Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- Following the Rabbi 30 min
- From Copying to Being Sent 20 min
- What We Mean by Discipleship 15 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Series | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 496 | Session Introduction | A Season of Mourning |
| 2 | 497 | Guest Conversation | The Lord’s Prayer (Brad Gray and Brad Nelson) |
| 3 | 498 | The Four Pillars | Text |
| 4 | 499 | The Four Pillars | Truth in Text |
| 5 | 500 | Guest Conversation | Passover (David Rudolph) |
| 6 | 501 | The Four Pillars | Tome at the Center of the Spiral |
| 7 | 502 | The Four Pillars | Community |
| 8 | 503 | The Four Pillars | Japanese Woodworking Joint |
| 9 | 504 | The Four Pillars | Coming Home to Community |
| 10 | 505 | The Four Pillars | Discipleship |
| 11 | 506 | The Four Pillars | Talmid & Morah |
| 12 | 507 | The Four Pillars | Discipleship as a Forge |
| 13 | 508 | The Four Pillars | Wrestling |
| 14 | 509 | The Four Pillars | Don’t Let Go |
| 15 | 510 | The Four Pillars | Soul Wrestling |
| 16 | 511 | Guest Conversation | Does God See Me? (Dieula Previlon) |
| 17 | 512 | Live Episode | Ten Years of BEMA |
| 18 | 513 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Introduction |
| 19 | 514 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Rahab |
| 20 | 515 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Daughters of Zelophehad |
| 21 | 516 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Akhsah |
| 22 | 517 | Book Conversation | The Gospel of Being Human |
| 23 | 518 | Women in Joshua & Judges | Deborah |
Last week: Elle Grover Fricks described community as witnesses who tell God’s story “again,” like a bride sharing letters from her absent groom. She named three barriers that keep people away (church hurt, intellectual superiority and self-sufficiency) and invited us to come home anyway.
This week: Marty turns to the third pillar, discipleship as Jesus practiced it, and separates the rare calling of intensive discipleship from principles any of us can live.
About This Session
Marty begins with humility. He admits he has spoken too confidently in the past about how rabbinic discipleship worked, and he places BEMA’s teaching within the scholarly “quests for the historical Jesus.” He then describes three features of discipleship in Jesus’ world: a full-time commitment, a way of learning built on imitation, and a progression from copying the rabbi, to interpreting, to friendship, to being sent. He traces these through five Gospel passages, including a fresh reading of Peter sinking in the water.
The second half compares this with how churches usually use the word “discipleship.” Marty tells the story of his own intensive discipleship in campus ministry, admits he is not doing it right now, and insists that not being in this kind of discipleship says nothing about anyone’s standing before God. He closes with principles open to every believer.
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Think of someone who taught you a skill by letting you watch and then try it yourself (cooking, a trade, a sport, an instrument, a job). What did you pick up from them that they never actually put into words?
Following the Rabbi 30 min
Marty describes what discipleship looked like in Jesus’ world, starting with how much we can and cannot know.
Q1: Optional Marty says his language about discipleship has “softened” over the years: no less passionate, but more careful. He thinks the critique of “received” history is valid but often goes too far, and that the truth is usually “somewhere in the middle”1. Why might a teacher’s admission that he once overstated things make the rest of what he says easier to trust rather than harder?
Read Matthew 4:18–22 aloud.
Q2: Marty describes discipleship in this world as a 24/7/365 commitment, not “show up on Tuesdays and Thursdays.” Disciples went where the rabbi went, slept where he slept and ate where he ate2. List everything these four men leave in the passage. What does the text show you about what following Jesus cost them, and what it did not tell them in advance?
Read Matthew 14:22–33 aloud.
Q3: Marty’s reading of Peter is that he reasons, “If it’s really you, you’d want me to do this too,” because a rabbi doesn’t do anything he doesn’t want his disciples to copy. Peter really does walk on water. When he sinks, he has lost faith in himself, not in Jesus, so “Why did you doubt?” means “Why don’t you believe you can do what I’ve called you to do?”3 We often say, “I can’t be like Jesus.” Where in your own life do you hear yourself saying that, and what would change if Jesus believed you could?
From Copying to Being Sent 20 min
Marty traces how a disciple grows from repeating the rabbi to being sent out under his authority.
Q4: Marty reads “the keys” in Matthew 16 as likely permission to interpret and teach independently while staying aligned with the rabbi; before this, a disciple could only say “I’ve heard my rabbi say…”4 In John 15 the disciples move from students to something close to peers, and Jesus reverses the usual pattern by choosing them instead of waiting to be asked5.
