BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 6 · Week 40 of 66

Episode 244

Spiritual Abuse — The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill

1 Samuel 9 and Galatians 5: Why Do We Keep Choosing Saul?

90-minute session 1 Samuel 9:1–2; Genesis 11:1–9; Galatians 5:22–23

For group discussion. Listen to episode 244 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Why Do We Do It? 25 min
  3. Both Things Are True 20 min
  4. Empire or Flourishing 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 6 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 205 Introduction Session 6 Intro
2 206 Guest Conversation The Nature of Truth (Reed Dent)
3 207 Guest Conversation The Sacred Overlap (J. R. Briggs)
4 208 Midrash Iscah, Sarai, and Birth Orders
5 209 Midrash Noah’s Backstory and the Nephilim
6 210 Midrash The Man in the Fur Coat
7 211 Gospel of John Blue Jeans Theology
8 212 Character Study Jacob, Part 1
9 213 Character Study Jacob, Part 2
10 214 Character Study Joseph, Part 1
11 215 Character Study Joseph, Part 2
12 216 Guest Conversation Can We Talk? (Porshe Chiles)
13 217 Midrash Isaac’s Bad Eyes
14 218 Midrash Death at Dinner
15 219 Guest Conversation Loving the Adventure (Becky Solomon)
16 220 The Chosen The Chosen S1E1 — “I Have Called You by Name”
17 221 The Chosen The Chosen S1E2 — “Shabbat”
18 222 The Chosen The Chosen S1E3 — “Jesus Loves the Little Children”
19 223 The Chosen The Chosen S1E4 — “The Rock on Which It Is Built”
20 224 The Chosen The Chosen S1E5 — “The Wedding Gift”
21 225 The Chosen The Chosen S1E6 — “Indescribable Compassion”
22 226 The Chosen The Chosen S1E7 — “Invitations”
23 227 The Chosen The Chosen S1E8 — “I Am He”
24 228 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 1 (Dallas Jenkins)
25 229 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 2 (Dallas Jenkins)
26 230 Guest Conversation Unfettered (Mandy Smith)
27 231 Introducing the Team Deconstruction w/ Reed Dent
28 232 Introducing the Team Jephthah’s Daughter w/ Elle Grover Fricks
29 233 Introducing the Team Striking the Rock w/ Josh Bossé
30 234 Guest Conversation The Jewish Roots of Christianity (Jen Rosner)
31 235 Jewish Roots Tanakh and Religion
32 236 Jewish Roots Paul, Jewish Law, and Atonement in Hebrews
33 237 Jewish Roots Ways Parted for a Dark History
34 238 Jewish Roots What Difference Does It Make?
35 239 Co-host Study Abraham Considers a Catechism w/ Reed Dent
36 240 Co-host Study Sin and the Archaeology of Joshua w/ Elle Grover Fricks
37 241 Guest Conversation Don’t Exasperate Your Kids (Becky Solomon)
38 242 Spiritual Abuse Commodities and Variables
39 243 Spiritual Abuse The Place We Find Ourselves
40 244 Spiritual Abuse The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill
41 245 Spiritual Abuse Liturgy for Repentance and Healing
42 246 Guest Conversation A Look into Our Window (Eugenia Ortega)
43 247 Co-host Study Sleepless in Susa w/ Josh Bossé
44 248 Co-host Study Joy and Lot’s Untitled Wife w/ Elle Grover Fricks
45 249 Guest Conversation Escaping the Beast (Michael Burns)
46 250 The Chosen The Chosen S1E0 — “The Shepherd”
47 251 Gospel of John A Griever’s Guide to Life
48 252 Gospel of John What’s in a Logos?
49 254 Gospel of John A Wedding and Some Housekeeping
50 255 Gospel of John Water, Spirit, Darkness, Light
51 256 Gospel of John The One from Above
52 301 Gospel of John On Doubting and Locked Doors
53 302 Gospel of John Do You Even Like Me?
54 303 Gospel of John The History and Style of the Gospel of John
55 312 Parables Dissecting a Swallow
56 313 Parables The Good Samaritan
57 314 Parables The Barn Builder
58 315 Parables The Lost Son
59 316 Parables The Unforgiving Servant
60 325 Sanctuary Waking Up in the Mishkan
61 326 Sanctuary Entering the Mishkan
62 327 Sanctuary Feasting at the Mishkan
63 328 Sanctuary Listening by the Mishkan
64 329 Sanctuary Moving the Mishkan
65 330 Sanctuary Traversing the Mishkan
66 331 Sanctuary Resting with the Mishkan

