BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 5 · Week 13 of 14

Episode 203

You Are Here

Four Pillars to Recover: Text, Community, Discipleship, Wrestling

90-minute session Isaiah 55:10–11; Ephesians 6:17; Matthew 28:19–20; Genesis 32:22–32

For group discussion. Listen to episode 203 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Text and Community 25 min
  3. Discipleship and Wrestling 25 min
  4. Living in Babylon, Returning Home 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 5 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 191 Introduction Session 5 Intro
2 192 Method Telling a Story
3 193 Church History AD 100–300
4 194 Church History AD 300–500
5 195 Church History AD 500–700
6 196 Church History AD 700–1000
7 197 Church History AD 1000–1300
8 198 Church History AD 1300–1550
9 199 Church History AD 1550–1650
10 200 Church History AD 1650–1800
11 201 Church History AD 1800–1925
12 202 Church History AD 1925 to Today
13 203 Today You Are Here
14 204 Capstone Session 5 Capstone

Last week: The history reached our own lifetimes, from fundamentalism and liberalism to the Jesus Movement and Jacob Neusner, and Marty insisted that “we find ourselves - as every generation has - perfectly placed for this future.”1

This week: With the timeline complete, Marty marks the “you are here” spot on the map and names four pillars the church lost and can recover.2

About This Session

This episode gathers up the entire BEMA journey, from creation to the present. Marty names four pillars that were present throughout Scripture and especially in the first-century church rooted in Judaism: Text, Community, Discipleship and Wrestling. When the church rejected its Jewish heritage, he argues, it lost not only relationships with Jewish people but each of these pillars, and it took on empire narratives of consumerism, comfort and doctrinal control instead.3

The episode is hopeful, not only critical. Marty points to the tools, connectivity and cultural openness to complexity that make these pillars more recoverable today than ever, and he frames the whole discussion with t’shuvah (“return” or “repentance”): asking what to remove, what to keep and what ancient practices to recover. He also insists that change starts small. After a trip to Israel in 2008, he began by memorizing one paragraph of the Bible each week.4

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a time you used a “You Are Here” map in a mall, park or hospital. What did you need to know before you could figure out where to go next?

Text and Community 25 min

The first two pillars are a Bible carried inside us and a community that includes people we disagree with.

Read Isaiah 55:10–11 and Ephesians 6:17 aloud.

Q1: Marty says first-century Jewish children memorized the entire Torah and much of the Tanakh (the Hebrew Bible), and that there is a crucial difference between having a Bible on the shelf and having the Bible within you. He connects Isaiah 55 to the power of God’s word to accomplish its purpose, and Paul’s description of the word as “the sword of the Spirit,” suggesting that losing our connection to the Text means losing connection to the power of the Holy Spirit.5 What images do these two passages use for God’s word? What do they suggest the word does, and where does each passage picture that word being located?

Q2: When the church abandoned its Jewish identity and practice, Marty argues, it reverted to Roman empire values: self-preservation, luxury, comfort and leisure. The Kingdom’s most effective tool is an inclusive community that shows the world a better way to live, not merely friendship with the like-minded but radical fellowship with people we disagree with. That, the notes say, is what makes the church truly Eucharistic.6 Our own group brings together several traditions. Where have you experienced real fellowship across disagreement, here or elsewhere, and what made it hold?

Q3: Optional Marty lists modern tools for the first two pillars: BibleGateway.com and online lexicons that allow word searches in seconds, and Zoom, social networks and email that make community possible in new ways. The challenge, the notes say, is not to settle for pseudo-community that allows continued idolatry of consumerism.7 Where do these tools genuinely help your engagement with the Text and with community, and where do they let you settle for less?

Discipleship and Wrestling 25 min

Jesus formed people by sharing life with them, and the faith he inherited welcomed hard questions.

Read Matthew 28:19–20 aloud.

Q4: Jesus spent three years with twelve young men (and women), all day, every day. Marty notes that he started no churches and went on no missionary journeys; he said “follow me” and showed people how to live. The Great Commission calls us to make disciples, not merely to run programs or attend events.8 Notice what the passage actually tells the disciples to do. How does that compare with the way you were discipled, and what is the closest you have come to that kind of life-on-life formation?

Q5: Optional The notes say modern churches have replaced immersive discipleship with Bible studies and conferences, which have value but are not substitutes. Marty points to on-the-job training as proof that immersive learning still works and calls for faith communities restructured around total immersion rather than programs.9 What would one realistic step toward that kind of discipleship look like in your church, or in this group?

Read Genesis 32:22–32 aloud.

