BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 10 · Week 15 of 23

Episode 510

The Four Pillars — Soul Wrestling

The Four Pillars: Soul Wrestling

90-minute session Genesis 32:22–30; Luke 24:13–35

For group discussion. Listen to episode 510 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Brain Wrestling and Soul Wrestling 20 min
  3. A Night at the Jabbok 30 min
  4. Limping Toward Esau 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 10 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 496 Session Introduction A Season of Mourning
2 497 Guest Conversation The Lord’s Prayer (Brad Gray and Brad Nelson)
3 498 The Four Pillars Text
4 499 The Four Pillars Truth in Text
5 500 Guest Conversation Passover (David Rudolph)
6 501 The Four Pillars Tome at the Center of the Spiral
7 502 The Four Pillars Community
8 503 The Four Pillars Japanese Woodworking Joint
9 504 The Four Pillars Coming Home to Community
10 505 The Four Pillars Discipleship
11 506 The Four Pillars Talmid & Morah
12 507 The Four Pillars Discipleship as a Forge
13 508 The Four Pillars Wrestling
14 509 The Four Pillars Don’t Let Go
15 510 The Four Pillars Soul Wrestling
16 511 Guest Conversation Does God See Me? (Dieula Previlon)
17 512 Live Episode Ten Years of BEMA
18 513 Women in Joshua & Judges Introduction
19 514 Women in Joshua & Judges Rahab
20 515 Women in Joshua & Judges Daughters of Zelophehad
21 516 Women in Joshua & Judges Akhsah
22 517 Book Conversation The Gospel of Being Human
23 518 Women in Joshua & Judges Deborah

Last week: Elle Grover Fricks gave us three arenas for wrestling (the text, our community and tradition, and God himself) and a blessing to grip all three and not let go.1

This week: The Four Pillars series closes with Reed Dent’s reflection on Jacob at the Jabbok and the difference between wrestling with ideas and wrestling with our own souls.2

About This Session

Reed does not walk through Genesis 32 line by line. Instead he reads it the way Lectio Divina works, noticing phrases that stand out and asking what God brings to mind through them. His main move is to separate “brain wrestling” (working through doctrines, interpretations and ideas about God) from “soul wrestling” (a personal struggle with God’s presence, with our own identity and with how the way of Jesus asks us to treat other people). Both matter, but people often try to settle a soul problem with brain work.

Moving through the passage, Reed reflects on Jacob being left alone, on struggling “with God and with humans,” on the question “What is your name?” and on what it means to overcome when you walk away limping. The match, the hosts suggest, prepares Jacob to meet his estranged brother Esau with a softened heart. The episode’s tagline sums it up: “You came in looking for better answers but ended up leaving a better person.”

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Last week you were invited to read Genesis 32:22–30 slowly and note one phrase that stood out. If you did, share the phrase without explaining it. If you didn’t, describe a place where you tend to do your best thinking or praying alone.

Brain Wrestling and Soul Wrestling 20 min

Reed names two levels of wrestling and warns that it is easy to live on only one.

Q1: Reed’s framework sorts wrestling into two levels, each played out with humans, with God and with ourselves.3

  • Brain wrestling with humans: re-examining interpretations, doctrines, traditions, sermons and denominational positions.
  • Soul wrestling with humans: struggling with Jesus’s commands about other people: forgive, love your enemies, “Who is my neighbor?”
  • Brain wrestling with God: asking who God is and why God acts or doesn’t act.
  • Soul wrestling with God: asking where God is; longing for presence when God feels absent.
  • Brain wrestling with self: thinking about your beliefs.
  • Soul wrestling with self: asking “Who am I?” and staying open to change.

Which of these describe the kind of wrestling you have done most, and which feel less familiar?

Q2: Optional Marty compares Reed’s approach to Lectio Divina, which asks what God is saying to me through these words today. Historical-critical reading asks what the text meant to its first audience. The notes say BEMA usually works in the first mode, this episode deliberately uses the second, and “both are valid ways to engage scripture.”4 What does each way of reading offer that the other might miss?

Q3: The notes put one warning bluntly: “You can use God to avoid God.” On BEMA’s Israel and Turkey trips, Reed noticed people asking detailed contextual questions to avoid harder topics like their marriage or their kids. Marty admits he often tries to satisfy a soul need with brain answers.5 If study ever becomes a way of keeping God at arm’s length for you, what does that look like? What might you be avoiding?

A Night at the Jabbok 30 min

Reed reads Jacob’s story phrase by phrase, listening for what God might be stirring up.

Read Genesis 32:22–30 aloud, slowly, twice. Leave a short silence between the readings.

Q4: Without explaining or analyzing yet, which word or phrase caught your attention in this reading? After everyone who wishes to has shared, what do you notice about the phrases the group chose?

Q5: “Jacob was left alone.” Reed reads this as a picture of going “to the end of yourself,” and notes that Jesus, Elijah and Moses were led into solitary places because some work can only happen there. Marty pushes back: nobody stripped Jacob; he sent everyone away himself. Sometimes we push ourselves into lonely deserts, and God says, “You’ve done this to yourself. I’ll meet you here.” Brent wonders whether the wrestling started right away or only after hours alone.6 How do these readings of Jacob’s solitude add to each other?

