BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 6 · Week 19 of 66

Episode 223

The Chosen S1E4 — “The Rock on Which It Is Built”

Luke 5: Empty Nets, a Wife Who Pushes Back, and a Net for All Kinds

90-minute session Luke 5:1–11; John 1:35–42; Genesis 2:18

For group discussion. Listen to episode 223 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Simon at the End of Himself 25 min
  3. The Catch and the Call 25 min
  4. Gather All Kinds 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 6 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 205 Introduction Session 6 Intro
2 206 Guest Conversation The Nature of Truth (Reed Dent)
3 207 Guest Conversation The Sacred Overlap (J. R. Briggs)
4 208 Midrash Iscah, Sarai, and Birth Orders
5 209 Midrash Noah’s Backstory and the Nephilim
6 210 Midrash The Man in the Fur Coat
7 211 Gospel of John Blue Jeans Theology
8 212 Character Study Jacob, Part 1
9 213 Character Study Jacob, Part 2
10 214 Character Study Joseph, Part 1
11 215 Character Study Joseph, Part 2
12 216 Guest Conversation Can We Talk? (Porshe Chiles)
13 217 Midrash Isaac’s Bad Eyes
14 218 Midrash Death at Dinner
15 219 Guest Conversation Loving the Adventure (Becky Solomon)
16 220 The Chosen The Chosen S1E1 — “I Have Called You by Name”
17 221 The Chosen The Chosen S1E2 — “Shabbat”
18 222 The Chosen The Chosen S1E3 — “Jesus Loves the Little Children”
19 223 The Chosen The Chosen S1E4 — “The Rock on Which It Is Built”
20 224 The Chosen The Chosen S1E5 — “The Wedding Gift”
21 225 The Chosen The Chosen S1E6 — “Indescribable Compassion”
22 226 The Chosen The Chosen S1E7 — “Invitations”
23 227 The Chosen The Chosen S1E8 — “I Am He”
24 228 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 1 (Dallas Jenkins)
25 229 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 2 (Dallas Jenkins)
26 230 Guest Conversation Unfettered (Mandy Smith)
27 231 Introducing the Team Deconstruction w/ Reed Dent
28 232 Introducing the Team Jephthah’s Daughter w/ Elle Grover Fricks
29 233 Introducing the Team Striking the Rock w/ Josh Bossé
30 234 Guest Conversation The Jewish Roots of Christianity (Jen Rosner)
31 235 Jewish Roots Tanakh and Religion
32 236 Jewish Roots Paul, Jewish Law, and Atonement in Hebrews
33 237 Jewish Roots Ways Parted for a Dark History
34 238 Jewish Roots What Difference Does It Make?
35 239 Co-host Study Abraham Considers a Catechism w/ Reed Dent
36 240 Co-host Study Sin and the Archaeology of Joshua w/ Elle Grover Fricks
37 241 Guest Conversation Don’t Exasperate Your Kids (Becky Solomon)
38 242 Spiritual Abuse Commodities and Variables
39 243 Spiritual Abuse The Place We Find Ourselves
40 244 Spiritual Abuse The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill
41 245 Spiritual Abuse Liturgy for Repentance and Healing
42 246 Guest Conversation A Look into Our Window (Eugenia Ortega)
43 247 Co-host Study Sleepless in Susa w/ Josh Bossé
44 248 Co-host Study Joy and Lot’s Untitled Wife w/ Elle Grover Fricks
45 249 Guest Conversation Escaping the Beast (Michael Burns)
46 250 The Chosen The Chosen S1E0 — “The Shepherd”
47 251 Gospel of John A Griever’s Guide to Life
48 252 Gospel of John What’s in a Logos?
49 254 Gospel of John A Wedding and Some Housekeeping
50 255 Gospel of John Water, Spirit, Darkness, Light
51 256 Gospel of John The One from Above
52 301 Gospel of John On Doubting and Locked Doors
53 302 Gospel of John Do You Even Like Me?
54 303 Gospel of John The History and Style of the Gospel of John
55 312 Parables Dissecting a Swallow
56 313 Parables The Good Samaritan
57 314 Parables The Barn Builder
58 315 Parables The Lost Son
59 316 Parables The Unforgiving Servant
60 325 Sanctuary Waking Up in the Mishkan
61 326 Sanctuary Entering the Mishkan
62 327 Sanctuary Feasting at the Mishkan
63 328 Sanctuary Listening by the Mishkan
64 329 Sanctuary Moving the Mishkan
65 330 Sanctuary Traversing the Mishkan
66 331 Sanctuary Resting with the Mishkan

