BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 6 · Week 33 of 66

Episode 237

Jewish Roots — Ways Parted for a Dark History

A Slow Parting and the Long Shadow of the Teaching of Contempt

90-minute session James 2:1–4; 2 Corinthians 11:24

For group discussion. Listen to episode 237 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. A Parting, Not a Split 25 min
  3. The Teaching of Contempt 25 min
  4. Learning From Relationship 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 6 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 205 Introduction Session 6 Intro
2 206 Guest Conversation The Nature of Truth (Reed Dent)
3 207 Guest Conversation The Sacred Overlap (J. R. Briggs)
4 208 Midrash Iscah, Sarai, and Birth Orders
5 209 Midrash Noah’s Backstory and the Nephilim
6 210 Midrash The Man in the Fur Coat
7 211 Gospel of John Blue Jeans Theology
8 212 Character Study Jacob, Part 1
9 213 Character Study Jacob, Part 2
10 214 Character Study Joseph, Part 1
11 215 Character Study Joseph, Part 2
12 216 Guest Conversation Can We Talk? (Porshe Chiles)
13 217 Midrash Isaac’s Bad Eyes
14 218 Midrash Death at Dinner
15 219 Guest Conversation Loving the Adventure (Becky Solomon)
16 220 The Chosen The Chosen S1E1 — “I Have Called You by Name”
17 221 The Chosen The Chosen S1E2 — “Shabbat”
18 222 The Chosen The Chosen S1E3 — “Jesus Loves the Little Children”
19 223 The Chosen The Chosen S1E4 — “The Rock on Which It Is Built”
20 224 The Chosen The Chosen S1E5 — “The Wedding Gift”
21 225 The Chosen The Chosen S1E6 — “Indescribable Compassion”
22 226 The Chosen The Chosen S1E7 — “Invitations”
23 227 The Chosen The Chosen S1E8 — “I Am He”
24 228 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 1 (Dallas Jenkins)
25 229 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 2 (Dallas Jenkins)
26 230 Guest Conversation Unfettered (Mandy Smith)
27 231 Introducing the Team Deconstruction w/ Reed Dent
28 232 Introducing the Team Jephthah’s Daughter w/ Elle Grover Fricks
29 233 Introducing the Team Striking the Rock w/ Josh Bossé
30 234 Guest Conversation The Jewish Roots of Christianity (Jen Rosner)
31 235 Jewish Roots Tanakh and Religion
32 236 Jewish Roots Paul, Jewish Law, and Atonement in Hebrews
33 237 Jewish Roots Ways Parted for a Dark History
34 238 Jewish Roots What Difference Does It Make?
35 239 Co-host Study Abraham Considers a Catechism w/ Reed Dent
36 240 Co-host Study Sin and the Archaeology of Joshua w/ Elle Grover Fricks
37 241 Guest Conversation Don’t Exasperate Your Kids (Becky Solomon)
38 242 Spiritual Abuse Commodities and Variables
39 243 Spiritual Abuse The Place We Find Ourselves
40 244 Spiritual Abuse The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill
41 245 Spiritual Abuse Liturgy for Repentance and Healing
42 246 Guest Conversation A Look into Our Window (Eugenia Ortega)
43 247 Co-host Study Sleepless in Susa w/ Josh Bossé
44 248 Co-host Study Joy and Lot’s Untitled Wife w/ Elle Grover Fricks
45 249 Guest Conversation Escaping the Beast (Michael Burns)
46 250 The Chosen The Chosen S1E0 — “The Shepherd”
47 251 Gospel of John A Griever’s Guide to Life
48 252 Gospel of John What’s in a Logos?
49 254 Gospel of John A Wedding and Some Housekeeping
50 255 Gospel of John Water, Spirit, Darkness, Light
51 256 Gospel of John The One from Above
52 301 Gospel of John On Doubting and Locked Doors
53 302 Gospel of John Do You Even Like Me?
54 303 Gospel of John The History and Style of the Gospel of John
55 312 Parables Dissecting a Swallow
56 313 Parables The Good Samaritan
57 314 Parables The Barn Builder
58 315 Parables The Lost Son
59 316 Parables The Unforgiving Servant
60 325 Sanctuary Waking Up in the Mishkan
61 326 Sanctuary Entering the Mishkan
62 327 Sanctuary Feasting at the Mishkan
63 328 Sanctuary Listening by the Mishkan
64 329 Sanctuary Moving the Mishkan
65 330 Sanctuary Traversing the Mishkan
66 331 Sanctuary Resting with the Mishkan

