BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 4 · Week 33 of 57

Episode 166

Hebrews — Atonement 101

Hebrews 9–10: Many Pictures of the Cross, and a Cleansed Conscience

90-minute session Hebrews 8:13; Hebrews 9:11–14; Hebrews 10:1–14; Leviticus 16:20–22

For group discussion. Listen to episode 166 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Clubs in the Bag 25 min
  3. What the Blood Is For 25 min
  4. Temple, Priest, and Sacrifice 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 4 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeBookFocus
1 134 Introduction Session 4 Intro
2 135 Acts Uncut Corners
3 136 Acts Each One
4 137 Acts A Dry Tree
5 138 Acts Unclean Sheets
6 139 Acts Theosabes
7 140 Acts Not to Burden You
8 141 Acts Mathetes or Talmidim?
9 142 Acts Calling of a Prophet
10 143 Acts The Epilogue
11 144 Galatians Paul’s Gospel
12 145 Galatians Right Hand of Fellowship
13 146 Galatians The Curse
14 147 Galatians Two Women, Two Covenants
15 148 Galatians Set Free to Be Free
16 149 Romans Blended Family
17 150 Romans Righteousness from God
18 151 Romans Buried Alive
19 152 Romans The Struggle
20 153 Romans The Potter
21 154 Romans Therefore
22 155 Romans God’s Mission, Paul’s Mission
23 156 1 Corinthians Broken Body
24 157 2 Corinthians Apostleship
25 158 Ephesians Family Membership
26 159 Philippians Joy
27 160 Colossians Gnostic Heresy
28 161 1 Thessalonians Parousia
29 162 2 Thessalonians Man of Lawlessness
30 163 Pastoral Epistles Timid Timothy & Tough Titus
31 164 Philemon Faith Works
32 165 Hebrews Running a Better Race
33 166 Hebrews Atonement 101
34 167 James Mitzvoth
35 168 1 Peter Living Stones and a Spiritual House
36 169 2 Peter The Other Side of a Conversation
37 170 1 John Love and Truth
38 171 2 John The “Woman”
39 172 3 John Diotrephes
40 173 Jude False Teachers
41 174 Revelation A Book for Its Time
42 175 Revelation Ephesus and Their First Love
43 176 Revelation Smyrna and Their Crown
44 177 Revelation Pergamum and Satan’s Throne
45 178 Revelation Thyatira and Her Jezebel
46 179 Revelation Waking Up in Sardis
47 180 Revelation Philadelphia and Their New Name
48 181 Revelation Lukewarm Laodicea
49 182 Revelation The Throne Room
50 183 Revelation Seals from Scripture
51 184 Revelation Let the Games Begin
52 185 Revelation Bittersweet Prophecy
53 186 Revelation Mother and Dragons
54 187 Revelation The Blessed and Faithful Fallen
55 188 Revelation The Fall of Greatness
56 189 Revelation The End Is a New Beginning
57 190 Capstone Session 4 Capstone

Last week: We met Hebrews as a sermon for Jewish believers after the temple’s destruction, bracketed by the line “He sat down at the right hand of God” (1:3 and 10:12). Inside that bracket, Jesus is the merciful and faithful high priest who shows us how to persevere through suffering.

This week: We stay in Hebrews and ask the question it answers more directly than any other New Testament book: what did Jesus’ death accomplish, and for whom?

About This Session

The episode surveys the major ways Christians have explained the atonement over the centuries: the ransom theory, Christus Victor, penal substitution, the moral exemplar view, solidarity, and René Girard’s scapegoat theory. Marty argues that each one grew out of the world its teachers lived in (persecution, war, courtrooms, modern skepticism), and that each is useful in its place, like the clubs in a golf bag. He is especially critical of leaning on penal substitution alone.

The heart of the episode is Hebrews’ repeated claim that the old sacrifices could not clear the worshiper’s conscience, while Jesus’ sacrifice does. In Marty’s reading, God never needed sacrifice; we did. Along the way he offers an iPhone analogy for old and new covenant and shows Jesus serving in Hebrews as temple, priest, and sacrifice all at once. People in our room were taught different things about the cross, so come ready to listen as much as to speak.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: When you were growing up, what picture, illustration, or story did you hear most often to explain why Jesus died? How did it make you feel about God?

Clubs in the Bag 25 min

Christians have told the story of the cross in several ways, and the episode argues that each telling carries the fingerprints of its age.

Q1: The episode walks through six theories and the settings they came from: a persecuted early church that heard Jesus as a ransom paid for captives, a medieval world of plague and crusade that celebrated Christ as victor over death, Reformation-era lawyer-theologians like John Calvin who framed the cross as a legal substitution, twentieth-century liberal theology’s moral example, Tony Jones’s solidarity theory, and René Girard’s scapegoat.1 Which of these had you heard of before, and which were new? What do you notice about how each one fits the world it came from?

Q2: Optional The notes point to C.S. Lewis’s The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe as a picture of the ransom theory: Aslan’s deal with the White Witch, the “deep magic,” and a resurrection that leaves her empty-handed. The episode also names that theory’s problems: it puts power in Satan’s hands and makes God look deceptive.2 What other stories, songs, or sermon illustrations carry one of these theories without naming it?

