Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- Two Ways to Preserve Truth 30 min
- Charlemagne, the Schism, and the Dark Ages 20 min
- Has Christendom Ended? 15 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Section | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 191 | Introduction | Session 5 Intro |
| 2 | 192 | Method | Telling a Story |
| 3 | 193 | Church History | AD 100–300 |
| 4 | 194 | Church History | AD 300–500 |
| 5 | 195 | Church History | AD 500–700 |
| 6 | 196 | Church History | AD 700–1000 |
| 7 | 197 | Church History | AD 1000–1300 |
| 8 | 198 | Church History | AD 1300–1550 |
| 9 | 199 | Church History | AD 1550–1650 |
| 10 | 200 | Church History | AD 1650–1800 |
| 11 | 201 | Church History | AD 1800–1925 |
| 12 | 202 | Church History | AD 1925 to Today |
| 13 | 203 | Today | You Are Here |
| 14 | 204 | Capstone | Session 5 Capstone |
Last week: The church took up “the handle end of the sword,” yet the monks preserved texts, served the sick, and built practices that made space for God.1
This week: East and West disagree over how to preserve truth, icons or creeds, and the disagreement helps lead to the Great Schism of 1054.2
About This Session
The episode explores a deep cultural difference behind the conflicts of these centuries. Western Christianity tends to communicate truth through words, definitions and creeds; Eastern Christianity through pictures, images and story.3 In the Iconoclastic Controversy, Western eyes saw prayer before icons as idolatry, while the East understood icons as windows to the divine and “books” for people who could not read. Both were trying to solve the same problem: how to preserve biblical truth in a world with no printing press, widespread illiteracy, and worship in languages most people did not speak.4
The episode also introduces Charlemagne, the “Father of the West,” and reconsiders the so-called Dark Ages, which the notes say were not entirely dark.5 The Great Schism, traditionally dated to 1054, divided the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church through a gradual process.6 Finally, Marty offers his own critical definition of “Christendom” as Christianity grounded in empire and asks whether it has ever ended.7 The notes insist that neither East nor West has a monopoly on truth.2
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Think of something you understand best through a picture, a map or a story rather than a written explanation. Why does that way of learning work for you?
Two Ways to Preserve Truth 30 min
East and West both wanted to keep the biblical story alive; they disagreed about how.
Read Exodus 20:4–6 aloud.
Q1: The notes say the Western critique of icons was that the practice “seemed to violate commandments against graven images.”4 As you listen to the commandment, what exactly does it forbid, and what reasons does it give? Report what you notice. Then consider: what would a Western Christian need to believe about icons to see them as a violation of this text?
Q2: The Eastern position, as the notes describe it, is that icons “are not objects of worship but windows to the divine,” that the worshiper “venerates the God behind the story the icon represents,” and that icons serve as “books” for the illiterate.4 Brent describes his visits to Eastern Orthodox churches as “very moving experiences.”8 What makes this explanation persuasive, or not, to you?
Q3: Optional The notes list the practical realities of the time: no printing press, widespread illiteracy, worship in Latin or Greek, and the Jewish educational system that had preserved Scripture orally “removed from Christian practice.”4 If you were a church leader then, responsible for an illiterate farming village, how would you help people remember the story of Jesus?
Q4: The notes suggest that just as Easterners do not worship icons, Westerners do not worship their doctrinal statements, “though the line may be fine,” and they name a Western tendency toward “doctrinal idolatry.”9 Consider this diagnostically for whatever tradition you come from. Where could a beloved statement, creed or way of explaining the faith become something we trust in place of God? How would you notice if it had?
Charlemagne, the Schism, and the Dark Ages 20 min
These centuries were neither as dark nor as unified as they are often imagined.
Q5: The notes describe Charlemagne (reigning about 768 to 814) as uniting the Western church “in ways not seen since Constantine” and urging intellectual and spiritual revitalization; they also note his work “can be viewed with either admiration or critical eyes.”5 Meanwhile ordinary people lived with illiteracy, worship in a language they did not understand, and dependence on clergy for religious knowledge.10 What would faith have felt like for an ordinary farmer in that world?
Q6: Optional The notes say the “Dark Ages” were not entirely dark at all, citing James Hannam’s The Genesis of Science and figures like Boniface, and suggest this era set up the scientific revolution.10 Why do you think the label “Dark Ages” has been so durable?
Q7: The Great Schism is traditionally dated to 1054, but some historians argue it was not finalized until 1472; it was “an ongoing process” rather than a single moment, and the Western church felt “shock and terror at losing half the Christian empire.”6 Many of us have lived through a church split or a slow drifting apart. Without naming anyone, what did you learn about how divisions actually happen, and what would you do differently if you saw one beginning now?
Has Christendom Ended? 15 min
Marty asks whether the empire mindset ever left the church.
Q8: The notes compare dictionary definitions of Christendom (a worldwide body of Christians, or church and state as two aspects of one society) with Marty’s sharper view: Christianity “with imperial undertones,” grounded in empire since Constantine, summed up in the attitude “Give me the handle end of the sword. Now we’re in charge.”7 What difference does the definition you choose make for how you tell church history?
Q9: Optional The notes raise the possibility that “even when church and state separated,” the imperial mindset remained.7 Where do you think Christendom has truly ended, and where might it continue in new forms?
Q10: Where in your own life (your conversations, your hopes for the church, your reactions to culture) do you notice the wish to be “in charge,” and what would it look like this week to set that wish down?
Closing 15 min
This week we saw the church divide along a line that ran deeper than doctrine: two cultures with two ways of keeping the story alive. The East painted the story so people could read it in images; the West wrote it down so it could be defined and recited. Each saw danger in the other, and each carried its own risk of trusting the tool more than the God it pointed to. Charlemagne united the West for a time, the schism split East from West, and Christendom’s imperial mindset raises the question of whether it ever really ended. The invitation is humility: neither half of the church holds all the truth.
Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one thing you could learn from a Christian tradition very different from your own?
Looking Ahead
Ep. 197 — AD 1000–1300 (18:47): After the schism, the Western church faces a crisis of papal authority, and the Crusades follow. Marty and Brent confront the violence committed “in Jesus’s name,” the rise of Scholasticism and Thomas Aquinas, and the challenge to own this dark history rather than disown it.11
What to bring next week: Read Exodus 1:8–14 and Deuteronomy 6:20–25. Notice who is speaking, and which pronouns they use, when the story of Egypt is retold in Deuteronomy.
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 500–700.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 195. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/195. The shift to “the handle end of the sword” and the monastic contributions. ↩
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 700–1000.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 196. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/196. The Iconoclastic Controversy, the East-West Schism, and the conclusion that neither East nor West is entirely right or wrong. ↩ ↩2
-
Ep. 196 notes. Eastern and Western worldviews. ↩
-
Ep. 196 notes. The Iconoclastic Controversy: the Eastern position, the Western critique, and the historical context. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Ep. 196 notes. Charlemagne’s contributions and legacy. ↩ ↩2
-
Ep. 196 notes. The Great East-West Schism, its gradual nature, causes and results. ↩ ↩2
-
Ep. 196 notes. Definitions of Christendom and Marty’s critical perspective. ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Ep. 196 notes. Brent’s visits to Eastern Orthodox churches. ↩
-
Ep. 196 notes. Western “doctrinal idolatry” and the parallel between icons and doctrinal statements. ↩
-
Ep. 196 notes. The “Dark Ages” reconsidered and the reality for common people. ↩ ↩2
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 1000–1300.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 197. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/197. The crisis of papal authority, the Crusades, Scholasticism, and owning dark history. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.