BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 10 · Week 5 of 23

Episode 500

David Rudolph — Passover

Passover, Easter, and the Parting of the Ways

90-minute session Acts 15:1–21; John 10:17–18; Ephesians 2:11–22; 1 Corinthians 9:19–23

For group discussion. Listen to episode 500 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. A Shared Date 20 min
  3. From Dependence to Distance 25 min
  4. Doing Jewish Things with Jewish People 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 10 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 496 Session Introduction A Season of Mourning
2 497 Guest Conversation The Lord’s Prayer (Brad Gray and Brad Nelson)
3 498 The Four Pillars Text
4 499 The Four Pillars Truth in Text
5 500 Guest Conversation Passover (David Rudolph)
6 501 The Four Pillars Tome at the Center of the Spiral
7 502 The Four Pillars Community
8 503 The Four Pillars Japanese Woodworking Joint
9 504 The Four Pillars Coming Home to Community
10 505 The Four Pillars Discipleship
11 506 The Four Pillars Talmid & Morah
12 507 The Four Pillars Discipleship as a Forge
13 508 The Four Pillars Wrestling
14 509 The Four Pillars Don’t Let Go
15 510 The Four Pillars Soul Wrestling
16 511 Guest Conversation Does God See Me? (Dieula Previlon)
17 512 Live Episode Ten Years of BEMA
18 513 Women in Joshua & Judges Introduction
19 514 Women in Joshua & Judges Rahab
20 515 Women in Joshua & Judges Daughters of Zelophehad
21 516 Women in Joshua & Judges Akhsah
22 517 Book Conversation The Gospel of Being Human
23 518 Women in Joshua & Judges Deborah

Last week: Reed described Scripture as “God-breathed” in two senses, coming from God and giving life, and showed that poetry, satire, story and history can each carry real truth. He also left us with a test for any way of reading: does it produce fear, or love?1

This week: The four-pillars series pauses for BEMA’s 500th episode. Rabbi Dr. David Rudolph traces how the early church went from relying on the Jewish community to set the date of its central yearly celebration to deliberately cutting that tie at the Council of Nicaea.2

About This Session

For its 500th episode, BEMA paired a celebration (the announcement of its first live recording) with a sobering history lesson. David Rudolph, a Messianic Jewish New Testament scholar, uses one question, when to celebrate Pascha (the early church’s name for Passover and, later, Easter), as a window into the “parting of the ways” between church and synagogue. The story runs from Polycarp asking the Jewish community when Nisan 14 fell, through the Bar Kokhba revolt and a bitter dispute between East and West, to Constantine’s letter after Nicaea, which is openly antisemitic.

Rudolph’s aim is honest reckoning, not condemning the church. Nicaea made decisions many of us treasure, and it also made a decision that has fed antisemitism for 1,700 years. Our traditions relate to Easter, the church calendar and the early councils in different ways, so this guide invites each of us to describe what we were taught and notice what this history adds, rather than to defend or accuse.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: When you were growing up, how did you know Easter was coming, and what (if anything) did your family or church do to mark it?

A Shared Date 20 min

The earliest Gentile believers celebrated differently from their Jewish neighbors but chose to celebrate on the same day.

Q1: The notes describe early Gentile Pascha (from the Hebrew Pesach, “Passover”) as mainly a celebration of the Lord’s Supper, with leavened bread and no week of avoiding leaven. It was not a Seder. Yet the Quartodecimans (Latin quartodecimani, “fourteeners”) kept it on Nisan 14, the same date as the Jewish community. Brent sums it up: the practice was different, but the date was shared, and that shared date was a deliberate sign of unity.3 Polycarp kept this date because he had seen the Apostle John do it, and to keep it he had to ask the Jewish community when it fell. When he and Anicetus of Rome disagreed about the date, they agreed to disagree.4 What do you notice about the kind of relationship a shared date created, and about the way Polycarp and Anicetus handled their disagreement?

Read Acts 15:1–21 aloud.

Q2: The notes explain that the Jerusalem Council decided Gentile believers did not have to become Jews or take on the full “yoke of the Torah,” yet many still worshiped alongside Jewish believers and probably timed their observance to match.5 As you listen to the passage, what does the council ask of the Gentiles, and what does it leave open? How might that combination have made room for the choice Polycarp later made? (If you read Acts 15 this past week, include the detail that surprised you.)