Read John 15:12–17 aloud.
What words in this passage mark a change in the relationship? What does it suggest to you that Jesus took the initiative with the Twelve?
Q5: Optional Marty points out two unusual things in the Great Commission. Jesus keeps his authority instead of passing it on, and he sends out all of them, including those described in “But some doubted”6.
Read Matthew 28:16–20 aloud.
What does it mean to you that the doubters were sent too? How might that shape the way you treat your own doubts, or someone else’s?
What We Mean by Discipleship 15 min
Marty compares rabbinic discipleship with the ways churches use the word today.
Q6: Marty names three common modern meanings of discipleship: disciple as believer (common, he says, in his own Christian Church/Church of Christ tradition), discipleship as spiritual formation, and discipleship as church assimilation through small groups. He considers each one fine as language, but none of them is what Jesus did with Peter, James and John. Rabbinic discipleship was rare, and not being in it says nothing about anyone’s standing before God7. Which of these meanings did you grow up with? What did that use of the word get right, and what might it have made harder to see?
Q7: Optional Marty admits his campus ministry discipleship “could get real culty real quick,” so the group stayed tied to the wider church through worship, small groups, service and peer accountability8. What other safeguards would you want around any close mentoring relationship, so that it stays healthy?
Q8: Marty admits, “I’m not doing discipleship right now,” and reminds himself, “I’m not letting Jesus down”9. Even so, he offers principles for everyone: follow someone a step or two ahead of you, reach back to someone a step or two behind, and remember that “It’s one thing to follow Jesus. It’s another thing to know that somebody is watching you follow Jesus”10. Think of the person you brought to mind this week. Who is a step or two behind you, and what is one small, “two-degree” step you could take with either of them?
Closing 15 min
Marty starts by admitting he has sometimes claimed more certainty than the evidence supports, and then shows what still holds up. In Jesus’ world a disciple gave the rabbi their whole life and learned by imitating him, moving from copying, to interpreting, to friendship, to being sent. When Jesus calls us to imitate him, he believes we can, even when we don’t. That intensive kind of discipleship was always rare, and not being in it does not make anyone less faithful. The principles are still open to all of us, and as Brent reminds us, there are no shortcuts: even Jesus took about three years11.
Closing Question: In one sentence, where do you most need to hear Jesus say, “Why don’t you believe you can do what I’ve called you to do?”
Looking Ahead
Ep. 506 — Talmid & Morah (56:25): Elle Grover Fricks joins Marty and Brent to look at the Hebrew, Greek and Latin words for “disciple,” and she traces a pattern where the language of discipling keeps appearing next to the language of children. From it she argues that making disciples often means becoming a spiritual parent, taking responsibility for someone while protecting their independence. The episode also gives the “I do, we do, you do” model and a strong case for naming what people do well.
What to bring next week: Read 1 Corinthians 4:15 and 1 Timothy 1:2 and notice what Paul calls the people he invested in. Then think of one person who said out loud what you were doing right, and what it did for you.
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “The Four Pillars — Discipleship.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 505. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/505. Marty’s language has “softened,” and he holds that the critique of received history is valid but often goes too far, with the truth “somewhere in the middle.” ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. The 24/7/365 nature of rabbinic discipleship, shown in Matthew 4:18–22. ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. Marty’s reading of Matthew 14:22–33: Peter lost faith in himself, not in Jesus, and Jesus’ question means “Why don’t you believe you can do what I’ve called you to do?” ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. “The keys” (Matthew 16:13–20) likely meant permission to interpret and teach independently under the rabbi’s authority. ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. In John 15:12–17 the disciples become near-peers, and “You did not choose me, but I chose you” reverses the normal pattern. ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. In the Great Commission Jesus keeps his authority and sends out believers and doubters alike. ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. Three modern meanings of discipleship; disciple-as-believer is common in Marty’s own tradition; rabbinic discipleship was rare and says nothing about anyone’s standing before God. ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. Marty’s campus ministry experiment and the safeguards that kept it tied to the wider church. ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. Marty’s admission that he is not doing discipleship right now, and his reminder that he is not letting Jesus down. ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. Discipleship principles for everyone, including following someone ahead, reaching back to someone behind, accountability and a “two-degree shift.” ↩
-
Ep. 505 notes. The episode’s summary, including Brent’s point that there are no shortcuts because Jesus spent about three years with his disciples. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.