BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 6 · Week 34 of 66

Episode 238

Jewish Roots — What Difference Does It Make?

Romans 11: From Jewish Roots to a Jewish Character

90-minute session Romans 11:17–24; Luke 22:14–20

For group discussion. Listen to episode 238 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. A Tragic Schism and Three Characters 25 min
  3. Participation, Not Appropriation 25 min
  4. Four Words and a Debt 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 6 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 205 Introduction Session 6 Intro
2 206 Guest Conversation The Nature of Truth (Reed Dent)
3 207 Guest Conversation The Sacred Overlap (J. R. Briggs)
4 208 Midrash Iscah, Sarai, and Birth Orders
5 209 Midrash Noah’s Backstory and the Nephilim
6 210 Midrash The Man in the Fur Coat
7 211 Gospel of John Blue Jeans Theology
8 212 Character Study Jacob, Part 1
9 213 Character Study Jacob, Part 2
10 214 Character Study Joseph, Part 1
11 215 Character Study Joseph, Part 2
12 216 Guest Conversation Can We Talk? (Porshe Chiles)
13 217 Midrash Isaac’s Bad Eyes
14 218 Midrash Death at Dinner
15 219 Guest Conversation Loving the Adventure (Becky Solomon)
16 220 The Chosen The Chosen S1E1 — “I Have Called You by Name”
17 221 The Chosen The Chosen S1E2 — “Shabbat”
18 222 The Chosen The Chosen S1E3 — “Jesus Loves the Little Children”
19 223 The Chosen The Chosen S1E4 — “The Rock on Which It Is Built”
20 224 The Chosen The Chosen S1E5 — “The Wedding Gift”
21 225 The Chosen The Chosen S1E6 — “Indescribable Compassion”
22 226 The Chosen The Chosen S1E7 — “Invitations”
23 227 The Chosen The Chosen S1E8 — “I Am He”
24 228 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 1 (Dallas Jenkins)
25 229 Guest Conversation Manna Program, Part 2 (Dallas Jenkins)
26 230 Guest Conversation Unfettered (Mandy Smith)
27 231 Introducing the Team Deconstruction w/ Reed Dent
28 232 Introducing the Team Jephthah’s Daughter w/ Elle Grover Fricks
29 233 Introducing the Team Striking the Rock w/ Josh Bossé
30 234 Guest Conversation The Jewish Roots of Christianity (Jen Rosner)
31 235 Jewish Roots Tanakh and Religion
32 236 Jewish Roots Paul, Jewish Law, and Atonement in Hebrews
33 237 Jewish Roots Ways Parted for a Dark History
34 238 Jewish Roots What Difference Does It Make?
35 239 Co-host Study Abraham Considers a Catechism w/ Reed Dent
36 240 Co-host Study Sin and the Archaeology of Joshua w/ Elle Grover Fricks
37 241 Guest Conversation Don’t Exasperate Your Kids (Becky Solomon)
38 242 Spiritual Abuse Commodities and Variables
39 243 Spiritual Abuse The Place We Find Ourselves
40 244 Spiritual Abuse The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill
41 245 Spiritual Abuse Liturgy for Repentance and Healing
42 246 Guest Conversation A Look into Our Window (Eugenia Ortega)
43 247 Co-host Study Sleepless in Susa w/ Josh Bossé
44 248 Co-host Study Joy and Lot’s Untitled Wife w/ Elle Grover Fricks
45 249 Guest Conversation Escaping the Beast (Michael Burns)
46 250 The Chosen The Chosen S1E0 — “The Shepherd”
47 251 Gospel of John A Griever’s Guide to Life
48 252 Gospel of John What’s in a Logos?
49 254 Gospel of John A Wedding and Some Housekeeping
50 255 Gospel of John Water, Spirit, Darkness, Light
51 256 Gospel of John The One from Above
52 301 Gospel of John On Doubting and Locked Doors
53 302 Gospel of John Do You Even Like Me?
54 303 Gospel of John The History and Style of the Gospel of John
55 312 Parables Dissecting a Swallow
56 313 Parables The Good Samaritan
57 314 Parables The Barn Builder
58 315 Parables The Lost Son
59 316 Parables The Unforgiving Servant
60 325 Sanctuary Waking Up in the Mishkan
61 326 Sanctuary Entering the Mishkan
62 327 Sanctuary Feasting at the Mishkan
63 328 Sanctuary Listening by the Mishkan
64 329 Sanctuary Moving the Mishkan
65 330 Sanctuary Traversing the Mishkan
66 331 Sanctuary Resting with the Mishkan