Q3: Marty borrows Scot McKnight’s image: each atonement theory is like a golf club, and you would not use a putter to drive off the tee. Forcing penal substitution to explain everything is like playing a whole round with one club.3 The episode’s sharpest concern is a popular version that pictures an “Angry Father, nice Jesus, helper Holy Spirit,” which Marty says “destroys Trinity doctrine.”4 Several of our traditions have taught penal substitution as central. What has that way of telling the story done well for you or your church? Where, if anywhere, have you seen it slide into the picture Marty warns about?

Q4: Think of different moments in a person’s life: grief, addiction, shame, injustice, doubt. Which “club” has helped you most in a particular season, and which might help someone you love who is struggling right now?

What the Blood Is For 25 min

Hebrews keeps returning to one word that changes the whole conversation: conscience.

Read Hebrews 9:11–14 aloud.

Q5: The notes count roughly five times that Hebrews says the old sacrifices could not “clear the conscience of the worshiper.” Animal blood gave outward cleansing but not inner peace, while Jesus’ sacrifice “cleanses our consciences from acts that lead to death.”5 Read the passage again quietly. What words describe what the old sacrifices did, and what words describe what Christ’s blood does? Report what you find.

Read Hebrews 10:1–10 aloud.

Q6: The episode draws a key insight from Hebrews 10: God commanded sacrifices but does not need or want them, as the Psalms and Prophets also say. In the notes’ words, “God doesn’t need sacrifice - we do.” God could simply forgive, but people would keep their guilty consciences, so the sacrificial system was God’s provision for us rather than a payment to satisfy him.6 What in this passage supports that reading? How does it sit with what you were taught, and what questions does it raise for you?

Q7: Optional The notes say the Levitical system “actually reminded people of sin annually rather than removing guilt.”7 Where have you seen religious practices that keep reminding people of their failures without ever letting them feel clean?

Q8: If the point of the cross is that your conscience can actually be cleansed, what is one thing you still carry as though it had never been dealt with? You do not have to name it aloud. What would it look like to live this week as someone whose conscience has been made clean?

Temple, Priest, and Sacrifice 15 min

Hebrews pictures Jesus filling every role in the old system at once, and the episode offers two images for how old and new relate.

Q9: The notes say Jesus serves in Hebrews as temple (where God meets people), high priest (the one who offers), and sacrifice (the offering that cleanses), and that this combination is why his work is “once for all” rather than endlessly repeated.8 The episode also expects Girard’s scapegoat theory, which draws on the Levitical scapegoat, to shape evangelical theology in coming decades.9

Read Leviticus 16:20–22 aloud.

What do you notice about what happens to the scapegoat and to the people watching? How does that picture connect to a cleansed conscience?

Read Hebrews 8:13 aloud.

Q10: Optional Marty compares the old covenant to an iPhone 5 and the new to an iPhone 11. The older phone is not junk; it holds technology the newer one depends on, though nobody goes back once they have the new one. The notes add that “obsolete” would be better translated “old”: the covenant aged, it was not discarded.10 Last week reminded us to read Hebrews’ “better” language without contempt for Judaism. How does “old” rather than “obsolete” change the way this verse sounds to you? Where does the analogy help, and where might it fall short?

Closing 15 min

The church has told the story of the cross in many ways, and each telling grew up in a particular world. Hebrews holds several of those threads together, presenting Jesus as temple, priest, and sacrifice. Its steady concern is not a God who needs appeasing but people whose consciences need cleansing. God gave sacrifice for our sake, and in Jesus that gift is complete. We can hold our favorite “club” with gratitude while staying humble before a mystery larger than any one theory.

Closing Question: In one sentence each: which picture of the cross do you want to carry with you this week, and why?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 167 — James — Mitzvoth (29:04): The episode reads James as a letter from the leader of the Jerusalem church to Jewish believers scattered among the nations. It argues that James’s “works” (mitzvoth, deeds of covenant obedience) are a different subject from Paul’s “works of the law,” so the two are not contradicting each other.

What to bring next week: Read James 1–2. Mark every place James talks about doing, deeds, or works, and bring one example from your own week where faith showed up (or failed to show up) as action.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Hebrews — Atonement 101.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 166. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/166. The six atonement theories and the historical setting the episode assigns to each. ↩

  2. Ep. 166 notes. The Narnia example and the problems with the ransom theory. ↩

  3. Ep. 166 notes. Scot McKnight’s golf club metaphor. ↩

  4. Ep. 166 notes. The critique of a popular evangelical picture that divides the Trinity. ↩

  5. Ep. 166 notes. Hebrews’ repeated emphasis on the conscience. ↩

  6. Ep. 166 notes. God’s relationship to sacrifice in Hebrews 10. ↩

  7. Ep. 166 notes. The annual reminder of sin in the Levitical system. ↩

  8. Ep. 166 notes. Jesus’ triple role as temple, high priest, and sacrifice. ↩

  9. Ep. 166 notes. Girard’s scapegoat theory and its expected influence. ↩

  10. Ep. 166 notes. The iPhone analogy and “old” rather than “obsolete.” ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.