Last week: We read Acts 21 as the clearest statement that Paul himself lived as a Torah-observant Jew, and we heard sacrifice described as a whole process for drawing near to God rather than a death alone.1

This week: Two more chapters of Understanding the Jewish Roots of Christianity. Dr. Isaac W. Oliver shows that church and synagogue parted slowly and unevenly, and Rabbi Dr. Eugene Korn traces the painful history of Christian anti-Judaism that followed.2

About This Session

The first half of the episode questions the idea of a single, clean split between Judaism and Christianity. Paul accepted discipline from Jewish authorities, James calls a Christian gathering a “synagogue,” Roman tax policy pushed communities apart, and Torah-observant followers of Jesus probably persisted in some places until the seventh century.3 Brent compares the process to an S-curve of technology adoption: a slow start, a rapid middle, and a long tail that never quite reaches 100%.4

The second half is hard listening. Korn describes an “adversus judaeos” (against the Jews) tradition that dominated Christian theology for about 1,500 years, from Augustine’s teaching about the curse of Cain to cathedral art, forced disputations, massacres, Martin Luther’s writings, and the conditions that made the Holocaust possible.5 The episode also traces how Jewish thought about Christianity changed over time, and it ends with cautious hope about post-Holocaust dialogue.6 This is history that belongs to every branch of the church, so we come to it to understand, not to assign blame to someone else’s tradition.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a friendship, family tie or community you were once part of that slowly drifted apart rather than ending on one particular day. Looking back, what small things moved it along?

A Parting, Not a Split 25 min

Oliver argues that the separation of church and synagogue happened gradually, region by region, for many reasons at once.

Read James 2:1–4 aloud, then 2 Corinthians 11:24.

Q1: The notes point out that the Greek of James 2:2 uses the word “synagogue” for a Christian gathering, though most modern translations render it “assembly,” and that Paul’s receiving lashes from Jewish authorities five times shows he still submitted to Jewish jurisdiction.3 Look at the wording in your own Bible for James 2:2. What does your translation call the gathering, and what picture of the earliest followers of Jesus do these two verses give you?

Q2: Optional Brent’s S-curve has a slow ramp, a rapid acceleration around events like the fiscus Judaicus (the Jewish tax), the Bar Kokhba revolt and Constantine, and a long tail of Jewish followers of Jesus into the seventh century.4 Where on that curve do you think most Christians today imagine the split happened, and what does the long tail add to the picture?

Q3: The notes list theological, political, economic and social pressures behind the separation. Nerva’s reform in 96 CE, for example, meant Jewish apostates were no longer regarded as Jews by Rome, and Christian enthusiasm that asked Gentiles to abandon their ancestral gods was seen as threatening Jewish communities’ standing.7 Why might it matter to tell the story as a slow, many-sided parting rather than as one dramatic break? What changes about how we think of Judaism and of our own origins?

Q4: The notes record that some Christians in the early centuries attended both church and synagogue (John Chrysostom condemned it), and Brent suggests there is value in learning from other faith perspectives.8 Where in your own life do you have the chance to learn from a tradition other than your own, and what helps you do that with both openness and conviction?

The Teaching of Contempt 25 min

Korn shows how theological contempt for Judaism grew, over centuries, into contempt for Jewish people and then into violence.

Q5: Korn describes the Ecclesia et Synagoga figures carved in European cathedrals: the church triumphant, erect, crowned and clear-sighted, the synagogue downcast and blindfolded, with a broken staff and falling scriptures.5 What would a worshiper absorb from walking past those figures every week, even without hearing a single sermon on the subject?

Q6: Optional The notes name a “central conundrum” in this tradition: “If Jews no longer had a divine mission, how to explain Jewish survival?” Augustine’s answer was that Jews bear the curse of Cain.5 What does it reveal about a theology when it has to explain away the continued life of a people?