Last week: We saw that church and synagogue parted slowly and unevenly, and we faced the 1,500-year “teaching of contempt” that turned theological anti-Judaism into persecution, along with the cautious hope of post-Holocaust dialogue.1

This week: The final chapters of Understanding the Jewish Roots of Christianity ask the practical question: if Jesus, the apostles and the New Testament were thoroughly Jewish, what difference does that make for us?2

About This Session

Marty and Brent weigh two views of the Jewish-Christian schism: one that sees the separation as divinely ordained and irreversible, and one (the view BEMA takes) that sees it as a tragic result of human sin that God never intended.3 Drawing on Mark Kinzer, they describe three groups that emerged in the second century rather than two, and they consider Kinzer’s claim that the church needs Jews who live visibly as Jews in order to keep its Jewish character.4

The conversation then turns practical. The hosts distinguish cultural appropriation from participation (using the Passover Seder as their example), walk through Archbishop Foley Beach’s six implications of Jesus’s Jewishness, and look at Gerald R. McDermott’s four words that need reconsidering: Christ, Jews, Law and Kingdom.5 It is a hopeful close to the series, with honest attention to how much history Christians carry into any conversation with Jewish neighbors.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a time you were a guest in someone else’s tradition: a wedding, a holiday meal, a service in another church or faith. What did your hosts do that made you feel welcome without pretending you were one of them?

A Tragic Schism and Three Characters 25 min

The episode argues that the separation of Jews and Gentiles in the church was a human tragedy rather than God’s design.

Read Romans 11:17–24 aloud.

Q1: The notes summarize Paul’s image this way: the church is branches on a tree supported by Jewish roots, “not a separate tree growing from different seeds.”6 As you listen to the passage, what does Paul say supports what, and what attitude does he warn the grafted-in branches against? Name one phrase that stood out.

Q2: The hosts contrast two views of the schism. The first treats the separation as “necessary, providential, and irreversible,” and the notes observe that it is popular partly because it “poses no threat to current identities.” The second treats it as a tragic break caused by human sin, and quotes John Howard Yoder: “we should not read history as if the outcome that happened had to happen.”3 What is at stake in choosing between those two views? How does each one shape the way we see the Jewish people today?

Q3: Optional Mark Kinzer names three groups in the second century: the wider Jewish community, Jewish members of the ecclesia who followed Jesus while keeping their Jewish identity, and the emerging Gentile church.4 What changes in the story when there are three characters instead of two? Why might the middle group matter so much?

Q4: Kinzer writes, “To be Jewish, the ecclesia needs Jews, and it needs them to live in a way that accentuates rather than hides their identity as Jews.”4 The notes say the goal is a church with a Jewish character, not merely Jewish roots.7 What would a congregation have to change, in how it worships, teaches and welcomes, for that sentence to become true? What could you do in your own church to move even slightly in that direction?

Participation, Not Appropriation 25 min

The hosts draw a line between taking Jewish traditions for ourselves and participating in them alongside Jewish people.

Q5: The notes describe appropriation as Gentiles “removing the root and source” of a tradition, such as a group of only Gentiles holding “their” Passover meal, while participation means engaging Jewish practices within a community that includes Jewish presence, or from an intentionally educational posture with proper respect.8 Why does the presence of Jewish people make such a difference to the meaning of the same meal?

Read Luke 22:14–20 aloud.

Q6: Optional The notes suggest Jesus’s covenant meal might be “another renewal rather than complete replacement,” pointing out that Israel’s history is full of covenant renewals and that Hebrew has no separate word for “renewed” that differs from “new.”9 Listening to Luke 22, what in the scene connects Jesus’s meal to Israel’s story? How does “renewed covenant” sound different from “new covenant” to you?

