Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- How Have We? 25 min
- A Better Past or New Tomorrows 20 min
- A Scroll of Remembrance 20 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Book | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 33 | Introduction | Session 2 Intro |
| 2 | 34 | Joshua | The Hardest Story in the Bible (for me) |
| 3 | 35 | Joshua | Crossroads of the Earth |
| 4 | 36 | Judges | The Redemption Cycle |
| 5 | 37 | Ruth | A Love Story |
| 6 | 38 | Samuel | A Donkey Herder to Lead Us |
| 7 | 39 | Samuel | A King After God’s Own Heart |
| 8 | 40 | Kings & Chronicles | One Story, Two Sources |
| 9 | 41 | Kings & Chronicles | The Story Behind the Story |
| 10 | 42 | Elijah & Elisha | The Fire of Elijah |
| 11 | 43 | Elijah & Elisha | Go in Peace |
| 12 | 44 | Psalms | Our Harps in the Trees |
| 13 | 45 | Proverbs & Ecclesiastes | Wisdom and Meaning |
| 14 | 46 | Song of Songs | Song of Sexuality |
| 15 | 47 | The Prophets | The Lord’s Mouthpiece |
| 16 | 48 | Amos | Plumb Line |
| 17 | 49 | Hosea | Garden |
| 18 | 50 | Micah | Judge |
| 19 | 51 | Isaiah | Vineyard |
| 20 | 52 | Jonah | Potential |
| 21 | 53 | Nahum | Diyn |
| 22 | 54 | Zephaniah | T'shuvah |
| 23 | 55 | Isaiah | Woe |
| 24 | 56 | Jeremiah | Weeping |
| 25 | 57 | Lamentations | Lament and Hope |
| 26 | 58 | Habakkuk | Watchtower |
| 27 | 59 | Obadiah | Petra |
| 28 | 60 | Joel | Locusts |
| 29 | 61 | Ezekiel | Strength |
| 30 | 62 | Daniel | Son of Man |
| 31 | 63 | Job | Perspective |
| 32 | 64 | Isaiah | Servant |
| 33 | 65 | Isaiah | Hope |
| 34 | 66 | Ezra/Nehemiah | Passionate Leadership |
| 35 | 67 | Haggai | Build! |
| 36 | 68 | Zechariah | Apocalyptic Literature |
| 37 | 69 | Malachi | Q&A |
| 38 | 70 | Esther | Esther — Purim |
| 39 | 71 | The Prophets | The Prophetic Table |
| 40 | 72 | Capstone | Session 2 Capstone |
Last week: Zechariah gave the remnant decades of pictures meant to give hope to people in the present, not timetables. His king on a donkey taught them to walk obediently within empire and wait for rescue through humility and God’s providence.1
This week: Malachi, whose name means “my messenger,” speaks to a community disappointed by the return. God and the people trade questions and answers, and a faithful few respond by writing a scroll of remembrance.2
About This Session
The remnant had come home expecting the glory of the old kingdom, but they were still under Persian rule. The episode, drawing on Walter Brueggemann’s Out of Babylon, describes Persia’s control as longer, wider and more subtle than Babylon’s: a cultural servitude that worked “from the inside out.”3 Disappointed, the people slid into apathy. They offered blind and lame animals, held back their tithes and concluded that it was futile to serve God.4
Malachi exposes this through a distinctive pattern: God makes an accusation, the people respond with a defensive “How have we…?”, and God gives the evidence.5 The episode centers on a question from Rabbi David Fohrman, “Do we imagine new tomorrows or do we lie to ourselves about a better past?”, and Marty shares his own struggle with nostalgia.6 Unlike many prophetic books, Malachi ends with a positive response: a remnant who fear the Lord, talk with each other and are called God’s treasured possession.7
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Think of a season you call “the good old days,” whether in a church, a job, a family or a town. What made it good, and what do you tend to leave out when you remember it?
How Have We? 25 min
Malachi’s dialogue shows a people who honestly cannot see their own drift.
Read Malachi 1:6–8 and Malachi 3:7–10 aloud.
Q1: The notes lay out Malachi’s pattern: God makes an accusation, the people respond with a defensive question, God provides specific evidence, and the cycle repeats.8 Find each step in the two passages you just read. What do you notice about the people’s questions, and what do they suggest about how well the people know themselves?
Q2: The notes contrast later Jewish practice, with its extreme care to offer spotless sacrifices, with the attitude of Malachi’s audience: “A blind goat… who cares. A goat’s a goat. Temple is a temple; path is a path.”9 Brent points out that giving then meant gathering goods and animals and traveling to bring them, and the people’s attitude became, “What? It doesn’t even do any good, so why go to all this effort?”10 The notes say the root issue was not theological confusion but apathy. How does disappointment with outcomes turn into carelessness with practices?
Q3: The notes say Malachi 3:10, the well-known tithing passage, “is often misused as a prosperity formula,” and that in context it is about the consequences of not believing God’s promises and taking an apathetic approach to covenant faithfulness.11 Our churches have taught and practiced giving in different ways, and this verse may carry memories for some of us. How have you heard Malachi 3:10 used, and what changes when you read it as a word to disappointed, apathetic people?
Q4: Optional Where has a disappointing outcome made you half-hearted about a practice that once mattered to you, such as prayer, giving, worship, Scripture or community? What might bringing your best, rather than a “blind goat,” look like there this month?