Q7: The episode makes a sobering claim: while Nazism was not Christian ideology, Christian theology “played a necessary role by convincing Christians that Jews were rejected by God and deserved scorn,” after 1,500 years of anti-Judaism.9 The notes trace this through crusaders, blood libels and papal decrees, and also through Martin Luther, whose own church in Wittenberg bore a Judensau relief.10 How do ideas taught in church become permission for how people are treated outside it? Without pointing at any other tradition, what responsibility does this history place on us today in the way we preach, teach and talk casually about Jews and Judaism?

Learning From Relationship 15 min

The episode also traces how Jewish thinkers came to see Christianity, and it notes how much relationship changes understanding.

Q8: The notes describe how rabbinic thought moved over the centuries from regarding Jewish followers of Jesus as heretics, to ruling that Christians were not idolaters, to appreciating Christianity as something positive for Gentiles. They connect this to the Jewish teaching that “each covenant is independently valid” and that Gentiles need not convert to Judaism for God’s love.6 What strikes you about that generosity, given the history we have just discussed?

Q9: Optional Maimonides is noted for developing views on Christianity “without actually conversing with Christians,” which the notes say shows “how relationship versus mere book knowledge affects interfaith understanding.”6 Where have you formed opinions about a group of people mainly from books, sermons or headlines rather than from knowing them?

Q10: The episode ends with the hope that post-Holocaust dialogue has created “unprecedented opportunities for mutual understanding and appreciation.”11 What is one concrete step you could take this season toward actual relationship or understanding with Jewish neighbors, writers or communities?

Closing 15 min

This week we saw that church and synagogue did not part in a single moment. They drifted apart slowly, pushed by theology, politics, money and fear, and some Jewish followers of Jesus held on for centuries. We also faced what came after: a teaching of contempt, carved in stone and preached from pulpits, that helped prepare the ground for violence and finally for the Holocaust. That history belongs to all of us who bear the name Christian. The episode does not end in despair, though, because it shows that honest relationship can begin to heal what centuries of contempt broke.

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one thing from this history you want to remember the next time you hear Jews or Judaism spoken about in church?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 238 — Jewish Roots — What Difference Does It Make? (56:08): The final episode on the book weighs whether the Jewish-Christian schism was divinely ordained or a tragic result of human sin, introduces Mark Kinzer’s three groups that emerged in the second century, and draws the line between cultural appropriation and participation. It closes with six practical implications of Jesus’s Jewishness and four words that need fresh thought: Christ, Jews, Law and Kingdom.12

What to bring next week: Read Romans 11:17–24 (Paul’s olive tree) once before we meet. Notice who the root is, who the branches are, and what warnings Paul gives.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Jewish Roots — Paul, Jewish Law, and Atonement in Hebrews.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 236. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/236. Acts 21:17–26 as the most explicit statement of Paul’s Torah observance, and Moffitt’s view of sacrifice as a process of drawing near. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Jewish Roots — Ways Parted for a Dark History.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 237. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/237. The episode covers chapters 7 (Isaac W. Oliver) and 8 (Eugene Korn) of the book. ↩

  3. Ep. 237 notes. Paul’s submission to Jewish authorities (2 Corinthians 11), James 2:2’s use of “synagogue,” and the persistence of Torah-observant followers of Jesus. ↩ ↩2

  4. Ep. 237 notes. Brent’s S-curve model of adoption applied to the parting of the ways. ↩ ↩2

  5. Ep. 237 notes. The adversus judaeos tradition, the central conundrum, Augustine’s curse-of-Cain teaching, and the Ecclesia et Synagoga iconography. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  6. Ep. 237 notes. The evolution of Jewish responses to Christianity, the independent validity of each covenant, and Maimonides. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  7. Ep. 237 notes. The fiscus Judaicus, Nerva’s reform of 96 CE, and Roman political pressures. ↩

  8. Ep. 237 notes. Christians attending both church and synagogue, and Brent’s observation about learning from other traditions. ↩

  9. Ep. 237 notes. The Holocaust connection and the role of 1,500 years of theological anti-Judaism. ↩

  10. Ep. 237 notes. Medieval and early modern persecution and the Protestant contribution, including Luther and the Wittenberg Judensau. ↩

  11. Ep. 237 notes, Modern Implications and Brief Summary. Post-Holocaust dialogue and cautious hope. ↩

  12. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Jewish Roots — What Difference Does It Make?” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 238. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/238. The two views of the schism, Kinzer’s three groups, appropriation versus participation, and the four words. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.