BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 6 · Week 30 of 66

Episode 234

Jen Rosner — The Jewish Roots of Christianity

Supersessionism, God's Faithfulness, and Jewish Followers of Jesus

90-minute session Romans 11:1–2; Romans 11:28–29

For group discussion. Listen to episode 234 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. A Jewish Follower of Jesus 20 min
  3. Supersessionism and the Faithfulness of God 30 min
  4. Spirit and Tradition 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 6 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 205 Introduction Session 6 Intro
2 206 Guest Conversation The Nature of Truth (Reed Dent)
3 207 Guest Conversation The Sacred Overlap (J. R. Briggs)
4 208 Midrash Iscah, Sarai, and Birth Orders
5 209 Midrash Noah’s Backstory and the Nephilim
6 210 Midrash The Man in the Fur Coat
7 211 Gospel of John Blue Jeans Theology
8 212 Character Study Jacob, Part 1
9 213 Character Study Jacob, Part 2
10 214 Character Study Joseph, Part 1
11 215 Character Study Joseph, Part 2
12 216 Guest Conversation Can We Talk? (Porshe Chiles)
13 217 Midrash Isaac’s Bad Eyes
14 218 Midrash Death at Dinner
15 219 Guest Conversation Loving the Adventure (Becky Solomon)
16 220 The Chosen The Chosen S1E1 — “I Have Called You by Name”
17 221 The Chosen The Chosen S1E2 — “Shabbat”
18 222 The Chosen The Chosen S1E3 — “Jesus Loves the Little Children”
19 223 The Chosen The Chosen S1E4 — “The Rock on Which It Is Built”
20 224 The Chosen The Chosen S1E5 — “The Wedding Gift”
21 225 The Chosen The Chosen S1E6 — “Indescribable Compassion”
22 226 The Chosen The Chosen S1E7 — “Invitations”
23 227 The Chosen The Chosen S1E8 — “I Am He”
24 228 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 1 (Dallas Jenkins)
25 229 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 2 (Dallas Jenkins)
26 230 Guest Conversation Unfettered (Mandy Smith)
27 231 Introducing the Team Deconstruction w/ Reed Dent
28 232 Introducing the Team Jephthah’s Daughter w/ Elle Grover Fricks
29 233 Introducing the Team Striking the Rock w/ Josh Bossé
30 234 Guest Conversation The Jewish Roots of Christianity (Jen Rosner)
31 235 Jewish Roots Tanakh and Religion
32 236 Jewish Roots Paul, Jewish Law, and Atonement in Hebrews
33 237 Jewish Roots Ways Parted for a Dark History
34 238 Jewish Roots What Difference Does It Make?
35 239 Co-host Study Abraham Considers a Catechism w/ Reed Dent
36 240 Co-host Study Sin and the Archaeology of Joshua w/ Elle Grover Fricks
37 241 Guest Conversation Don’t Exasperate Your Kids (Becky Solomon)
38 242 Spiritual Abuse Commodities and Variables
39 243 Spiritual Abuse The Place We Find Ourselves
40 244 Spiritual Abuse The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill
41 245 Spiritual Abuse Liturgy for Repentance and Healing
42 246 Guest Conversation A Look into Our Window (Eugenia Ortega)
43 247 Co-host Study Sleepless in Susa w/ Josh Bossé
44 248 Co-host Study Joy and Lot’s Untitled Wife w/ Elle Grover Fricks
45 249 Guest Conversation Escaping the Beast (Michael Burns)
46 250 The Chosen The Chosen S1E0 — “The Shepherd”
47 251 Gospel of John A Griever’s Guide to Life
48 252 Gospel of John What’s in a Logos?
49 254 Gospel of John A Wedding and Some Housekeeping
50 255 Gospel of John Water, Spirit, Darkness, Light
51 256 Gospel of John The One from Above
52 301 Gospel of John On Doubting and Locked Doors
53 302 Gospel of John Do You Even Like Me?
54 303 Gospel of John The History and Style of the Gospel of John
55 312 Parables Dissecting a Swallow
56 313 Parables The Good Samaritan
57 314 Parables The Barn Builder
58 315 Parables The Lost Son
59 316 Parables The Unforgiving Servant
60 325 Sanctuary Waking Up in the Mishkan
61 326 Sanctuary Entering the Mishkan
62 327 Sanctuary Feasting at the Mishkan
63 328 Sanctuary Listening by the Mishkan
64 329 Sanctuary Moving the Mishkan
65 330 Sanctuary Traversing the Mishkan
66 331 Sanctuary Resting with the Mishkan