Q6: Optional The man tells Jacob he has struggled “with God and with humans.” Reed found it freeing to realize that much of his own theological struggle was with people’s representations of God, not with God. When hard questions feel like falling down a well, he offers the image of a cenote: a sinkhole that looks like a dangerous pit, with beautiful pools underneath. The notes add that wrestling doesn’t always overturn tradition: “Sometimes the truth is hard because it isn’t what you were taught. Sometimes it’s hard because it is what you were taught.”7 Where have you found that a struggle you thought was with God was really with what people had told you about God?

Q7: Jacob asks for a blessing and gets a question back: “What is your name?” His new name, Israel, means “one who struggles with God.” Reed reads this as: maybe what I’m missing isn’t knowledge of God but understanding of myself. He also observes that the biblical writers ask where God is, not whether God exists; Job and the Psalmists ask why God is hiding his face.8 Which question sits closer to your life right now: “Where is God?” or “Who am I?” Answer only as much as you want to; you are welcome to simply hold the question.

Limping Toward Esau 15 min

The match ends with a limp, a new name and a reconciliation Jacob never expected.

Q8: Marty says overcoming isn’t coming out washed clean and victorious; it can mean coming out “even more of a mess, limping.” At Peniel Jacob says, “I saw God face to face, and yet my life was spared.” Brent notices that Jacob begins the night gripping hard and ends it saying, in effect, “God spared me. I didn’t have anything to do with it.” The hosts warn that “I won’t let you go unless you bless me” can be bent into prosperity thinking, and say the wrestling should center on getting God.9 How does this change what you think of as “blessing” or “winning” in your own struggles?

Q9: Optional Jacob is about to meet Esau. Marty says the encounter left him “soft enough, open enough” to receive Esau’s forgiveness. Reed also calls for a “tag team”: friends who honor your discomfort without bulldozing it with quick answers. The notes suggest taking time alone with God before a hard conversation so your own heart can be softened first.10 Without naming anyone, where might you need that kind of softening, or whose questions could you sit with this week without fixing them? What would one step look like?

Closing 15 min

Jacob goes out alone, grapples all night without knowing his opponent, asks for a blessing and gets a question about himself instead. He leaves with a new name and a limp, and only afterward realizes he has seen God face to face, much like the disciples on the road to Emmaus who recognized Jesus only in hindsight. Reed’s point for those of us who love studying the text is that study is good, but it can also keep God at a distance. Soul wrestling means staying in the ring, saying “I don’t know” when that is true, and insisting on God’s presence rather than on mastery. The goal is to become someone who can cross the river and embrace an estranged brother.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one thing the four pillars (text, community, discipleship, wrestling) have stirred in you that you want to carry forward?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 511 — Dieula Previlon: Does God See Me? (1:01:45): With the Four Pillars series finished, Brent and Elle Grover Fricks sit down with Dieula Previlon, a counselor, ordained minister and founder of Elevate Her International Ministries. The conversation covers why the church often struggles to receive hurting people, why safety must come before anyone shares their story, lament as an act of faith, the place of the body in spiritual practice, and the West African practice of Sankofa (remembering the past honestly).11 Because the topic is trauma, our group will keep every question optional; no one will be asked to tell their story.

What to bring next week:

  • Read Psalm 13 aloud once, slowly, and notice where in your body (stomach, chest, shoulders) you feel tension or ease as you read. Jot down a word or two.

References

  1. Brent Billings with Elle Grover Fricks. “The Four Pillars — Don’t Let Go.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 509. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/509. Elle’s three arenas of wrestling and her closing blessing. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings, with co-host Reed Dent. “The Four Pillars — Soul Wrestling.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 510. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/510. The episode closes the Four Pillars series with Reed’s reflection on Genesis 32. ↩

  3. Ep. 510 notes. Reed’s table of brain wrestling and soul wrestling with humans, God and self. ↩

  4. Ep. 510 notes. Lectio Divina compared with historical-critical reading. ↩

  5. Ep. 510 notes. Using God to avoid God; the trip example; Marty’s admission about brain answers to soul needs. ↩

  6. Ep. 510 notes. “Jacob was left alone”: Reed on solitude, Marty’s counterpoint and Brent’s question. ↩

  7. Ep. 510 notes. Struggling with people’s representations of God, the cenote image and wrestling that does not always overturn tradition. ↩

  8. Ep. 510 notes. “What is your name?”, the name change from Jacob to Israel and the question of “where,” not “whether.” ↩

  9. Ep. 510 notes. Overcoming redefined, Peniel and the warning about a prosperity reading of the blessing. ↩

  10. Ep. 510 notes. The wrestling as preparation to meet Esau, the “tag team” and wrestling before reconciliation. ↩

  11. Brent Billings and Elle Grover Fricks, with guest Dieula Previlon. “Dieula Previlon — Does God See Me?” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 511. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/511. The topics of the interview with Dieula Previlon. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.