BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 4 · Week 8 of 57

Episode 141

Mathetes or Talmidim?

Acts 16–20: From Spreading the Message to Making Disciples

90-minute session Acts 16:1–5; Acts 17:10–34; Acts 18:1–11; Acts 19:1–10

For group discussion. Listen to episode 141 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Whoever Is Being Pushed Out 20 min
  3. Finding Truth in Athens 25 min
  4. Students or Disciples? 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 4 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeBookFocus
1 134 Introduction Session 4 Intro
2 135 Acts Uncut Corners
3 136 Acts Each One
4 137 Acts A Dry Tree
5 138 Acts Unclean Sheets
6 139 Acts Theosabes
7 140 Acts Not to Burden You
8 141 Acts Mathetes or Talmidim?
9 142 Acts Calling of a Prophet
10 143 Acts The Epilogue
11 144 Galatians Paul’s Gospel
12 145 Galatians Right Hand of Fellowship
13 146 Galatians The Curse
14 147 Galatians Two Women, Two Covenants
15 148 Galatians Set Free to Be Free
16 149 Romans Blended Family
17 150 Romans Righteousness from God
18 151 Romans Buried Alive
19 152 Romans The Struggle
20 153 Romans The Potter
21 154 Romans Therefore
22 155 Romans God’s Mission, Paul’s Mission
23 156 1 Corinthians Broken Body
24 157 2 Corinthians Apostleship
25 158 Ephesians Family Membership
26 159 Philippians Joy
27 160 Colossians Gnostic Heresy
28 161 1 Thessalonians Parousia
29 162 2 Thessalonians Man of Lawlessness
30 163 Pastoral Epistles Timid Timothy & Tough Titus
31 164 Philemon Faith Works
32 165 Hebrews Running a Better Race
33 166 Hebrews Atonement 101
34 167 James Mitzvoth
35 168 1 Peter Living Stones and a Spiritual House
36 169 2 Peter The Other Side of a Conversation
37 170 1 John Love and Truth
38 171 2 John The “Woman”
39 172 3 John Diotrephes
40 173 Jude False Teachers
41 174 Revelation A Book for Its Time
42 175 Revelation Ephesus and Their First Love
43 176 Revelation Smyrna and Their Crown
44 177 Revelation Pergamum and Satan’s Throne
45 178 Revelation Thyatira and Her Jezebel
46 179 Revelation Waking Up in Sardis
47 180 Revelation Philadelphia and Their New Name
48 181 Revelation Lukewarm Laodicea
49 182 Revelation The Throne Room
50 183 Revelation Seals from Scripture
51 184 Revelation Let the Games Begin
52 185 Revelation Bittersweet Prophecy
53 186 Revelation Mother and Dragons
54 187 Revelation The Blessed and Faithful Fallen
55 188 Revelation The Fall of Greatness
56 189 Revelation The End Is a New Beginning
57 190 Capstone Session 4 Capstone

Last week: The Jerusalem Council distinguished the works of the law that made Israel distinct from what was required of Gentiles, and chose not to burden them. Then Paul and Barnabas, agreed on the gospel, parted ways over Mark.

This week: Paul’s second and third journeys. A surprising circumcision, a speech in Athens, and a quiet shift in how Paul spends his time.

About This Session

The episode opens with what looks like a contradiction. Right after the council decides Gentiles need not be circumcised, Paul circumcises Timothy. Marty argues that both actions come from the same conviction: the gospel welcomes “whoever is being pushed out.” In Athens, Paul begins with affirmation, quotes the Greeks’ own poets, and uses their altar to an unknown god as a bridge, an approach the notes connect to the conviction that truth can be found everywhere.

The title comes from a language problem. The Greek New Testament uses one word, mathetes, for everything from a casual student to a committed disciple, while Hebrew distinguishes a limud (as the notes describe it, a student who attends and learns) from a talmid (a disciple who commits years to imitating a rabbi’s whole life). The episode traces Paul’s journeys from zero disciples on the first, to three on the second, to “about twelve” on the third, mirroring Jesus, and asks whether disciple-making is more central to God’s mission than church planting alone.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of someone who shaped your life not mainly by what they taught you but by letting you watch how they lived. What did you pick up from them?

Whoever Is Being Pushed Out 20 min

Right after the council, Paul does something that seems to undo it.

Read Acts 16:1–5 aloud.

Q1: Notice what Luke tells us about Timothy’s family, what Paul does, and what Paul and Timothy then deliver to the churches (verse 4). What makes this scene surprising, coming right after Acts 15?

Q2: Optional The notes describe Timothy as “a mamzer - illegitimate child,” excluded from circumcision “due to his mixed heritage.” The episode rejects the common explanation that Paul was simply avoiding offense to Jews, calling Timothy’s circumcision “not cultural accommodation but radical welcome.”1 How does that reading change the way you see Paul’s decision?

