BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 10 · Week 13 of 23

Episode 508

The Four Pillars — Wrestling

The Four Pillars: Wrestling

90-minute session Exodus 3:1–6; Acts 10; Acts 15

For group discussion. Listen to episode 508 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Why We Wrestle: Two Cathedrals 20 min
  3. Moses Turns Aside 20 min
  4. Peter on the Rooftop 25 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 10 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 496 Session Introduction A Season of Mourning
2 497 Guest Conversation The Lord’s Prayer (Brad Gray and Brad Nelson)
3 498 The Four Pillars Text
4 499 The Four Pillars Truth in Text
5 500 Guest Conversation Passover (David Rudolph)
6 501 The Four Pillars Tome at the Center of the Spiral
7 502 The Four Pillars Community
8 503 The Four Pillars Japanese Woodworking Joint
9 504 The Four Pillars Coming Home to Community
10 505 The Four Pillars Discipleship
11 506 The Four Pillars Talmid & Morah
12 507 The Four Pillars Discipleship as a Forge
13 508 The Four Pillars Wrestling
14 509 The Four Pillars Don’t Let Go
15 510 The Four Pillars Soul Wrestling
16 511 Guest Conversation Does God See Me? (Dieula Previlon)
17 512 Live Episode Ten Years of BEMA
18 513 Women in Joshua & Judges Introduction
19 514 Women in Joshua & Judges Rahab
20 515 Women in Joshua & Judges Daughters of Zelophehad
21 516 Women in Joshua & Judges Akhsah
22 517 Book Conversation The Gospel of Being Human
23 518 Women in Joshua & Judges Deborah

Last week: Reed Dent described discipleship as a forge: shared, ordinary life slowly brings a relationship “up to temperature,” and only then can a word of wisdom or challenge land.1

This week: Marty and Brent begin the fourth pillar, wrestling, which Marty calls the “universal pillar” because it can happen anywhere, at any time, in any setting.2

About This Session

This episode argues that questions are not a threat to faith. Marty starts from the claim that Western Christianity, built heavily on philosophy, has drifted toward an obsession with certainty, so that our confidence often rests in a theological system rather than in the living God. He is careful to say this is not a rejection of creeds or orthodoxy. His central picture is Dunkeld Cathedral in Scotland, where iron that once reinforced the stone is now pushing the walls apart, so the building has to be carefully taken down and rebuilt to be saved. Brent adds Notre-Dame, where restoration meant returning to older materials and methods.

The hosts then read two passages. Moses at the burning bush shows the posture wrestling needs: curiosity, attention and wonder. Peter’s vision in Acts 10 shows the process, as scripture, tradition and experience collide and Peter follows God rather than his belief system. Marty closes with a method from constructive theology (critique, retrieval, construction) and with the claim that the Holy Spirit and prayer run through all four pillars.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of an old building, a family home or a well-used object that has had to be repaired or renovated. What did the people doing the work have to keep, and what did they have to replace?

Why We Wrestle: Two Cathedrals 20 min

Marty and Brent use two restored cathedrals to explain what wrestling is for.

Q1: Dunkeld Cathedral is about 800 years old. Its stone was reinforced with iron, and over the centuries that iron has aged and expanded until it is “pushing the building apart.” To save the cathedral, restorers must take it apart stone by stone, remove what once helped but now harms, add new supports and rebuild.3 What details of this picture stand out to you? What does it suggest about how something good in our faith can, over time, start to cause harm?

Q2: Optional Brent’s counterpoint is Notre-Dame, restored after the 2019 fire with wood from the original sources and traditional methods. In his telling, wrestling asks two questions at once: What should we return to? and What should we rebuild differently? Because it holds both, wrestling “always involves tension.”4 Where have you seen a person or a church need the first question more than the second, or the other way around?

Q3: Marty says creeds, orthodoxy and systematic theology have real value; the trouble begins when certainty becomes the goal. The notes summarize his core problem this way: “We say our faith is in God, but under pressure it often turns out to rest in a system rather than a person.” He also says of theology, “It’s not a test that we’re going to pass. It’s a life that we’re going to live.”5 Every tradition in this room (Church of Christ, Baptist, Christian Church, Methodist) has its own strengths and its own “iron.” Without judging any tradition, including your own, how could you tell in your own life whether your confidence is resting in a system or in a person?

Moses Turns Aside 20 min

The burning bush becomes a portrait of the posture wrestling requires.

Read Exodus 3:1–6 aloud.

Q4: Listen for what Moses sees, what he says to himself and what he does before God speaks. What does the passage tell us about the bush, and which detail seems to be the one that matters? The notes point out that a burning bush in the wilderness was not remarkable in itself; what caught Moses’s attention was that the bush was not consumed.6

Q5: The rabbis read this scene as revealing Moses’s character. He needed curiosity (wanting to know more), attention (watching long enough to notice something unusual) and wonder (being open to something beyond his understanding). Brent adds that a shepherd leaving his flock shows how compelling the sight must have been. The hosts compare it to a well-made gas fireplace: you can only tell it from a real fire by watching long enough to see whether the wood burns.7 Which of the three (curiosity, attention, wonder) comes most naturally to you, and which is hardest? What tends to keep you from turning aside?