Last week: Josh Bossé read the story of Moses at Kadesh as a story of grief, in which everyone but Moses knew it was time to move on.1

This week: Dr. Jennifer Rosner introduces supersessionism and the “new Jewish-Christian encounter,” opening a short series on the Jewish roots of Christianity.2

About This Session

Dr. Jennifer Rosner is a Jewish follower of Jesus who teaches systematic theology, including at Fuller Theological Seminary and the Messianic Jewish Theological Institute. She heard the gospel for the first time in college, came to faith in Jesus, and for a time “shelved” her Jewish identity because she had no models for being both. During seminary that identity “started clamoring for attention again,” and her life’s work since has been exploring what it means to be both Jewish and a follower of Jesus.3

The conversation centers on supersessionism (replacement theology), which the notes describe as often unconscious, and on the question Catholic theologian Bruce Marshall poses: how can Christians affirm both God’s ongoing covenant with Israel and the universal saving mission of Christ? Dr. Rosner also describes two perspectives within Messianic Judaism and her hope of “unparting the ways.” Marty admits he began with skepticism about Messianic Judaism and was transformed by the scholarship she introduced him to.4

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: You were invited to bring a phrase you have heard in church about Jews, Judaism or the “Old” Testament. What phrase did you bring, and where do you remember hearing it?

A Jewish Follower of Jesus 20 min

Dr. Rosner’s own story shows how deeply Judaism and Christianity have been treated as mutually exclusive.

Q1: The notes say Dr. Rosner initially “shelved” her Jewish identity because she had no models for being both Jewish and a follower of Jesus, and that this reflects a broader historical reality: many Jewish believers in Jesus have felt forced to choose one identity or the other.3 What does it tell you about the history of Judaism and Christianity that she felt she had to choose? What might it have taken for a church to help her not have to?

Q2: Optional Gerald McDermott, from Reformed circles, gave supersessionist lectures while leading a trip to Israel, until a friend kept pulling him aside at lunch: “Jerry, did you ever think about…” His thinking was revolutionized. Marty likewise began with skepticism and low expectations about Messianic Judaism and found a whole world of rigorous scholarship.5 When has a friend’s patient question changed your mind about something important? What made you able to hear it?

Supersessionism and the Faithfulness of God 30 min

The notes argue that replacement theology raises a question about whether God keeps his promises.

Q3: Supersessionism is the view that God’s covenant through Jesus supersedes or replaces his covenant with Israel, which positions Israel as “old, outdated, done away with.” It can be punitive (Israel failed, so God moved on) or developmental (Israel was just the starting point), and the notes say it is often unconscious, rarely examined.6 Think diagnostically about the tradition you know best. Where might this assumption have been present in songs, sermons, or everyday words like “old” and “new,” without anyone intending harm?

Read Romans 11:1–2 and Romans 11:28–29 aloud.

Q4: The notes name a key problem with supersessionism: “if God abandoned His covenant with Israel, can we trust His covenant commitments?”6 The notes do not cite a particular passage for this, so this one is offered for the group to test the question against. What does Paul say here about God’s people and about God’s gifts and calling? Report what you notice.

Q5: Optional Dr. Rosner says the “new Jewish-Christian encounter” is more than interfaith dialogue: its distinctive mark is that Jews and Christians begin to reassess their own traditions after real engagement with the other. She draws on John Howard Yoder’s description of Judaism as “a non non-Christian religion,” one that cannot be placed in the same category as other religions because of its inherent connection to Christianity.7 Why do you think Judaism cannot simply be filed alongside other world religions in Christian thinking?

