Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- From Persecuted to Powerful 30 min
- Four Councils and a Shift in Orthodoxy 35 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Section | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 191 | Introduction | Session 5 Intro |
| 2 | 192 | Method | Telling a Story |
| 3 | 193 | Church History | AD 100–300 |
| 4 | 194 | Church History | AD 300–500 |
| 5 | 195 | Church History | AD 500–700 |
| 6 | 196 | Church History | AD 700–1000 |
| 7 | 197 | Church History | AD 1000–1300 |
| 8 | 198 | Church History | AD 1300–1550 |
| 9 | 199 | Church History | AD 1550–1650 |
| 10 | 200 | Church History | AD 1650–1800 |
| 11 | 201 | Church History | AD 1800–1925 |
| 12 | 202 | Church History | AD 1925 to Today |
| 13 | 203 | Today | You Are Here |
| 14 | 204 | Capstone | Session 5 Capstone |
Last week: We traced the second-century break between Jewish and Gentile believers and what the church lost with it: its Jewish teachers, its interpretive framework, and much of its grip on the text.1
This week: Persecution ends, Christianity becomes the empire’s faith, and four councils define who Christ is. Marty asks what was gained and what was lost.2
About This Session
The episode covers the two centuries in which Christianity moved from a persecuted movement to an imperial religion. It begins with Constantine’s vision before a battle, the Chi-Rho symbol, and his decision to legalize Christianity; later, under Theodosius, Christianity became advantageous and effectively the imperial religion.3 Marty calls the roughly 1,400 years from the fourth century to the French Revolution “Christendom,” or “imperial Christianity.”4
Freedom from persecution brought new challenges: time for long-postponed debates, an influx of convenience converts, and Greek philosophy replacing the Jewish framework of relationship and narrative.5 Four councils (Nicea, Constantinople, Ephesus and Chalcedon) affirmed Christ’s divinity, his humanity, his single personhood, and that he is fully God and fully human at once.6 The hosts honor those clarifications while asking whether they would have been needed if the church had kept its Jewish roots, and Marty describes the period as the start of a “downhill slide” in which orthodoxy became about affirming beliefs rather than living a particular way.7
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Think of a group, club or cause you belonged to that suddenly became popular. What changed once it was easy, or even advantageous, to belong?
From Persecuted to Powerful 30 min
Constantine’s conversion ended the threat of death for Christians and opened a very different chapter.
Q1: According to Constantine’s own testimony, he saw a vision of a shield bearing the Greek letters Chi and Rho and understood it to mean “In Christ, you will conquer.” The notes list four ways historians read the story: genuine miracle, political genius, some combination of both, or a real vision that Constantine misunderstood.3 Which reading seems most likely to you, and what in the story moves you toward it?
Q2: Optional The notes distinguish Constantine making Christianity legal (ending persecution) from Theodosius making it advantageous and effectively the imperial religion.3 Why does that difference matter? What changes when a faith moves from tolerated to favored?
Q3: The early teaching manual called the Didache required those being baptized to swear off their old pagan way of life, dying to it and walking into a “brand new family, this Jewish walk.” After legalization, many came into the church because it had become “convenient, efficient, effective, and advantageous,” and research cited in the episode describes Christianity as a “fad among the Roman elite.”5 What happens to a community’s discipleship when following Jesus starts to cost nothing and gain something? Where do you see the same dynamic at work in churches today?
Q4: If following Jesus in your setting costs little, what would a costlier, more Didache-like commitment look like in one specific area of your life this month?
Four Councils and a Shift in Orthodoxy 35 min
The councils asked precise questions about Christ’s nature, and the way the questions were asked tells its own story.
Q5: The notes lay out the councils’ progressive logic: Nicea (325) affirmed that Christ is God, Constantinople (381) that he is human, Ephesus (431) that he is one person rather than two, and Chalcedon (451) that he is fully God and fully man at the same time.6 The notes also explain that a Gnostic framework (spiritual good, physical not good) made saying Jesus was truly a man feel “dangerous and degrading.”8 In your own words, what problem was each council trying to solve?