Last week: We named spiritual abuse as “the use of spiritual power or authority to coerce, shame or bring harm,” heard why it is so hard to see from the inside, and took “Can you question this?” as a test of a healthy community, all framed by Micah 6:8.1

This week: In part three of the series, Elle Grover Fricks, a former mental health therapist who attended Mars Hill from 2009 until it closed, joins Marty and Brent to reflect on Christianity Today’s podcast The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill.2

About This Session

As in the past two weeks, sharing is optional, you may pass on any question, and what is shared here stays here. Some of us may have been part of churches with dynamics like the ones described; please speak only about your own experience, and listen to others without rushing to judge.

The hosts use Mars Hill as a mirror rather than a target. The key question shifts from “why did he do it” or “why did they do it” to “why do we do it?”3 They name the conditions that let spiritual abuse flourish: big charismatic personalities, franchised church growth models, personal brands, us-versus-them identity, and success measured by numbers.4 Elle insists that Mars Hill was both a place of genuine transformation and community and a system that enabled abuse, and that flattening the story into pure condemnation or pure defense harms survivors.5 The episode contrasts an “empire” model of ministry success with a “flourishing” model measured by the fruit of the Spirit, and it asks whether pastoring, leading, managing and running an organization have been collapsed into one role.6

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a time you were swept up in excitement about a person, team or movement. What drew you in, and what did you notice later that you did not see at first?

Why Do We Do It? 25 min

The episode turns the question about one church’s leaders into a question about all of us.

Read 1 Samuel 9:1–2 aloud.

Q1: The notes compare a Christian culture that “prefers narcissistic leaders” to Israel demanding King Saul, “the tall, charismatic ‘donkey herder’ rather than David.”7 What does the text emphasize about Saul when we first meet him? What kinds of qualities still catch our eye when we choose or follow leaders?

Q2: The notes list what reinforces this pattern: the boomer megachurch movement, church growth conferences that franchise successful models, origin stories “packaged and leveraged for association and branding,” us-versus-them tribal identity, and metrics that measure numeric growth rather than spiritual fruit.7 Which of these have you seen up close, in any church or organization? Why do you think the hosts insist the real question is “why do we do it?”3

Read Genesis 11:1–9 aloud.

Q3: Optional Marty admits he has an almost subconscious sense of how to build platforms and “leverage energy,” which can serve the kingdom or self-interest, so he surrounds himself with people who can hold him accountable. Elle connects this to Babel, where God sees that the people “can do anything.”8 What does the Babel story suggest about the gift and the danger of being able to gather people and energy?

Q4: One attendee described viewing shocking statements as “tongue-in-cheek”: “of course he said that, but we know what he really meant because he’s saying things that need to be said.” The notes call this confirmation bias, which happens “in any context where big vision and charismatic personality create strong loyalty.”9 When a leader you admire says something that troubles you, what do you usually do with it? What would help you take that discomfort seriously?

Both Things Are True 20 min

Elle asks listeners to hold genuine good and real harm together without letting either cancel the other.

Q5: Elle describes a welcoming culture where people showed up “with tattoos, messy pasts, and current struggles without judgment,” and the notes call the “deep, authentic connection” there “a genuine good that coexisted with harmful dynamics.” She compares this to abusive relationships, where “genuine love and care coexist with harm.”10 Why do you think it is so tempting, from a distance, to flatten a story like this into all good or all bad? How does flattening it hurt the people who lived it?5

Q6: Optional The notes describe a complex picture on gender. Mark Driscoll directly called abusive men in the congregation to repentance and encouraged women to report abuse to law enforcement, which the notes call a protective factor, yet this “coexisted with” theology and messaging that caricatured women and asked them to “recede.”11 Traditions in our group hold different convictions about men’s and women’s roles, so the question here is not which view is right. What does this example teach about how protective and harmful messages can live side by side in one church?

Q7: If someone told you their old church both changed their life and deeply hurt them, what would it look like to listen without pushing them toward either verdict?

Empire or Flourishing 20 min

The episode argues that how a church defines success shapes everything else.

Read Galatians 5:22–23 aloud.

