BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 4 · Week 20 of 57

Episode 153

Romans — The Potter

Romans 8:28–11:36: Predestination, Mercy and the Grafted Olive Tree

90-minute session Romans 8:28–30; Romans 9:19–24; Romans 10:9–13; Romans 11:1–5; Romans 11:17–29

For group discussion. Listen to episode 153 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Predestined: A First-Century Hearing 20 min
  3. The Potter’s Mercy 25 min
  4. Grafted In, Not Replacing 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 4 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeBookFocus
1 134 Introduction Session 4 Intro
2 135 Acts Uncut Corners
3 136 Acts Each One
4 137 Acts A Dry Tree
5 138 Acts Unclean Sheets
6 139 Acts Theosabes
7 140 Acts Not to Burden You
8 141 Acts Mathetes or Talmidim?
9 142 Acts Calling of a Prophet
10 143 Acts The Epilogue
11 144 Galatians Paul’s Gospel
12 145 Galatians Right Hand of Fellowship
13 146 Galatians The Curse
14 147 Galatians Two Women, Two Covenants
15 148 Galatians Set Free to Be Free
16 149 Romans Blended Family
17 150 Romans Righteousness from God
18 151 Romans Buried Alive
19 152 Romans The Struggle
20 153 Romans The Potter
21 154 Romans Therefore
22 155 Romans God’s Mission, Paul’s Mission
23 156 1 Corinthians Broken Body
24 157 2 Corinthians Apostleship
25 158 Ephesians Family Membership
26 159 Philippians Joy
27 160 Colossians Gnostic Heresy
28 161 1 Thessalonians Parousia
29 162 2 Thessalonians Man of Lawlessness
30 163 Pastoral Epistles Timid Timothy & Tough Titus
31 164 Philemon Faith Works
32 165 Hebrews Running a Better Race
33 166 Hebrews Atonement 101
34 167 James Mitzvoth
35 168 1 Peter Living Stones and a Spiritual House
36 169 2 Peter The Other Side of a Conversation
37 170 1 John Love and Truth
38 171 2 John The “Woman”
39 172 3 John Diotrephes
40 173 Jude False Teachers
41 174 Revelation A Book for Its Time
42 175 Revelation Ephesus and Their First Love
43 176 Revelation Smyrna and Their Crown
44 177 Revelation Pergamum and Satan’s Throne
45 178 Revelation Thyatira and Her Jezebel
46 179 Revelation Waking Up in Sardis
47 180 Revelation Philadelphia and Their New Name
48 181 Revelation Lukewarm Laodicea
49 182 Revelation The Throne Room
50 183 Revelation Seals from Scripture
51 184 Revelation Let the Games Begin
52 185 Revelation Bittersweet Prophecy
53 186 Revelation Mother and Dragons
54 187 Revelation The Blessed and Faithful Fallen
55 188 Revelation The Fall of Greatness
56 189 Revelation The End Is a New Beginning
57 190 Capstone Session 4 Capstone

Last week: Paul pictured our freedom through slavery and marriage, named the real struggle between image-bearer and appetite, and ended in the assurance that there is no condemnation and nothing can separate us from God’s love.

This week: Paul takes up the hardest questions his blended family was asking: what predestination means, whether God may show mercy to outsiders, and what becomes of Israel now that Gentiles are coming in.

About This Session

This is the longest episode in the Romans series, and it covers some of the most debated chapters in the Bible. The episode reads predestination in Romans 8 through the first-century oracle system, where a predestined outcome depended on the worshipper’s obedience.1 It reads the potter and the clay in Romans 9 as a picture of God’s prerogative to show mercy, not to reject, and it argues that Romans 9–11 is primarily a defense of Gentile inclusion in God’s covenant family.2

The episode then turns to the olive tree of Romans 11. It argues firmly against replacement theology, the idea that the church replaced Israel: Gentiles are wild branches grafted into Israel’s tree, and God’s gifts and calling to Israel are irrevocable.3 Our traditions have taught different things about election and predestination, so this session is a place to hear one another, not to settle the debate.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a group you joined (a team, a family, a church, a workplace) where others had been there long before you. What helped you feel you belonged, and what made you feel like a guest?

Predestined: A First-Century Hearing 20 min

The episode asks how Paul’s first readers would have heard the word “predestined.”

Read Romans 8:28–30 aloud.

Q1: Trace the chain of verbs in verses 29 and 30. What does God do at each step, and where does the chain end? What purpose does verse 29 give for it all?

Q2: The notes explain that first-century people consulted oracles, such as those at Delphi or Didyma, and that the formula was conditional: “If you offer X sacrifice, and if you do Y, then it is predestined that Z will happen.”4 In that world, “predestination was contingent upon obedience,” so the episode concludes that Paul’s discussion “assumes the believer’s choice to follow God’s plan.”5 How does hearing “predestined” in that setting change the way verses 28–30 sound to you?

Q3: Optional Each of our traditions has a history with this word. Some emphasize God’s sovereign choice, others human response, and many hold both together in tension. What were you taught about predestination, how did that teaching shape your faith, and what in the oracle reading do you find helpful, troubling or unconvincing?

