Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- Breathed Into, Breathed Out 25 min
- Many Kinds of True 25 min
- Habits for Reading 15 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Series | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 496 | Session Introduction | A Season of Mourning |
| 2 | 497 | Guest Conversation | The Lord’s Prayer (Brad Gray and Brad Nelson) |
| 3 | 498 | The Four Pillars | Text |
| 4 | 499 | The Four Pillars | Truth in Text |
| 5 | 500 | Guest Conversation | Passover (David Rudolph) |
| 6 | 501 | The Four Pillars | Tome at the Center of the Spiral |
| 7 | 502 | The Four Pillars | Community |
| 8 | 503 | The Four Pillars | Japanese Woodworking Joint |
| 9 | 504 | The Four Pillars | Coming Home to Community |
| 10 | 505 | The Four Pillars | Discipleship |
| 11 | 506 | The Four Pillars | Talmid & Morah |
| 12 | 507 | The Four Pillars | Discipleship as a Forge |
| 13 | 508 | The Four Pillars | Wrestling |
| 14 | 509 | The Four Pillars | Don’t Let Go |
| 15 | 510 | The Four Pillars | Soul Wrestling |
| 16 | 511 | Guest Conversation | Does God See Me? (Dieula Previlon) |
| 17 | 512 | Live Episode | Ten Years of BEMA |
| 18 | 513 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Introduction |
| 19 | 514 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Rahab |
| 20 | 515 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Daughters of Zelophehad |
| 21 | 516 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Akhsah |
| 22 | 517 | Book Conversation | The Gospel of Being Human |
| 23 | 518 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Deborah |
Last week: Marty opened the four pillars with the text. He told how it became his central spiritual practice, read the passages that convince him God’s word never returns void, and urged us to make space for it while not making it an idol.
This week: Reed takes up the same pillar without hearing Marty’s take first. He asks what “God-breathed” means, argues that the Bible conveys the meaning of human experiences with God, and shows that there is more than one kind of truth.
About This Session
Reed grew up treating the Bible as a manual for getting saved and living a godly life. In this episode he begins with one Greek word in 2 Timothy 3:16, theopneustos (“God-breathed”), and asks whether Scripture is “breathed into” by God or “breathed out by” God. He finds truth in both and uses the creation of Adam, shaped from dirt and filled with God’s breath, as a picture of a Bible that is fully human and fully divine.
From there the conversation widens. Reed, Marty, and Brent use a newspaper and a poem about 9/11, a satirical headline, a scene from The Lord of the Rings, and the moment Brent became a father to show that facts are not the only kind of truth. They borrow Meir Sternberg’s image of three “faders” on a soundboard (history, theology, and aesthetics). Reed closes with practical habits for reading: notice familiar church words, read with Jesus as the lens, read with friends, follow rabbit trails, and judge your reading by its fruit. Some of these ideas may sit differently depending on what each of our traditions has taught about Scripture, and that difference is welcome in the room.
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Think of a story, song, poem, or film that told you something true about life even though none of it actually happened. What did it show you, and why do you think it landed the way it did?
Breathed Into, Breathed Out 25 min
One Greek word can be heard two ways, and each way protects something important.
Read 2 Timothy 3:14–17 aloud. Then read Genesis 2:7 and Isaiah 55:10–11.
Q1: Translations render theopneustos in 2 Timothy 3:16 as “God-breathed,” “breathed out by God,” “inspired by God,” or “given by inspiration of God.” The word joins theos (God) with pneustos (breathed), related to pneuma (breath, wind, spirit). Reed links one reading, “breathed into,” to Genesis 2:7, and the other, “breathed out by,” to Isaiah 55:11.1 Looking at the three passages side by side, what does breath or word do in each one? Where does it come from, and where does it go?
Q2: Optional Reed sums up the two readings in short phrases: “All Scripture is life-giving” and “All Scripture has a divine nature.” Each can be pushed too far. The first can turn into picking out which parts are inspired; the second can imagine a Bible that dropped from the sky and must be flawless, so that any imperfection makes the whole thing useless.2 Why do you think holding both readings together guards against both extremes?
Q3: Reed’s model is the creation of Adam: God shapes something material and human from the dirt and then breathes divine life into it, so the Bible is a human thing and a divine thing at once. He says the popular images of inspiration (dictation, or God using the authors like a glove) hold a kernel of truth but may go “a bridge too far.” Marty adds that he holds a “source” view, yet it does not push him toward literalism: if God chose to write a poem, it is an inspired poem.3 Our traditions have taught different things about how the Bible came to be. What were you taught about inspiration, what do you think that teaching was trying to protect, and how does Reed’s picture sit with you?
Q4: If “All Scripture is life-giving,” then the breath does not stop at the page. Think of a passage that has breathed life into you at some point. What was happening in your life at the time, and what did the text do?
Many Kinds of True 25 min
A newspaper and a poem can both be true without being true in the same way.