A Better Past or New Tomorrows 20 min
The people’s apathy grows out of a story they tell themselves about the past.
Read Malachi 3:13–15 aloud.
Q5: In this exchange the people say, “It is futile to serve God. What do we gain? Evildoers prosper.”12 The episode pairs this with Rabbi Fohrman’s question: “Do we imagine new tomorrows or do we lie to ourselves about a better past?” and with a fundamental truth: “You can’t go backwards, you can only go forward.”13 How does a romanticized past make the present feel futile, and what would it take for Malachi’s audience to imagine a new tomorrow instead?
Q6: Marty describes friends who were miserable in an old setting, moved somewhere challenging and began remembering the old place as “the good old days.” He admits he has felt the same pull toward “how it was four years ago,” and says: “When I begin to believe this [nostalgia], I start to live much more poorly in the present. I get a lot more cynical, jaded, bitter and angry. I fall into bad attitudes and bad habits. I find myself beginning to fall into sins of the past.”14 Where do you recognize that pattern, in yourself or in a community you love, and what helps break it?
Q7: Optional The notes describe Persia’s control as cultural rather than physical: not robbing possessions but robbing identity as God’s partners, enticing people into a system of control.15 The episode applies this to us: “It’s harder to fight the idolatry present in our Western American culture than outright idolatry because it’s more subtle and hidden and internal.”16 What is one subtle way our culture shapes you “from the inside out,” and how would you notice it?
A Scroll of Remembrance 20 min
Malachi’s message lands, and a few people respond.
Read Malachi 3:16–18 aloud.
Q8: The notes say the faithful remnant heard the message, “Feared the Lord and talked with each other,” wrote a “scroll of remembrance,” and were called God’s “treasured possession,” echoing the language of the Exodus covenant.17 What do you notice about what this group actually does, and why might talking with each other be part of the response?
Q9: The episode closes with a theme it finds throughout Scripture, that small groups of committed people can change everything, pointing to the 7,000 who had not bowed to Baal in Elijah’s day and to this remnant.18 It describes our moment as a culture “dominated by debate and argument and bifurcated worldviews” that “seems to be beyond hope,” and says a few people putting their names on a scroll can still make a difference.19 What would it look like for this group to put our names on a scroll, and what would we be committing to?
Q10: Optional The notes list the remnant’s examples alongside Elijah’s 7,000 as proof that a faithful few can matter.20 Who has been part of a faithful few for you, people who kept walking the path when others lost heart, and what did their faithfulness make possible in your life?
Closing 15 min
Malachi’s people came home and found that the glory they expected had not arrived. Living under a quieter empire, they grew disappointed and then apathetic, offering blind goats and asking, “How have we…?” when God named it. The episode asks whether we will imagine new tomorrows or lie to ourselves about a better past, because we cannot go backwards. A small remnant chose to fear the Lord, talk with each other and write their names on a scroll, and God called them his treasured possession.21
Closing Question: In one sentence each, name one thing from “the good old days” you want to stop going back to, or one new tomorrow you want to imagine.
Looking Ahead
Ep. 70 — Esther — Purim (34:43): A story written for the Jews who stayed in Persia rather than returning. Esther never names God, yet God seems present throughout, and the episode follows Rabbi David Fohrman in tracing Esther’s parallels to Joseph, her shrewd wisdom before the king, and Mordecai’s challenge that silence in the face of injustice is complicity.22
What to bring next week: Read Esther 4. Notice Mordecai’s argument to Esther and Esther’s reply, and come ready to say which line strikes you most and why.
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Zechariah — Apocalyptic Literature.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 68. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/68. Apocalyptic literature conveys hope to its present audience, and Zechariah 9:9–10 encouraged the remnant to walk obediently within empire. ↩
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Malachi — Q&A.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 69. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/69. Malachi means “my messenger,” uses a question-and-answer format, and ends with the faithful remnant’s scroll of remembrance. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The post-exilic disappointment and Persian cultural servitude, with the notes citing Walter Brueggemann, Out of Babylon. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Defective sacrifices, withheld tithes and the claim that “it’s futile to serve God.” ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The four-step Q&A dialogue structure. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Rabbi Fohrman’s question about new tomorrows and a better past, and Marty’s personal struggle with nostalgia. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The faithful remnant’s positive response. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The pattern of accusation, defensive question and evidence, which reveals the people’s spiritual blindness. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The contrast between later Jewish care for spotless sacrifices and the apathy of Malachi’s audience. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Brent’s observation about the effort giving required and the people’s attitude. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Malachi 3:10 in context as a word about apathy, not a prosperity formula. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The fourth exchange, Malachi 3:13–15. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Rabbi Fohrman’s question and the truth that we can only go forward. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Marty’s account of nostalgia and its effects on present living. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Persian control as cultural rather than physical servitude. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The modern application to Western culture’s subtle idolatry. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The remnant’s response in Malachi 3:16–18 and its echo of Exodus covenant language. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The power of the few, including the 7,000 in Elijah’s time. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. The application to a divided contemporary culture. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Small groups of committed people can change everything, as with the 7,000 and the remnant in Malachi. ↩
-
Ep. 69 notes. Summary of disappointment, nostalgia, apathy and the remnant’s response. ↩
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Esther — Purim.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 70. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/70. Esther’s audience in Persia, God’s hiddenness, the Joseph parallels, Esther’s strategy and Mordecai’s ethical challenge, drawing on Rabbi David Fohrman. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.