Q4: Verse 28 is often quoted on its own in hard seasons. Read in light of verse 29, what kind of “good” is God working toward? Where do you need to trust that purpose right now?

The Potter’s Mercy 25 min

Paul answers the objection that God has no right to welcome the outsider.

Read Romans 9:19–24 aloud.

Q5: Who seems to be raising the objection in verse 19? In verses 22 and 23, what does the potter do with the vessels “prepared for destruction,” and what does he do with the vessels of mercy? Who does verse 24 say the vessels of mercy include?

Q6: The notes say the potter metaphor “doesn’t focus on God’s rejection but on His prerogative to show mercy,” and that “Vessels prepared for destruction” refers to pagan Gentiles whom God bore “with great patience” rather than destroying, ultimately showing them mercy.6 They sum up: “Paul’s argument focuses on God’s acceptance and mercy, not rejection or exclusion.”7 Many of us learned this passage as being about God choosing some individuals and not others. What happens to the passage if its main question is whether God may show mercy to the outsider?

Read Romans 10:9–13 aloud.

Q7: Optional The notes say Paul appropriated a Roman imperial slogan, “If you proclaim with your mouth that Caesar is Lord, you will be saved,” and turned it toward Jesus, showing how the gospel “directly challenges political and cultural power structures.”8 Notice who verses 12 and 13 include. What would it have cost a believer in Rome to say “Jesus is Lord” out loud?

Q8: The notes describe God as “the divine Potter who specializes in showing mercy to vessels others might consider worthless.”9 Who are the people you, or your church, might be tempted to treat as vessels for destruction? What would God’s patience toward them look like in practice?

Grafted In, Not Replacing 20 min

Paul uses an olive tree to describe how Gentiles relate to Israel.

Read Romans 11:1–5 aloud, then Romans 11:17–29.

Q9: In verses 17–24, which branches are natural and which are wild? What supports what (look at verse 18)? What warning does Paul give the wild branches in verses 18–21? Then notice how verses 28 and 29 describe Israel.

Q10: The notes point out that the grafting “goes against nature - wild branches would typically harm a cultivated tree’s productivity,” which shows the scandal of God’s grace.10 The episode states that “replacement theology is incorrect” and that Gentiles “are grafted into the existing covenant community of Israel,” adding that the translation “in this way all Israel will be saved” (rather than “and so”) is crucial.11 Where have you heard the church described as having replaced Israel, and how does Paul’s picture of a single tree with one root challenge that?

Q11: Optional Paul recalls Elijah and the seven thousand who had not bowed to Baal. The notes draw out the principle that “God always maintains a faithful remnant” and is “always working through people willing to partner with His redemptive purposes.”12 Where have you seen a faithful remnant keep something alive when it looked lost?

Q12: The episode encourages “examining our own religious arrogance and exclusivity,” and the notes say God’s people are called to be “ambassadors of this radical inclusion rather than gatekeepers of exclusive privilege.”13 Paul tells the grafted branches not to boast. Where are you most tempted to act as a gatekeeper, and what would one act of welcome look like this week?

Closing 15 min

In Romans 9–11, Paul is not writing an abstract treatise on who is chosen; he is defending God’s freedom to show mercy to outsiders in a divided church. Predestination, heard through the oracles of his day, assumes a people who choose to follow God’s plan. The potter shows patience and mercy to vessels others had written off. And the Gentiles are wild branches grafted into Israel’s own tree, supported by its root, with no grounds to boast, because God’s gifts and calling to Israel are irrevocable.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: who is one person or group you want to stop gatekeeping and start welcoming?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 154 — Romans — Therefore (18:27): Paul’s great hinge in Romans 12:1, where eleven chapters about God’s mercy to everyone become a call to live as one living sacrifice. The episode covers love in the body of Christ, toward governing authorities and toward enemies, including what it means to heap burning coals on an enemy’s head.

What to bring next week: Read Romans 12 in one sitting. Choose one command from verses 9–21 that you find hardest to live, and bring it with you.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Romans — The Potter.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 153. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/153. Predestination read through the first-century oracle system. ↩

  2. Ep. 153 notes. The potter metaphor and Romans 9–11 as a defense of Gentile inclusion. ↩

  3. Ep. 153 notes. The olive tree, replacement theology and Israel’s irrevocable calling. ↩

  4. Ep. 153 notes. The oracle formula and the oracles at Delphi and Didyma. ↩

  5. Ep. 153 notes. Predestination contingent upon obedience. ↩

  6. Ep. 153 notes. The potter and clay metaphor (Romans 9:19–24). ↩

  7. Ep. 153 notes. Paul’s focus on acceptance and mercy. ↩

  8. Ep. 153 notes. The Roman imperial slogan and “Jesus is Lord.” ↩

  9. Ep. 153 notes. God as the divine Potter. ↩

  10. Ep. 153 notes. The grafting process goes against nature. ↩

  11. Ep. 153 notes. Replacement theology versus grafting theology. ↩

  12. Ep. 153 notes. The remnant principle. ↩

  13. Ep. 153 notes. Religious arrogance and the call to be ambassadors of inclusion. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.