BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 5 · Week 7 of 14

Episode 197

AD 1000–1300

The Crusades, Egypt Again, and Owning a Dark History

90-minute session Exodus 1:8–14; Deuteronomy 6:20–25

For group discussion. Listen to episode 197 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. The Crusades: Empire in Jesus’s Name 25 min
  3. Owning Versus Disowning History 25 min
  4. Scholasticism and What Was Lost 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 5 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 191 Introduction Session 5 Intro
2 192 Method Telling a Story
3 193 Church History AD 100–300
4 194 Church History AD 300–500
5 195 Church History AD 500–700
6 196 Church History AD 700–1000
7 197 Church History AD 1000–1300
8 198 Church History AD 1300–1550
9 199 Church History AD 1550–1650
10 200 Church History AD 1650–1800
11 201 Church History AD 1800–1925
12 202 Church History AD 1925 to Today
13 203 Today You Are Here
14 204 Capstone Session 5 Capstone

Last week: East and West split over how to preserve truth, icons or creeds, and Marty asked whether Christendom’s imperial mindset has ever really ended.1

This week: In one of the darkest chapters of church history, the Crusades, the episode asks Christians to own their history rather than disown it.2

About This Session

After the East-West Schism, the Western church faced a crisis: if the East could tell the Pope “no,” what did papal authority mean?3 Marty offers what he calls his own hunch, not received teaching, that the Crusades helped unify a fragmenting Christendom around a common enemy. He takes care to say the radical movement within Islam heading toward Palestine “did not represent the Islamic faith as a whole,” and he names a double standard: Christians refuse to be defined by their own fringe while painting others by theirs.4 The notes describe the Crusades as Empire thinking, with the wealthy and powerful sending the poor to fight, and compare it to Israel making bricks in Egypt.5

The episode contrasts the Jewish habit of owning history (“WE were in Egypt”) with a Western faith that is “just personal,” and adapts a familiar saying: “A dark history disowned by the descendants of it will be bound to repeat itself.”6 It closes with the rise of Scholasticism and the university, which created a new divide based on education, and with Thomas Aquinas’s synthesis of learning through Greek philosophy, which leads Marty to ask what the church had lost a thousand years after Jesus.7

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a family, a team, a town or a country you belong to. When someone brings up a painful part of its past, what is your first instinct: to explain it, defend it, distance yourself from it, or something else?

The Crusades: Empire in Jesus’s Name 25 min

The episode refuses to soften what was done in Jesus’s name and asks what kind of kingdom it served.

Q1: The notes describe a Western church shaken by the schism, its claim of apostolic succession challenged, and Marty’s hunch (in the words of a common saying) that “Nothing brings people together like a common enemy.”3 What makes a common enemy such a powerful way to unify a divided group, and what does it cost?

Read Exodus 1:8–14 aloud.

Q2: The notes observe that not everyone fought in the Crusades: “the wealthy and powerful sent the poor, uneducated, and commoners to do the fighting,” a pattern that echoes “the Israelites making bricks in Egypt under Pharaoh - this is Egypt, not the way of Jesus.”5 As you listen to the Exodus passage, what do you notice about who decides, who labors, and why the powerful act as they do? Report one detail that sounds familiar from the Crusades as the notes describe them.

Q3: Optional Marty describes three movements within Islam during the canonization of the Quran (progressive, moderate and radical) and notes that “we paint Islam with the brush of its most radical adherents while rejecting that same standard for Christianity.”4 Why is that double standard so easy to fall into, and what helps us resist it?

Q4: The notes set Empire (force, coercion, hierarchy, the stick rather than invitation) against Shalom (invitation, voice, living on every word that comes from the mouth of God).8 The Crusaders believed their cause was holy. When you care deeply about a good cause, what Empire tools (pressure, fear, using people) are you most tempted to reach for, and what would choosing invitation look like instead?

Owning Versus Disowning History 25 min

Jewish tradition says “we” about the whole story; much Western faith says “me.”

Read Deuteronomy 6:20–25 aloud.

Q5: The notes contrast the Jewish approach, “WE were in Egypt… WE were in the desert,” which owns every part of its history as corporate identity, with a Western faith that is “just personal,” a matter between “God and I” or “me and Jesus.”6 In this passage, a parent answers a child’s question about the commandments. What pronouns does the answer use, and what does that suggest about who the story belongs to? Report what you notice.