Q3: Optional The notes compare Polycarp’s situation to an immigrant family that relies on relatives back home to know when a festival falls, so the calendar becomes a reason to stay in touch.6 What calendar, habit or shared rhythm in your own life keeps you connected to people you might otherwise drift away from?

From Dependence to Distance 25 min

Over about two centuries, a shared date turned into a deliberate separation.

Q4: The notes trace several turning points. After the Bar Kokhba revolt (c. 132–135 CE), Rome expelled all Jews, including Jewish believers, from Jerusalem, and the church lost its Jewish “mother congregation.” Around 190 CE, Victor of Rome tried to excommunicate the churches of Asia Minor for keeping Nisan 14. The Councils of Arles (314) and Nicaea (325) then made Rome’s method official: the Sunday after the first full moon after the vernal equinox, always after Jewish Passover, a method that needed no input from the Jewish community.7 Walking through these steps together, at which point does the relationship seem to change most, and what made that moment so decisive?

Q5: Optional Rudolph compares the second-century dispute to how upset people would be today if someone moved Easter. This was the most important day of the church’s year, and sharing it was a large part of what held the church together.8 What practice in your church or tradition would cause that kind of outcry if someone changed it, and what does your answer reveal about what holds your community together?

Q6: Constantine’s letter after Nicaea, preserved by Eusebius, calls on the church: “Let us then have nothing in common with the detestable Jewish crowd, for we have received from our Savior a different way.” It also repeats the charge of deicide.9 Rudolph’s main point is that Nicaea’s decision on Christ’s divinity has echoed for 1,700 years, and so has its antisemitically motivated decision on the calendar. The notes compare the honesty he is asking for to nations that keep days of remembrance for their own historical wrongs, honoring what was good while still naming what was wrong.10 Our traditions hold Nicaea, its creed and the church calendar in different ways. Without defending or condemning any of them, how do you hold together gratitude for what the church got right and honesty about what it got wrong?

Q7: Rudolph says the “nothing in common” mindset still shows up today in ideas such as: Christians shouldn’t visit synagogues, Messianic Jews should assimilate into the church, or the “Christian God” is different from the God of Israel.11 Where, if anywhere, have you heard echoes of these ideas, and what would it take to notice and gently correct them in your own circles?

Doing Jewish Things with Jewish People 20 min

Rudolph closes with lessons that move this history into the present.

Read John 10:17–18 aloud.

Q8: Rudolph’s first lesson is to put the deicide charge to rest. He notes that Vatican II’s Nostra Aetate rejected the idea that all Jews are guilty of Jesus’ death, that Romans and others took part, and that those involved did not represent all Jews for all time. He then points to John 10:18 and to Jesus dying for everyone’s sins.12 What do you notice in these verses about who has power over Jesus’ life? How does that change the way the question “who killed Jesus?” ought to be asked?

Q9: Optional Rudolph is concerned about Gentile-only Seders in some Hebrew Roots circles, seeing them as a new form of worship cut off from any dependence on the Jewish community. He raises a question about the Seder’s covenantal language: can a Gentile say “He brought us out of Egypt”? His recommendation is to join a Messianic Jewish congregation’s community Seder or a Jewish friend’s Seder, since having guests is a traditional part of the meal.13 Some of us may have attended or hosted a church Seder that meant a lot to us. What does Rudolph’s concern help you see about those experiences, and what would change if Jewish people were at the table?

Read Ephesians 2:11–22 aloud.

Q10: The notes summarize Rudolph’s lessons as rejecting the deicide charge, fighting antisemitism actively, and following the principle “do Jewish things with Jewish people.” They also offer practical examples: noticing each year how the Western, Orthodox and Jewish dates line up, looking for a community Seder at a local Messianic synagogue, and correcting antisemitic tropes online with good information.14 In light of Ephesians 2, what is one concrete step you could take this year toward the interdependence Rudolph describes?

