see from the inside?

Q9: Optional The notes apply this to church life, comparing the temple project to building campaigns, budgets, and “counting attendees.” They are careful to say “Church buildings and budgets are not inherently wrong (amoral),” but that there is “a persistent temptation to build Empires rather than embody Shalom.”10 Without pointing at any particular church, what questions could help a congregation tell the difference between building for Shalom and building for Empire?

Q10: The notes call us to “continually remember their humble origins,” the “field shepherding sheep” and being “slaves in Egypt,” because “Forgetting these origins leads to becoming Pharaoh ourselves.”11 What is the humble beginning in your own story that you most need to keep remembering, and what helps you remember it?

Closing 15 min

Samuel/Kings tells us that David fell with Bathsheba and Solomon fell through his many wives, and that is true. Chronicles, looking back across centuries, tells us the story behind that story: a king uncomfortable in his palace of cedar who wanted to give God a house, and a son who built an Empire on horses, gold, and forced labor. God preferred the tent, mobile and present with the people. Both sources are inspired, and together they ask us to watch our morals and also the ambitions and systems that shape them. The persistent invitation is to remember where we came from and choose Shalom over Empire.

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one “tent” in your life that you are tempted to turn into a “temple”?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 42 — The Fire of Elijah (47:29): After the kingdom splits, the north sets up golden calves and King Ahab marries Jezebel. The prophet Elijah declares a drought, calls down fire on Mount Carmel, and then flees for his life. At Horeb, God meets him not in wind, earthquake, or fire but in a still small voice, and sends him to make a disciple.

What to bring next week: Read 1 Kings 18:20–39 and 1 Kings 19:9–18. Come ready to share one argument you won that did not actually change anyone’s heart.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “The Story Behind the Story.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 41. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/41. The differing agendas of the two sources, and the omission of the Bathsheba incident from Chronicles. ↩

  2. Ep. 41 notes. David’s temple request in 1 Chronicles 17 and the meaning of God’s preference for the tent. ↩

  3. Ep. 41 notes. Lust for Empire leads to moral failure, and David’s shift away from kiddush hashem after the temple request. ↩

  4. Ep. 41 notes. The subtlety of Empire and the way good intentions can build it. ↩

  5. Ep. 41 notes. The mirror passages of David’s census in 2 Samuel 24 and 1 Chronicles 21. ↩

  6. Ep. 41 notes. Both sources are true, and personal morality and systemic justice both matter. ↩

  7. Ep. 41 notes. 2 Chronicles 1 shows Solomon breaking the kingship laws of Deuteronomy 17. ↩

  8. Ep. 41 notes. The cost of Empire, paid by the oppressed, and Solomon’s use of forced labor. ↩

  9. Ep. 41 notes. Rehoboam follows the younger advisors, and the kingdom splits. ↩

  10. Ep. 41 notes. The application of Solomon’s temple project to modern church building and growth. ↩

  11. Ep. 41 notes. Remembering humble origins so that we do not become Pharaoh. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.