Q7: Archbishop Foley Beach lists sharing Jesus with Jewish friends as one implication of Jesus’s Jewishness, while the notes admit it has “historically” been “done poorly.” The episode also asks Christians to remember that most Jews “have relatives who died in the Holocaust at the hands of people who identified as Christians.”10 How do you hold those two things together? If you were invited into a conversation about faith with a Jewish friend, what posture would that history ask of you?

Four Words and a Debt 15 min

McDermott asks Christians to look again at four familiar words through a Jewish lens.

Q8: McDermott’s four words are Christ (Jesus as the Jewish Messiah, not an abstract one), Jews (in John, Ioudaios often refers to Judeans or a Judean worldview rather than all Jews), Law (Torah in light of “the Messiah’s Torah”), and Kingdom (not “boring Enlightenment-style sameness” but a “beautiful divine diversity” of Israel and the nations).11 Which of the four words would change the most for you if you read it this way, and why?

Q9: Optional The first of Beach’s implications is that “it would be incongruent for followers of a Jewish Messiah to be antisemitic.”12 Where might subtle forms of contempt still show up in ordinary Christian speech or teaching, even among people who would never call themselves antisemitic?

Q10: Beach’s last implication is to acknowledge the debt Christians owe the Jewish people, who bore “the burden and heat of the day.”12 What is one concrete way you could honor that debt in the coming month?

Closing 15 min

This week closed our time with Understanding the Jewish Roots of Christianity. We heard that the split between Jews and Gentiles in the church was a tragedy, not God’s design, and that the church was meant to have a Jewish character, not just Jewish roots. We are branches grafted onto a tree we did not plant. That calls for humility in how we borrow Jewish practices, honesty about the history we carry, and gratitude toward a people who bore the burden and heat of the day.

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one thing about how you read the Bible or speak about the Jewish people that this series has changed or confirmed for you?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 239 — Abraham Considers a Catechism w/ Reed Dent (56:05): The Jewish roots series ends, and Reed Dent joins Brent to continue the conversation about deconstruction and reconstruction. Using Abraham as the model, they argue that faith is trust expressed by walking, not agreement with a catechism, and they describe an arc from innocence through experience to a renewed innocence marked by assurance rather than certainty.13

What to bring next week: Read Genesis 12:1–4 and Genesis 15:1–6 once before we meet. Ask yourself what Abraham actually knew when he set out.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Jewish Roots — Ways Parted for a Dark History.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 237. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/237. The gradual parting of the ways, the adversus judaeos tradition, and post-Holocaust dialogue. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Jewish Roots — What Difference Does It Make?” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 238. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/238. The episode covers the final three chapters of the book edited by Gerald R. McDermott. ↩

  3. Ep. 238 notes. The two views on the Jewish-Christian schism, BEMA’s position, and John Howard Yoder. ↩ ↩2

  4. Ep. 238 notes. Mark Kinzer’s three corporate characters and his statement about the ecclesia needing Jews. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  5. Ep. 238 notes. Appropriation and participation, Foley Beach’s six implications, and McDermott’s four words. ↩

  6. Ep. 238 notes. The olive tree metaphor. ↩

  7. Ep. 238 notes, Summary. A Jewish character, not merely Jewish roots. ↩

  8. Ep. 238 notes. Cultural appropriation versus participation and the practical community examples. ↩

  9. Ep. 238 notes. The covenant renewal framework. ↩

  10. Ep. 238 notes. Beach’s fifth implication and the historical context for Jewish-Christian conversation. ↩

  11. Ep. 238 notes. McDermott’s four words requiring reconsideration. ↩

  12. Ep. 238 notes. Beach’s first and sixth implications. ↩ ↩2

  13. Brent Billings and Reed Dent. “Abraham Considers a Catechism w/ Reed Dent.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 239. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/239. Faith as trust and action, and the arc from innocence to experience to renewed innocence. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.