Q6: On an Israel trip, a Jewish guide was asked why he did not follow Jesus. He answered: “For us, Jesus is connected to 1,800 years of brutal Church history, much of which has been just filled with the slaughter of people in the name of this Jesus.”9 What is your honest reaction to hearing that? How does it change the way you think about how Jesus is seen by people outside the church?

Q7: Optional Donald Miller’s Blue Like Jazz describes a “reverse confessional” at Reed College, where Christians confessed on behalf of their faith, and readers pushed back: “Why would I apologize for something that happened centuries ago?”10 What would you say to someone who asked that question?

Q8: Marty adapts the familiar saying: “A dark history disowned by the descendants of it will be bound to repeat itself.”6 Every tradition in our room has chapters it would rather not claim. Thinking diagnostically rather than with blame, what would it look like for you, or for your tradition, to own a hard piece of its history in a way that changes how you live now?

Scholasticism and What Was Lost 15 min

While the poor fought, a small educated elite built the foundations of the modern university.

Q9: Optional The notes say university education was so exclusive that Brent suggests “1% might even be overstating the case,” with perhaps five people in a room, and that it gave “an incredible, almost inconceivable advantage.”7 Where do you see knowledge or education creating a gap between people today, including in churches?

Q10: Thomas Aquinas “changed the face of Christian history by bringing into a logical order the many fields of education,” and our education system is largely shaped by his perspective. Yet Marty hopes listeners will “critically examine just how lost we are 1,000 years after the Judaic movement of Jesus.”11 Looking back over the last seven weeks, what do you think the church had lost by this point? Which of those losses would you most like to recover in your own walk with God?

Closing 15 min

This week we faced the Crusades without looking away. A church shaken by schism found unity in a common enemy, and the powerful sent the poor to fight in Jesus’s name, repeating the pattern of Pharaoh rather than the way of Jesus. The episode asks us to say “we” about this history the way Jewish tradition says “WE were in Egypt,” because a dark history disowned by its descendants is bound to repeat itself. At the same time, learning flourished for a privileged few, and Greek logic took the place of much the church had received from its Jewish roots. Owning the story is the first step toward not repeating it.

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one piece of the church’s history you are willing to say “we” about this week?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 198 — AD 1300–1550 (20:37): After the Crusades, a spiritually and financially exhausted church turns to the sale of indulgences, while reformers like John Wycliffe and Jan Hus call for Scripture in the people’s own languages. Medieval nationalism and the printing press help set the stage for the Protestant Reformation, and Brent reminds us that “There’s always a remnant.”12

What to bring next week: Think of one Bible translation that has shaped your faith and, if you know, who made it and why. Bring one question you have always had about the Reformation.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 700–1000.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 196. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/196. Icons and creeds, the East-West Schism, and the question of whether Christendom has ended. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 1000–1300.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 197. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/197. The episode covers the Crusades and challenges Christians to own this dark history rather than disown it. ↩

  3. Ep. 197 notes. The crisis of papal authority and the Crusades as a possible unification strategy, presented as Marty’s personal hunch. ↩ ↩2

  4. Ep. 197 notes. The three movements within Islam and the problem of representation. ↩ ↩2

  5. Ep. 197 notes, Key Takeaways and Empire vs. Shalom. The wealthy and powerful sending the poor to fight, compared to the Israelites making bricks in Egypt. ↩ ↩2

  6. Ep. 197 notes. Owning versus disowning history, and the adapted saying about dark history. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  7. Ep. 197 notes. The rise of Scholasticism and the exclusivity of university education. ↩ ↩2

  8. Ep. 197 notes. Empire and Shalom characteristics. ↩

  9. Ep. 197 notes. The Jewish guide’s response on an Israel trip. ↩

  10. Ep. 197 notes. Donald Miller’s reverse confessional in Blue Like Jazz. ↩

  11. Ep. 197 notes. Thomas Aquinas and Marty’s critique of the triumph of Greek logic. ↩

  12. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “AD 1300–1550.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 198. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/198. The aftermath of the Crusades, indulgences, Wycliffe and Hus, nationalism, the printing press, and the remnant. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.