Q3: The notes resolve the apparent contradiction this way: when Gentiles were excluded for being uncircumcised, Paul said they did not need it; when Timothy was excluded from circumcision, Paul circumcised him. “The Gospel reverses whatever forces people to be outsiders,” and its message is that “whoever is being pushed out is welcome in.”2 Think about your church, family or circle of friends. Who is being pushed out right now, and in which direction would welcome have to move to bring them in?

Finding Truth in Athens 25 min

Paul engages one of the most sophisticated audiences in the ancient world, and he begins by listening.

Read Acts 17:16–28 aloud.

Q4: Notice how Paul begins his speech, what he points to in the city, and whom he quotes. The notes say Paul “begins with affirmation rather than confrontation,” “studies and quotes their poets and philosophers,” and uses “their own religious symbols (altar to unknown god) as conversation bridges.”3 What do you notice about the tone of this speech compared to the city that distressed him in verse 16?

Q5: Optional The notes hold up the Jews of Berea as a “model of noble character through eager reception and careful Scripture examination.”4

Read Acts 17:10–12 aloud.

What two qualities does Luke praise in the Bereans? Which of the two comes more naturally to you?

Q6: The episode teaches that “truth can be found everywhere and should be utilized wherever discovered.” The notes apply this to “secular philosophy, non-Christian religions, popular culture - as all truth belongs to God,” while also naming the need to balance “truth recognition with doctrinal discernment.”5 Our traditions draw these lines in different places. Where have you found something true in an unexpected place? How do you hold that alongside discernment?

Students or Disciples? 20 min

A single Greek word hides a distinction that shaped how Jesus and Paul made followers.

Q7: The episode contrasts three terms:6

  • Mathetes (Greek): a general term covering everything from casual student to committed disciple.
  • Limud (Hebrew, as the notes use it): a student who attends classes and learns but does not commit to imitating the teacher’s life.
  • Talmid (Hebrew): a disciple who commits years to following a rabbi, imitating every aspect of the rabbi’s life.

It then traces Paul’s journeys: on the first, zero disciples and zero house churches; on the second, three disciples (Timothy, Priscilla and Aquila) and one house church; on the third, about twelve disciples and multiple house churches.7

Read Acts 18:1–4 and Acts 19:1–10 aloud.

Notice who Paul lives and works alongside, how long he stays, and how many people Luke mentions in Acts 19:7. What do you notice about how Paul’s ministry has changed?

Q8: Optional The notes call attention to “Luke’s deliberate paralleling of Paul’s ministry with Jesus’ ministry,” including the “about twelve disciples” detail, and conclude that “disciple-making appears more central to God’s mission than church planting alone.”8 What would change if a church measured its health by the disciples it was forming rather than by its attendance or the number of churches it started?

Q9: The notes end with a challenge: “are we making mathetes or talmidim?”9 Where are you a student of Jesus, attending and learning, and where are you a disciple, imitating his life? Who is one person who could follow you closely enough to learn from how you live?

Closing 15 min

Paul’s actions around circumcision only look inconsistent until we see what drives them: whoever is being pushed out is welcome in. In Athens he begins by listening and affirming, trusting that truth found in the culture can point beyond itself. And across his journeys he moves from spreading the message widely to investing in a small number of people who live alongside him, about twelve, like Jesus. The question the episode leaves us with is personal: are we making students, or disciples?

Closing Question: In one sentence each: who is one person you will invest in more deeply this month?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 142 — Calling of a Prophet (21:54): The episode returns to the question from Unclean Sheets about whether Paul’s Damascus road experience was a conversion. Looking closely at Paul’s retelling to King Agrippa in Acts 26, Marty argues that the added details deliberately echo the callings of Jonah, Ezekiel, Jeremiah and Isaiah, so that Paul presents himself as a prophet called to bring light to the Gentiles.

What to bring next week: Read Acts 26:12–18 and Jeremiah 1:4–5. Write down any words or images in Paul’s account that remind you of a prophet’s story you already know.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Mathetes or Talmidim?” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 141. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/141. Timothy as a mamzer and his circumcision as radical welcome. ↩

  2. Ep. 141 notes. The gospel of inclusion and the reversal of whatever makes people outsiders. ↩

  3. Ep. 141 notes. Paul’s contextual approach in Athens. ↩

  4. Ep. 141 notes. The Berean Jews as a model. ↩

  5. Ep. 141 notes. Truth recognition and doctrinal discernment. ↩

  6. Ep. 141 notes. The mathetes, limud and talmid framework. ↩

  7. Ep. 141 notes. The evolution of Paul’s ministry across three journeys. ↩

  8. Ep. 141 notes. Luke’s parallel between Paul and Jesus, and disciple-making over church planting. ↩

  9. Ep. 141 notes. The closing challenge of mathetes or talmidim. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.