BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 4 · Week 7 of 57

Episode 140

Not to Burden You

Acts 15: The Jerusalem Council and the Practice of Binding and Loosing

90-minute session Acts 15:1–41; Genesis 9:1–7; Genesis 15:6; Amos 9:11–12; Matthew 16:19

For group discussion. Listen to episode 140 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Three Kinds of Law 20 min
  3. Binding and Loosing in Jerusalem 30 min
  4. Agreement, Then a Sharp Disagreement 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 4 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeBookFocus
1 134 Introduction Session 4 Intro
2 135 Acts Uncut Corners
3 136 Acts Each One
4 137 Acts A Dry Tree
5 138 Acts Unclean Sheets
6 139 Acts Theosabes
7 140 Acts Not to Burden You
8 141 Acts Mathetes or Talmidim?
9 142 Acts Calling of a Prophet
10 143 Acts The Epilogue
11 144 Galatians Paul’s Gospel
12 145 Galatians Right Hand of Fellowship
13 146 Galatians The Curse
14 147 Galatians Two Women, Two Covenants
15 148 Galatians Set Free to Be Free
16 149 Romans Blended Family
17 150 Romans Righteousness from God
18 151 Romans Buried Alive
19 152 Romans The Struggle
20 153 Romans The Potter
21 154 Romans Therefore
22 155 Romans God’s Mission, Paul’s Mission
23 156 1 Corinthians Broken Body
24 157 2 Corinthians Apostleship
25 158 Ephesians Family Membership
26 159 Philippians Joy
27 160 Colossians Gnostic Heresy
28 161 1 Thessalonians Parousia
29 162 2 Thessalonians Man of Lawlessness
30 163 Pastoral Epistles Timid Timothy & Tough Titus
31 164 Philemon Faith Works
32 165 Hebrews Running a Better Race
33 166 Hebrews Atonement 101
34 167 James Mitzvoth
35 168 1 Peter Living Stones and a Spiritual House
36 169 2 Peter The Other Side of a Conversation
37 170 1 John Love and Truth
38 171 2 John The “Woman”
39 172 3 John Diotrephes
40 173 Jude False Teachers
41 174 Revelation A Book for Its Time
42 175 Revelation Ephesus and Their First Love
43 176 Revelation Smyrna and Their Crown
44 177 Revelation Pergamum and Satan’s Throne
45 178 Revelation Thyatira and Her Jezebel
46 179 Revelation Waking Up in Sardis
47 180 Revelation Philadelphia and Their New Name
48 181 Revelation Lukewarm Laodicea
49 182 Revelation The Throne Room
50 183 Revelation Seals from Scripture
51 184 Revelation Let the Games Begin
52 185 Revelation Bittersweet Prophecy
53 186 Revelation Mother and Dragons
54 187 Revelation The Blessed and Faithful Fallen
55 188 Revelation The Fall of Greatness
56 189 Revelation The End Is a New Beginning
57 190 Capstone Session 4 Capstone

Last week: In Pisidian Antioch, Paul spoke to brothers, converts and God-fearers. The episode argued that opposition came less from rejecting Jesus than from discomfort when Gentiles filled the synagogue.

This week: The question finally comes to Jerusalem. Must Gentile believers become Jewish to belong fully to God’s household?

About This Session

The episode gives the group a framework for the whole session ahead. Second Temple Judaism, Marty explains, recognized three kinds of law: cultic law tied to the temple, ethical law true for everyone, and miqsat ma’asay haTorah (“works of the law”), the practices that made a person distinctly Jewish. The council’s debate was about that third category. The notes credit the Dead Sea Scrolls and the “New Perspective on Paul” with correcting centuries of reading Paul through later Western lenses.

The council itself is presented as a model of binding and loosing, a Jewish practice of deciding gray areas as a community that Jesus endorsed in Matthew 16. Peter speaks from his experience with Cornelius, James draws on Amos and on the covenant with Noah, and Paul stays surprisingly quiet. The letter that results says it “seemed good to the Holy Spirit” and to the leaders not to burden the Gentiles. Then, almost immediately, Paul and Barnabas have a sharp disagreement and part ways. Because this episode touches how churches make decisions and why they split, every tradition in the room will find something to recognize.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a time a group you belonged to had to make a hard decision together. What helped the group decide well, or what got in the way?

Three Kinds of Law 20 min

Before we hear the council’s decision, the episode clarifies what exactly was being debated.

Read Acts 15:1–5 aloud.

Q1: Notice exactly what is being required of the Gentile believers, and who is requiring it. How would you put the question in your own words?

Q2: The episode explains three categories of law recognized in the Second Temple period:1

  • Cultic law: requirements tied to the temple and altar, such as sacrifices and the priesthood. Christians believe Jesus fulfills this category.
  • Ethical law: principles true for everyone “because of how God designed the universe to function.”
  • Miqsat ma’asay haTorah (“works of the law”): practices that make a person distinctly Jewish, such as circumcision, kosher eating, wearing tassels and cleanliness laws, given to make Israel “a kingdom of priests.”

The notes say the central debate was whether this third category is “required for justification.”2 How does this framework change your sense of what Acts 15 is arguing about? Which category had you assumed it was about?