Q6: Bruce Marshall asks, “How can we affirm both the ongoing significance and endurance of God’s covenant with the people of Israel and the universal, ecclesially mediated saving mission of Christ?” Marshall also recognizes that affirming the covenant means affirming the Jewish people’s call to Torah observance and Judaism as a set of practices: “It’s not an abstract affirmation of Jewish chosenness, but a concrete acknowledgment of Jewish religious practice as part of covenant identity.”8 Why is the concrete version harder for many Christians than the abstract one? How might holding Marshall’s question change the way you speak about Jewish neighbors or Judaism this week?

Spirit and Tradition 15 min

Two perspectives within Messianic Judaism raise a question many Christians also live with.

Q7: Optional In the book At the Foot of the Mountain, Joshua Lessard represents a Spirit-centered perspective and Dr. Rosner a tradition-engaged one. Lessard’s example: at McDonald’s, should someone be thinking about whether to order a cheeseburger (which violates kosher law) or whether God is calling them to sit next to someone and share the gospel?9 What do you think each perspective is trying to protect?

Q8: Dr. Rosner advocates a both/and approach: it is possible to honor both Spirit-led spontaneity and covenantal commitment to practice.9 Many Christian traditions lean one way, toward careful structure and pattern or toward openness to the Spirit’s leading in the moment. Which way do you lean, and what would it look like this week to honor the side that comes less naturally to you?

Closing 15 min

Dr. Jennifer Rosner’s story shows how long Judaism and Christianity have been treated as two separate, mutually exclusive worlds, so much so that she once set aside her own Jewish identity to follow Jesus. Supersessionism, often unnoticed, says God has moved on from Israel; the notes ask what that would mean for God’s faithfulness to us. Bruce Marshall’s question holds two commitments together, God’s enduring covenant with Israel and the saving mission of Christ, and asks us not to drop either one. The invitation is to let real encounter reshape how we understand our own faith.

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one assumption about Judaism or the Jewish people you want to examine more honestly?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 235 — Jewish Roots — Tanakh and Religion (43:20): Marty and Brent discuss two essays from Understanding the Jewish Roots of Christianity. One argues that the New Testament has no existence apart from the Hebrew Scriptures; the other asks whether Jesus came to start a new religion, looking at how he related to the temple, ritual purity and the Sabbath.10

What to bring next week: Read Luke 4:16–21 and notice where Jesus is, what he reads, and what he says about it afterward.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with Josh Bossé. “Introducing the Team — Striking the Rock w/ Josh Bossé.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 233. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/233. Moses’s anger as grief and everyone but Moses knowing it was time to move on. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with guest Jennifer Rosner. “Jen Rosner — The Jewish Roots of Christianity.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 234. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/234. Jewish-Christian relations, Messianic Judaism, supersessionism, and the ongoing covenant with Israel; the episode introduces the series on Understanding the Jewish Roots of Christianity. ↩

  3. Ep. 234 notes. Dr. Rosner’s background and personal journey. ↩ ↩2

  4. Ep. 234 notes. Supersessionism, Bruce Marshall’s question, two perspectives in Messianic Judaism, “unparting the ways,” and Marty’s transformation. ↩

  5. Ep. 234 notes. Gerald McDermott’s transformation and Marty’s transformation. ↩

  6. Ep. 234 notes. The definition and problems of supersessionism. ↩ ↩2

  7. Ep. 234 notes. The four markers of the new Jewish-Christian encounter and Yoder’s phrase. ↩

  8. Ep. 234 notes. Bruce Marshall’s central question and its implications. ↩

  9. Ep. 234 notes. Two perspectives within Messianic Judaism and the McDonald’s example. ↩ ↩2

  10. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Jewish Roots — Tanakh and Religion.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 235. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/235. The inseparability of the Testaments and whether Jesus intended a new religion. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.