Last week: Jesus spent his days with curious children, honoring their teacher while warning that “smart men lack wisdom,” and naming a timid boy “Joshua the brave” at his first act of courage.1

This week: Simon’s schemes run out, his nets come up empty, and the miraculous catch of Luke 5 turns a desperate fisherman into a disciple.2

About This Session

The episode follows Simon to the end of his own resources. Deep in debt to Rome, he justifies fishing on the Sabbath, makes deals with Romans, and prays a raw prayer about God’s seemingly inconsistent promises. His wife Eden refuses to let him drift, and the hosts see in her the ezer kenegdo of Genesis 2. When Zebedee and his sons arrive to help, Jesus teaches from Simon’s boat, and the nets fill.2

The hosts also note how the show weaves John’s account (Andrew meets Jesus first through John the Baptist) together with the fishing call in the other Gospels, how Jesus teaches with a net in his hands, and his instruction to gather “all kinds” and let him do the sorting. Around the edges, Matthew’s isolation deepens and the Pharisees divide over how to handle John the Baptist.3

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a time you were determined to fix a problem on your own. What finally happened, and who (if anyone) ended up helping?

Simon at the End of Himself 25 min

Simon’s crisis is financial, but the episode shows it becoming spiritual.

Q1: The notes describe Simon’s desperate prayer as revealing “the authentic human struggle with God’s seemingly inconsistent promises throughout Israel’s history,” a story of “deliverance followed by wilderness, promised land followed by exile, return followed by oppression.”4 What do you hear in a prayer like that? Why might the hosts treat its raw honesty as authentic faith rather than a lack of it?

Q2: Optional Simon invokes pikuach nefesh (“preserving life”), “the Jewish teaching that almost any commandment can be broken to save a life,” arguing that his debt to Rome puts lives at stake. Eden challenges whether the principle really applies, or whether he is excusing “a longer pattern of faithlessness and self-reliance.”5 How would you describe the difference between a genuine emergency and a rationalization? Why is it so hard to tell from the inside?

Read Genesis 2:18 aloud.

Q3: The notes translate ezer kenegdo as “helper who opposes” and see it embodied in Eden, who “is not passively submissive but actively opposes Peter when he strays from faith and tries to fix everything himself.” They credit her with chutzpah (bold courage) and say the portrayal challenges both patriarchal readings and readings that ignore first-century context.6 Notice the words of the verse itself. What does “helper who opposes” add to the way you have heard this verse taught? Then think about your own life: who has loved you enough to push back when you drifted, and how did you receive it?

The Catch and the Call 25 min

The show pulls several Gospel accounts into one story of failure, help and recognition.

Read Luke 5:1–11 aloud.

Q4: Listen for what Simon says and does from the moment Jesus asks to use his boat to the moment he falls at Jesus’s knees. The notes trace Simon’s arc in the episode from “I don’t need a lamb, I need fish” to “Depart from me, I’m a sinful man.”7 What changes in Simon between verse 5 and verse 8? What do you think he sees that makes him respond the way he does?

Read John 1:35–42 aloud.

Q5: Optional In John’s Gospel, Andrew meets Jesus through John the Baptist and then brings his brother; in Matthew, Mark and Luke, Jesus calls the brothers while they are fishing. The show has Andrew meet Jesus first and then has Jesus call both brothers at the catch, which the notes call “creative faithfulness to the Text.”8 What is gained by honoring both accounts? Does it raise any questions for you about how the Gospels tell the same story differently?