Closing 15 min

What looks like a technical question, when to celebrate Easter, carries the story of the church’s relationship with the Jewish people. At first, Gentile believers gladly relied on their Jewish brothers and sisters to know when to celebrate. After Jerusalem fell, Rome became the center, the disagreement grew bitter, and at Nicaea the calendar was cut loose from Jewish reckoning in language that has fed antisemitism ever since. Rudolph does not ask us to condemn the church. He asks us to remember honestly, reject the deicide charge, protect our Jewish neighbors, and, where we share in Israel’s feasts, celebrate with Jewish people.15

Closing Question: In one sentence, what is one thing this history changes about how you will approach Easter (or Passover) next spring?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 501 — Tome at the Center of the Spiral (53:54): The four-pillars series returns to the pillar of Text, with Brent and Elle Grover Fricks in what Elle calls her “weirdest episode ever.” Using a framework called spiral dynamics, she affirms many ways of reading Scripture and then argues that the Bible is “a purple book about purple things calling us to live purple lives,” full of angels, dreams, holy places and sacred seasons. She challenges us to stop trimming away the supernatural and to give the sacred text more attention than the algorithm.16

What to bring next week:

  • For three mornings this week, notice what you reach for first when you wake up (news, social media, Scripture, something else), and bring one observation.
  • Read Numbers 22:21–35 (Balaam’s donkey) and note one detail that seems strange to you.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with co-host Reed. “The Four Pillars — Truth in Text.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 499. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/499. Reed holds together “breathed into” and “breathed out by,” describes categories of truth, and urges judging a way of reading by whether it produces fear or love. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings with guest Rabbi Dr. David Rudolph. “David Rudolph — Passover.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 500. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/500. The episode marks BEMA’s 500th episode and follows the dating of Pascha from dependence on the Jewish calendar to deliberate separation at Nicaea in 325. ↩

  3. Ep. 500 notes. Gentile Pascha differed from the Seder in practice (Eucharist, leavened bread, no week without leaven) but shared the Nisan 14 date, which Brent summarizes as a deliberate sign of unity; “Pascha” comes from the Hebrew Pesach, and quartodecimani means “fourteeners.” ↩

  4. Ep. 500 notes. Polycarp kept Nisan 14 because John had done so, had to ask the Jewish community when it fell, and agreed to disagree with Anicetus, who kept a Sunday date. ↩

  5. Ep. 500 notes. Acts 15 freed Gentiles from becoming Jews or taking on the full “yoke of the Torah,” yet many Gentiles worshiped with Jewish believers and probably timed their observance to match. ↩

  6. Ep. 500 notes. The immigrant-family example illustrates how Polycarp’s need to ask the Jewish community bound the two groups together. ↩

  7. Ep. 500 notes. The Bar Kokhba expulsion, Victor’s attempted excommunication around 190, and the Arles and Nicaea decisions mark the shift to a dating method needing no Jewish input. ↩

  8. Ep. 500 notes. Rudolph compares the second-century dispute to the outcry that would follow if someone moved Easter today, because sharing the day held the church together. ↩

  9. Ep. 500 notes. Constantine’s letter, as preserved by Eusebius, includes the “nothing in common” line and the charge of deicide. ↩

  10. Ep. 500 notes. Rudolph says both Nicaea’s decision on Christ’s divinity and its antisemitically motivated calendar decision have echoed for 1,700 years, and the notes point to national days of remembrance as a model of honest reckoning. ↩

  11. Ep. 500 notes. Rudolph lists present-day forms of the “nothing in common” mindset. ↩

  12. Ep. 500 notes. Rudolph’s first lesson cites Nostra Aetate, the participation of Romans and others, and John 10:18. ↩

  13. Ep. 500 notes. Rudolph critiques Gentile-only Seders, raises the question of covenantal language, and recommends joining a Messianic Jewish or Jewish friend’s Seder. ↩

  14. Ep. 500 notes. The notes list Rudolph’s lessons for today, including “do Jewish things with Jewish people,” and practical applications such as comparing calendars, attending community Seders and responding to antisemitism online; they also point to Ephesians 2 for exploring interdependence between Jews and Gentiles. ↩

  15. Ep. 500 notes. The notes’ summary describes the move from glad reliance to separation and Rudolph’s call to honest reckoning without condemning the church as a whole. ↩

  16. Brent Billings with Elle Grover Fricks. “The Four Pillars — Tome at the Center of the Spiral.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 501. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/501. Elle uses spiral dynamics to argue that the Bible is a “purple” book and that Scripture deserves more attention than the algorithm. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.