Q6: Optional Marty contrasts puzzles, which pair a problem with a solution, with mystery, where “walking through one door shows you four more.” He does not call puzzles bad, but he asks, “Where do I settle for puzzles when the greater reward is found in mystery?” He also introduces hypocognition: assumptions so deeply built in that we no longer have words for them.8 Where in your own faith are you tempted to want a puzzle solved when a mystery might be the greater gift?

Peter on the Rooftop 25 min

Peter’s vision shows scripture, tradition and experience colliding, and what faithful wrestling does with the collision.

Read Acts 10:9–29 aloud.

Q7: As you listen, sort what you hear into three piles: what Peter knows from scripture, what his tradition taught him and what he experiences on the roof and at Cornelius’s house. Marty stresses that avoiding table fellowship with Gentiles was a “biblically based, logical tradition,” not arbitrary exclusion. The notes sum up Peter’s realization: “The Bible called pork unclean; it never called the Gentile unclean.”9 What do you notice about how Peter moves from refusal to his conclusion that he “should not call anyone impure or unclean”?

Q8: Optional The hosts compare models for holding scripture, tradition and experience. Marty’s graduate program treats them as an equal triangle. Richard Rohr’s tricycle has one large front wheel that steers and two smaller back wheels; Rohr puts experience in front, while Marty prefers scripture as the front wheel. Marty also offers his own framing: the world we live in, the word we live by and the work we’re called to.10 If you drew your own tricycle, which wheel actually steers most of the time, and which do you wish steered?

Q9: Marty names a three-step method from constructive theology: critique (think critically about something), retrieval (recover what is right and good) and construction (build something new from what was recovered). Peter critiques his tradition without throwing out Judaism, retrieves what scripture actually says and constructs the worldview of the gospel. At the Jerusalem Council the church does this together: “It seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us.”11 The notes suggest a practice: take one belief you hold firmly and ask where it came from (scripture, tradition or experience).12 Choose one belief, or one “Cornelius moment” with someone outside your tradition who clearly loves God. What might critique, retrieval and construction look like for you, and who would you want to pray it through with?

Closing 15 min

Dunkeld Cathedral is still standing because someone was willing to put up scaffolding and look honestly at what was holding it together. Wrestling, as Marty describes it, is that scaffolding: it critiques, retrieves what is good and builds again. Brent reminds us that sometimes the rebuilding means returning to something old. Moses shows us the posture, curious and attentive enough to notice a bush that does not burn up. Peter shows us the process, following the God behind his system when the two seemed to pull apart. Held in prayer and in community, questions become one of the ways faith keeps growing.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one question you are willing to keep open this week instead of rushing to an answer?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 509 — Don’t Let Go (42:13): Brent is joined by Elle Grover Fricks, who offers three ways to wrestle, each building on the last: with the text (she gives eight readings of the transfiguration), with our community and tradition (choosing curious study over cynicism) and with God himself through daily practice. Her image is Jacob at the Jabbok, who would not let go until he was blessed.13

What to bring next week:

  • Read Luke 9:28–36 and write down one detail of the transfiguration that puzzles you.
  • Optional: notice one line in a creed, hymn, prayer or church practice you know that bothers or confuses you, and bring it if you are willing to share.

References

  1. Brent Billings with Reed Dent. “The Four Pillars — Discipleship as a Forge.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 507. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/507. Reed’s forge metaphor: shared life brings the relationship “up to temperature” before a word of wisdom, rebuke, encouragement or call can land. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “The Four Pillars — Wrestling.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 508. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/508. Wrestling as the “universal pillar” that treats questions as legitimate. ↩

  3. Ep. 508 notes. The Dunkeld Cathedral metaphor and its application to faith as scaffolding. ↩

  4. Ep. 508 notes. Brent’s Notre-Dame counterpoint and the two questions wrestling holds in tension. ↩

  5. Ep. 508 notes. Western Christianity and the “sin of certainty”; theology as meaning-making. ↩

  6. Ep. 508 notes. The detail of the bush not being consumed in Exodus 3. ↩

  7. Ep. 508 notes. The rabbinic reading of Moses’s curiosity, attention and wonder; Brent on the shepherd leaving his flock; the gas fireplace test. ↩

  8. Ep. 508 notes. Puzzles versus mystery and the idea of hypocognition from Karen Swallow Prior. ↩

  9. Ep. 508 notes. Peter’s tradition as biblically based and his realization about people, not food, in Acts 10. ↩

  10. Ep. 508 notes. The triangle, Richard Rohr’s tricycle and Marty’s “World, Word, Work” framing. ↩

  11. Ep. 508 notes. Critique, retrieval and construction from constructive theology; the Holy Spirit in the Jerusalem Council of Acts 15. ↩

  12. Ep. 508 notes. The “tracing a belief” and “modern Cornelius moments” applications. ↩

  13. Brent Billings with Elle Grover Fricks. “The Four Pillars — Don’t Let Go.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 509. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/509. Elle’s three ways to wrestle and the image of Jacob refusing to let go until blessed. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.