Q6: The early church, Marty says, was devoted to the same wrestling that characterized Jacob. They believed the text was meant to be wrestled with, rejected formulas, accepted many shades of gray, and lived with a culture of chutzpah (bold engagement and questioning). When the church lost the Text, questions and doubts became threats to doctrines and creeds; it began discouraging dissent and has historically even killed people for it. Marty sees an opening today, because younger generations value life’s complexities and questions can become doorways to discovery.10 What does Jacob do in this story, and what does he receive? How did the churches you grew up in treat questions and doubts, and how has this BEMA journey changed the way you handle your own?

Living in Babylon, Returning Home 15 min

Marty names our cultural captivity and calls us to a return that starts with small steps.

Q7: Optional Marty uses Emmylou Harris’s song “Time in Babylon” and Walter Brueggemann’s Out of Babylon to describe modern captivity to empire. His examples include five-lane highways and SUVs (“you need that chrome to get you home”), cluster mansions, brand-name obsession, and prioritizing results and wealth over conscience and generosity. The kingdom narrative, by contrast, calls for subversive community, generosity, hospitality, Sabbath and care for the marginalized.11 Which of Marty’s Babylon examples hits closest to home for you, and which kingdom practice is its best antidote?

Q8: T’shuvah asks three questions: what needs to be removed from our faith practice, what needs to be kept, and what ancient practices need to be recovered. The notes stress that this means returning, not inventing new things. Marty adds a Talmudic principle: “Just as rain falls in drops and forms mighty rivers, so it is with Torah. A man studies a little here and a little there, until understanding comes like a rushing spring.”12 Of those three questions (remove, keep, recover), which feels most pressing in your faith right now? What is one small, realistic and attainable “drop” you could begin with?

Closing 15 min

Marty marks the spot on the map: you are here. The church began as a Jewish movement that carried the Text in its memory, lived as an inclusive community, made disciples by sharing life, and wrestled boldly with God and with hard questions. When it rejected its Jewish heritage, it lost each of these pillars and drifted into the comforts and controls of empire. Yet we live with more tools, more access and more openness to complexity than any generation before us. The way forward is t’shuvah: a return that starts not with dramatic overnight change but with small, faithful drops that, over time, become a river.13

Closing Question: In one sentence, name the one pillar you will take a small step toward this week, and what the step is.

Looking Ahead

Ep. 204 — Session 5 Capstone (36:24): Next week is our finale, the last week of Session 5 and of BEMA’s five foundational sessions. Rather than new history, Marty and Brent reflect on the whole journey and read two passages from Sarah Bessey, a benediction from Out of Sorts and “The Commissioning” from Jesus Feminist, sending listeners out as ministers in their own lives.14

What to bring next week:

  • Come ready to name the one thing from all five sessions that has mattered most to you, and one thing you feel is still missing.
  • Read Jeremiah 29:4–7, Jeremiah’s letter to the exiles in Babylon.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 1925 to Today.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 202. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/202. The century from fundamentalism to today, Neusner, and Marty’s conclusion that every generation is “perfectly placed.” ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “You Are Here.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 203. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/203. The episode summarizes the BEMA journey and introduces the Four Pillars of BEMA. ↩

  3. Ep. 203 notes. The Four Pillars, their presence in the first-century church, and their loss when the church rejected its Jewish heritage. ↩

  4. Ep. 203 notes. Modern opportunities to reclaim the pillars, the framing of t’shuvah, and Marty’s practice of memorizing one paragraph a week after Israel in 2008. ↩

  5. Ep. 203 notes. Torah memorization, the Bible on the shelf versus within, Isaiah 55, and Ephesians’ “sword of the Spirit.” ↩

  6. Ep. 203 notes. Empire values, inclusive community as the Kingdom’s most effective tool, and radical fellowship as what makes the church Eucharistic. ↩

  7. Ep. 203 notes. Modern tools for Text and Community and the warning against pseudo-community. ↩

  8. Ep. 203 notes. Jesus’s model of discipleship and the Great Commission’s call to make disciples. ↩

  9. Ep. 203 notes. Bible studies and conferences as no substitute for immersion, and on-the-job training as a model. ↩

  10. Ep. 203 notes. Wrestling, Jacob, chutzpah, the church’s discouragement of dissent, and the opportunity of postmodernity and younger generations. ↩

  11. Ep. 203 notes. “Time in Babylon,” Brueggemann’s Out of Babylon, Marty’s examples of modern Babylon, and the kingdom narrative. ↩

  12. Ep. 203 notes. The three questions of t’shuvah and the Talmudic principle about rain and Torah. ↩

  13. Ep. 203 notes. The brief summary’s account of the pillars, their loss, modern opportunity, and t’shuvah through small steps. ↩

  14. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Session 5 Capstone.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 204. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/204. The conclusion of the five foundational sessions and the two Sarah Bessey readings. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.