Q8: The notes contrast an empire model, where success is “numeric growth, multiplication, and replication” and “people are meeting Jesus” can justify any means, with a flourishing model, where success is the fruit of the Spirit and “that people leave in a better place spiritually, even if they never return.”6 Read against Galatians 5, what would a church measure if it took the flourishing model seriously? What would it stop measuring?

Q9: Optional The notes say contemporary church culture has merged four distinct roles (pastor, leader, manager and CEO), and they cite Eugene Peterson’s observation that a pastor can truly care for only 50–60 people.12 Elle and the hosts also recognized the culture of pulling off in six weeks an event that normally takes six months, and the alternative is a leader willing to say, “maybe we won’t get as many baptisms, maybe our church won’t grow as much, maybe we won’t have the leverage we want, but that’s okay because it’s not worth abusing our staff.”13 Where have you seen growth or deadlines take priority over people’s health?

Q10: The notes name two measures of a church’s integrity: how “the marginalized, vulnerable, and non-tithers are treated,” and how emergencies are handled “in the wings,” backstage with staff and volunteers.14 Apply those two measures to a place where you serve or have influence. What is one thing you could do to make it healthier?

Closing 15 min

This week we looked at the rise and fall of Mars Hill, not to point at one church, but to ask why we keep choosing Saul. Big personality, flashy vision, franchised models and numeric success create the conditions for spiritual abuse, and all of us help build those conditions when we reward them. Elle reminded us that genuine good and real harm can live in the same place, and that survivors need us to hold both. Galatians 5 offers a different measure of success: love, joy, peace and the rest of the Spirit’s fruit, and people leaving more whole than they came.

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one thing you want to start valuing, or stop valuing, in the leaders and communities you follow?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 245 — Spiritual Abuse — Liturgy for Repentance and Healing (23:00): The final part of the series is not a teaching episode but a liturgy: prayers of lament, confession and intercession about domestic violence and spiritual abuse, designed to be prayed more than once. The prayers insist that survivors’ suffering is not their fault, not a punishment from God and not a cross to bear, and they call the church, systems of justice and perpetrators to repentance. The episode also points to places where help is available, including RAINN and the National Domestic Violence Hotline.15

What to bring next week: The episode is meant to be prayed rather than studied. If you can, listen to it once on your own in a quiet place before we meet, and note one line of prayer you want to carry with you. Be gentle with yourself as you listen.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Spiritual Abuse — The Place We Find Ourselves.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 243. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/243. Rachael Clinton Chen’s definition, the invisibility of abuse, “Can you question this?”, and Micah 6:8. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with co-host Elle Grover Fricks. “Spiritual Abuse — The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 244. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/244. Part 3 of the series, reflecting on Christianity Today’s podcast, with Elle’s background as listed in the notes. ↩

  3. Ep. 244 notes, Key Takeaways. “Why do we do it?” and shared participation in unhealthy cultures. ↩ ↩2

  4. Ep. 244 notes. The culture of narcissistic leadership, the franchising problem, and the brand danger. ↩

  5. Ep. 244 notes. The dual reality of harm and good, and the harm of flattening the narrative. ↩ ↩2

  6. Ep. 244 notes. The empire and flourishing models of success, and the pastor/leader/manager/CEO conflation. ↩ ↩2

  7. Ep. 244 notes. The culture of narcissistic leadership and the Saul parallel. ↩ ↩2

  8. Ep. 244 notes. Marty’s reflection on platform building and Elle’s Tower of Babel parallel. ↩

  9. Ep. 244 notes. The confirmation bias of reframing. ↩

  10. Ep. 244 notes. Mars Hill as authentic community, and Elle’s comparison to abusive relationships. ↩

  11. Ep. 244 notes. Complementarian masculinity and protection of women, and abuse prevention through awareness. ↩

  12. Ep. 244 notes. The pastor/leader/manager/CEO conflation and Eugene Peterson’s observation. ↩

  13. Ep. 244 notes. The six-week event timeline and the alternative of sacrificing growth for staff health. ↩

  14. Ep. 244 notes. State of emergency and the two measures of church integrity. ↩

  15. Marty Solomon, Brent Billings and Elle Grover Fricks. “Spiritual Abuse — Liturgy for Repentance and Healing.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 245. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/245. A liturgy of lament, confession and intercession regarding domestic violence and spiritual abuse, with resources for help. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.