Read Acts 15:22–29 aloud.
Q6: The notes point out that councils were not invented in the fourth century; the Jerusalem Council of Acts 15 gave a precedent, though the later councils were “set up for a rougher road” once separated from Jewish ways of interpreting.9 Compare the letter you just heard with the Nicene Creed’s phrase that Christ is “of one substance with the Father.”6 What kind of thing does each one ask of believers? What do you notice about the language, the tone and the goal of each?
Q7: Optional Marty uses the familiar question to philosophy majors, “What are you going to do with that degree?”, to describe highly educated Gentile converts bringing philosophical tools to questions the Bible was not written to answer in those terms.10 Where have you seen a good question get stuck because it was asked in the wrong framework?
Q8: Marty calls this period “the beginning of a downhill slide that I’m not sure we have ever recovered from,” because orthodoxy came to mean affirming correct beliefs rather than living a particular way.7 The hosts still treat the councils’ clarifications as significant.11 The traditions in our room relate to creeds and statements of faith in different ways, so approach this as a diagnosis rather than a verdict: in your own tradition, what tends to mark someone as a “real” Christian, what they affirm or how they live? What has that emphasis given you, and what might it have cost?
Q9: If the people who know you best described your faith only by how you lived this past week, without hearing anything you believe, what would they say? What is one practice you want them to be able to name a month from now?
Closing 15 min
This week the church stepped out from under the sword and into the palace. Persecution ended, crowds came in, and leaders finally had time to work through hard questions about who Jesus is. The councils gave answers the church still treasures, yet the hosts ask whether something was lost along the way: the Jewish framework of story, relationship and practice gave way to philosophical precision, and orthodoxy drifted toward believing correctly more than living faithfully. The Jerusalem Council had asked Gentile believers how to walk; the later councils asked them what to affirm. Both questions matter, and this week invites us to notice which one shapes us more.
Closing Question: In one sentence, name one way you want your faith this week to be visible in how you live, not only in what you believe.
Looking Ahead
Ep. 195 — AD 500–700 (14:26): As Rome falls, the church moves from the “pointy end of the sword” to “the handle end of the sword,” with forced conversions and anti-Jewish edicts. Yet the same era produces the monastic movements, which developed orthopraxy (right practice) and taught the church how to create space for God.12
What to bring next week: Read Genesis 18:1–8 and Matthew 22:36–40. Notice one spiritual practice (prayer, silence, fasting, a set time of Scripture reading) that has helped you, or that you wish you had.
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 100–300.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 193. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/193. The Jewish-Gentile schism and the loss of Jewish teachers, framework and access to the text. ↩
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 300–500.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 194. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/194. The transition from persecuted movement to imperial religion and the four ecumenical councils. ↩
-
Ep. 194 notes. Constantine’s vision and conversion, its four interpretations, and the difference between legalization and Theodosius’s imperial religion. ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Ep. 194 notes. Christendom defined as the roughly 1,400 years of “imperial Christianity.” ↩
-
Ep. 194 notes. The problem of freedom from persecution, convenience converts, the Didache’s baptismal requirements, and Christianity as a “fad among the Roman elite.” ↩ ↩2
-
Ep. 194 notes. The four councils, their outcomes (including “of one substance with the Father”), and their progressive logic. ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Ep. 194 notes. The loss of Jewish foundations and the “downhill slide” in which orthodoxy became affirming beliefs rather than living a particular way. ↩ ↩2
-
Ep. 194 notes. The Gnostic framework and why Christ’s humanity felt “dangerous and degrading.” ↩
-
Ep. 194 notes. The Jerusalem Council precedent (Acts 15) and the “rougher road.” ↩
-
Ep. 194 notes. The philosophy degree analogy. ↩
-
Ep. 194 notes, Summary. The theological clarifications “matter significantly” even as something essential was lost. ↩
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 500–700.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 195. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/195. The reversal from persecuted to persecutor and the monastic development of orthopraxy. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.