Q3: Optional The notes say the Dead Sea Scrolls “revolutionized understanding of Second Temple Judaism and Paul’s writings,” and that the New Perspective on Paul “corrected centuries of misreading Paul through later Western theological lenses.”3 What is one thing you were taught about “works of the law” that you would like to test as we move into Galatians and Romans?

Q4: The works of the law were good gifts that marked Israel as distinct. Christian traditions also have practices that mark who we are. Name one distinctive practice in your own tradition that you value. How do you keep it a gift for your community rather than a requirement you place on others before they can belong?

Binding and Loosing in Jerusalem 30 min

The council listens to experience and to Scripture, and reaches a decision it attributes to the Spirit and to themselves.

Read Acts 15:6–21 aloud.

Q5: Notice who speaks, in what order, and what each one appeals to. The notes describe Peter leading “with personal experience (Cornelius),” James representing “the most Jewish perspective” yet championing inclusion, and Paul as “surprisingly quiet during the council,” even though he was the issue’s catalyst.4 What do you notice about how the decision is reached?

Q6: Optional The episode explains that the school of Shammai required Gentiles to convert, while the school of Hillel held that justification comes by faith, like Abraham in Genesis 15. The notes say the council “sided with Hillel but went even further toward full inclusion.”5

Read Genesis 15:6 aloud.

Why would Abraham be such a natural example for this debate?

Q7: The notes explain that James’s requirements drew on the covenant with Noah, which applied to all humanity: no idolatry, sexual purity, and the sanctity of life (no blood, nothing strangled).6

Read Genesis 9:1–7 and Acts 15:28–29 aloud.

What connections do you notice? Why might a covenant made with all humanity be a fitting basis for what Gentiles were asked to do?

Q8: Binding (restricting or requiring) and loosing (permitting or releasing) was a Jewish process for deciding gray areas “where Scripture doesn’t give explicit direction,” and Jesus endorsed it in Matthew 16.7 The notes suggest the phrase “it seemed good to the Holy Spirit” means God “participates in community discernment rather than dictating absolute positions on gray areas.”8 Our traditions handle authority and decision-making quite differently, and none of them is being singled out here. How does your tradition decide questions Scripture does not settle explicitly? What would it look like for your church to reach a decision together that it could honestly say “seemed good to the Holy Spirit”?

Agreement, Then a Sharp Disagreement 15 min

Even after the council, faithful leaders could not agree on what to do next.

Read Acts 15:36–41 aloud.

Q9: Optional Notice what Paul and Barnabas disagree about, and what they do not disagree about. The notes observe that “even apostolic leaders like Paul and Barnabas struggled with implementation despite theological agreement.”9 What does this scene suggest about the difference between agreeing on the gospel and agreeing on how to carry it out?

Q10: The notes say denominational splits often result from poor binding and loosing, decisions made “out of ignorance,” and that “healthy disagreement requires respecting community decisions while maintaining dialogue.”10 Four traditions are represented in this room, each with its own history of agreements and divisions. Think of a disagreement you are part of right now, in church, family or work. What would it look like to disagree well in it this week?

Closing 15 min

The Jerusalem Council was not deciding whether Gentiles should be ethical or whether Jesus fulfilled the temple; it was deciding whether the practices that made Israel distinct were required for Gentiles to belong. Peter brought his experience, James brought Amos and the covenant with Noah, and the community reached a decision it believed seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to them. They chose not to burden the Gentiles. And then Paul and Barnabas, agreed on the gospel, parted over a person, a reminder that unity and disagreement can live in the same room.

Closing Question: In one sentence each: what is one burden you could stop placing on someone else?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 141 — Mathetes or Talmidim? (38:57): Right after the council, Paul circumcises Timothy, and the episode argues that this apparent contradiction reveals a consistent gospel of inclusion. It follows Paul to Athens and through his later journeys, contrasting the Greek word for disciple with the Hebrew talmid and tracing how Paul’s ministry shifted from spreading the message widely to making disciples.

What to bring next week: Read Acts 16:1–5, Acts 17:16–34, and Acts 19:1–10. Notice how many disciples are mentioned in Acts 19:7, and think about who has shaped your life by letting you follow them closely.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Not to Burden You.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 140. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/140. The three categories of Jewish law in the Second Temple period. ↩

  2. Ep. 140 notes. The central debate over whether the works of the law are required for justification. ↩

  3. Ep. 140 notes. The Dead Sea Scrolls and the New Perspective on Paul. ↩

  4. Ep. 140 notes. Peter, James and Paul at the council. ↩

  5. Ep. 140 notes. The Shammai and Hillel debate and the council’s decision. ↩

  6. Ep. 140 notes. The Noahic covenant as the framework for James’s requirements. ↩

  7. Ep. 140 notes. Binding and loosing and Matthew 16. ↩

  8. Ep. 140 notes. “It seemed good to the Holy Spirit” and community discernment. ↩

  9. Ep. 140 notes. Paul and Barnabas’s disagreement after the council. ↩

  10. Ep. 140 notes. Denominational splits and healthy disagreement. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.