Q6: The notes see a “divine setup” in the episode: Simon’s debt, the failed nights, Andrew’s encounter, Zebedee’s sons arriving, and Jesus teaching from the boat. They observe that “when Simon works alone he fails, but when others arrive to help, breakthrough becomes possible,” and that “what feels like meaningless struggle may be preparation for significant encounter.”9 Not every struggle resolves the way Simon’s did, so answer as honestly as you like. Looking back, where has the help of other people been part of how God met you? Is there a place where you are still trying to fish alone?

Gather All Kinds 15 min

Jesus gives his new disciples a job, and it is not sorting.

Q7: Optional The notes stress that the Pharisees were not one block. They were divided between the schools of Hillel and Shammai and over how to handle John the Baptist, whose tavilat t’shuvah (baptism of repentance) did not fit the usual ritual washings. Nicodemus questions and investigates, while his student Shmuel may go so far as to give John’s location to the Romans.10 What changes for you when the religious leaders in the story are divided rather than uniform?

Q8: Jesus tells his new disciples to gather “all kinds” of fish and he will sort them out later. The notes observe that “Christians often spend enormous energy on gatekeeping,” and that Jesus “removes this burden.” Meanwhile Matthew cannot even enter the bar where the fishermen gather, hated “more than Romans because he chose betrayal.”11 Who would your community find hardest to picture in the net? What would it feel like to let go of the sorting and simply keep gathering?

Closing 15 min

Simon spends this episode trying to save himself, with deals, rationalizations and lonely nights on the water. Eden will not let him drift, his partners arrive to help, and Jesus meets him in the boat with more fish than the nets can hold. The notes describe the journey as moving “from self-sufficiency to surrender, from practical concerns to recognition of who Jesus truly is.”12 And the first job Jesus gives the new disciples is not to decide who belongs, but to gather all kinds and trust him with the rest.

Closing Question: In one sentence, where do you need to stop fixing it yourself and let someone into the boat?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 224 — The Chosen S1E5 — “The Wedding Gift” (1:01:12): The show’s take on the wedding at Cana in John 2, Jesus’s first public sign. The hosts explain first-century wedding customs and the shame of running out of wine, explore the relationship between Jesus and his mother, and describe his first followers as a “ragamuffin” band of fishermen, a stone cutter and a former demoniac. The miracle, they suggest, is a point of no return.13

What to bring next week: Read John 2:1–11 and notice what Mary says, what she does, and what she does not know yet. If you have time, also read Luke 2:41–52, the scene of Jesus at twelve in Jerusalem that opens the episode.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “The Chosen S1E3 — ‘Jesus Loves the Little Children.’” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 222. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/222. Rabbi Josiah, “smart men lack wisdom,” and Joshua the brave. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “The Chosen S1E4 — ‘The Rock on Which It Is Built.’” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 223. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/223. The calling of Simon and the miraculous catch of Luke 5:1–11, with Eden as ezer kenegdo. ↩ ↩2

  3. Ep. 223 notes. Harmonizing the Gospel accounts, rabbinical teaching, “all kinds,” Matthew, and the Pharisee divide. ↩

  4. Ep. 223 notes. Simon’s desperate prayer and the pattern of Israel’s history. ↩

  5. Ep. 223 notes. Pikuach nefesh and Eden’s challenge. ↩

  6. Ep. 223 notes. Ezer kenegdo in Genesis 2:18 and Eden’s chutzpah. ↩

  7. Ep. 223 notes. Simon’s arc from “I don’t need a lamb” to “Depart from me.” ↩

  8. Ep. 223 notes. How the show harmonizes John with the Synoptic Gospels. ↩

  9. Ep. 223 notes. The divine setup and the role of community. ↩

  10. Ep. 223 notes. Divisions among the Pharisees, tavilat t’shuvah, Nicodemus and Shmuel. ↩

  11. Ep. 223 notes. Gathering all kinds, gatekeeping, and Matthew’s stigma. ↩

  12. Ep. 223 notes. The personal summary’s description of authentic discipleship. ↩

  13. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “The Chosen S1E5 — ‘The Wedding Gift.’” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 224. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/224. Wedding customs, Jesus and Mary, the “ragamuffin” disciples, and the miracle as a point of no return. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.