Q5: Reed compares two pieces about 9/11. The Wall Street Journal of September 12, 2001, listed flight numbers, times, and souls aboard; if it printed the wrong flight number, it would be in error. Scott Cairns’s poem “September 11” opens with Exodus’s pillar of cloud and fire and suggests that “we became the cloud and the fire.” Calling a poem “in error” means something completely different. Reed’s diagnosis: “We only have one category and we call it true/false.”4 Brent adds his own example: his Apple Watch recorded the exact second his son was born, but he says he truly became a father when he made eye contact with him at the warming table, something “not factually true in any way” that is still the real truth.5 Where in your own life do you rely on kinds of truth that a fact sheet could never hold?
Q6: Optional Meir Sternberg describes three “faders” on a soundboard: history (what happened?), ideology or theology (what does it mean?), and aesthetics (what style best communicates it?). Different passages mix them at different levels, and none is ever simply at zero.6 Go back to Genesis 2:7 from earlier. Where would you set each of the three faders for that verse, and why?
Q7: The notes name a fear underneath all this: “If the Bible fails in the factual category, we assume it cannot be true in any sense.”7 Asked whether the serpent in Genesis actually spoke, Karl Barth reportedly answered, “Madam, it doesn’t matter whether or not the serpent spoke; all that matters is what he said.”8 What feels freeing about Barth’s answer, and what feels unsettling? Where do you think that fear comes from?
Q8: Quoting Frederick Buechner, Reed says every doctrine “was a human experience first.” The divinity of Christ, for example, began in the experience of ordinary people who knew Jesus of Nazareth and found something happening in their lives that had never happened before.9 Pick one belief that matters deeply to you. What experience, yours or someone else’s, sits underneath it?
Habits for Reading 15 min
Reed closes with practices that help us read with love rather than fear.
Q9: Reed borrows the idea of “first-order language” from psychology: words a group finds so obviously true that nobody questions them, until they lose their meaning. He calls this “Christianese,” and his examples include faith, righteousness, and “by grace you have been saved.”10 Choose one of those words or phrases. How would you explain what you mean by it without using any other church words?
Q10: Optional Following Greg Boyd, Reed suggests going back to the person of Jesus when a passage is hard, and asking: “How would Jesus interpret this? How would he encourage his disciples to live it out?” He also recommends reading in havruta, reading aloud with friends where no question is off limits and the conversation itself is the fruit.11 Which of these two habits do you most need, and what would it take to practice it?
Q11: Reed’s last test is fruit. If a way of reading produces fear and destruction rather than love, question it. When certainty conflicts with loving your neighbor or your enemy, choose love and re-examine the certainty.12 Looking honestly at your own way of reading Scripture, what fruit has it produced in you and in your relationships? What, if anything, might you want to re-examine?
Closing 15 min
Reed invites us to loosen our grip on a single, factual kind of truth. Scripture is God-breathed in two ways: it comes from God, and it gives life, shaped from something human and filled with divine breath. When we read it as real people conveying the meaning of their encounters with God, poetry, satire, story, and history can all carry truth. The habits Reed offers keep us honest: question familiar words, read through the lens of Jesus, read with others, and test our reading by its fruit. A way of reading that leads to love of neighbor and enemy is a way of reading in step with Jesus.
Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one way your reading of Scripture could become more life-giving this month?
Looking Ahead
Ep. 500 — Passover (56:23): BEMA marks its 500th episode with Rabbi Dr. David Rudolph, a Messianic Jewish New Testament scholar, who traces how the early church dated Pascha (Passover), its central yearly celebration. The story moves from Gentile believers depending on the Jewish community to know when Passover fell, to the Council of Nicaea in 325 deliberately cutting the Christian calendar loose from Jewish reckoning in openly anti-Jewish language. It gives a concrete window into the “parting of the ways” that Marty described in week 3, when he said the church lost something important in splitting from Judaism.
What to bring next week: Read Acts 15, the Jerusalem Council. Note what the apostles decided Gentile believers did and did not have to take on, and come ready to share one detail that surprised you.
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with co-host Reed Dent. “The Four Pillars — Truth in Text.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 499. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/499. The translations and word parts of theopneustos, and Reed’s links to Genesis 2:7 and Isaiah 55:11. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. The emphasis and possible misuse of each reading of theopneustos. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. Popular images of inspiration, Marty’s “source” view, and Reed’s both/and model drawn from the creation of Adam. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. The 9/11 example of the Wall Street Journal and Scott Cairns’s poem, and the problem of having only one category of truth. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. Brent’s account of becoming a father as a truth beyond facts. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. Meir Sternberg’s three faders from The Poetics of Biblical Narrative. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. The fear that factual failure means the Bible cannot be true in any sense. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. Karl Barth’s reported answer about the serpent in Genesis. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. Frederick Buechner on doctrine beginning as human experience. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. First-order language and “Christianese.” ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. Jesus as the lens for interpretation (Greg Boyd) and reading in havruta. ↩
-
Ep. 499 notes. Judging a way of reading by its fruit and choosing love when certainty conflicts with it. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.