Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- Grain on the Sabbath 25 min
- The Donkey in the Pit 25 min
- A Bruised Reed 15 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Section | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 73 | Introduction | Session 3 Intro |
| 2 | 74 | Silent Years | Synagogue |
| 3 | 75 | Silent Years | Welcome to Hellenism |
| 4 | 76 | Silent Years | Sadducees |
| 5 | 77 | Silent Years | Herodians |
| 6 | 78 | Silent Years | Essenes |
| 7 | 79 | Silent Years | Zealots |
| 8 | 80 | Silent Years | Pharisees |
| 9 | 81 | Silent Years | Association |
| 10 | 82 | Reading the Gospels | The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why |
| 11 | 83 | Reading the Gospels | Gospel Narrative |
| 12 | 84 | The Four Gospels | Matthew — Mumzer |
| 13 | 85 | The Four Gospels | Mark — Roman Gospel |
| 14 | 86 | The Four Gospels | Luke — Ordered |
| 15 | 87 | The Four Gospels | John — Grafted |
| 16 | 88 | Matthew 1–4 | Setting the Stage |
| 17 | 89 | Matthew 1–4 | Written in the Stars |
| 18 | 90 | Matthew 1–4 | A Gospel of Two Kingdoms |
| 19 | 91 | Matthew 1–4 | Tavilah T'Shuvah |
| 20 | 92 | Matthew 1–4 | How to Bring Order Out of Chaos |
| 21 | 93 | Sermon on the Mount | Blessed |
| 22 | 94 | Sermon on the Mount | Hope of the World |
| 23 | 95 | Sermon on the Mount | Abolish or Fulfill |
| 24 | 96 | Sermon on the Mount | But I Say Unto You |
| 25 | 97 | Sermon on the Mount | Done in Secret |
| 26 | 98 | Sermon on the Mount | A Good Eye |
| 27 | 99 | Sermon on the Mount | Fruit of Fools |
| 28 | 100 | Matthew 8–12 | Healing at Great Cost |
| 29 | 101 | Matthew 8–12 | The Other Side |
| 30 | 102 | Matthew 8–12 | Son of Man |
| 31 | 103 | Matthew 8–12 | Healing in His Wings |
| 32 | 104 | Matthew 8–12 | Innocent as Doves |
| 33 | 105 | Matthew 8–12 | An Explosive Kingdom |
| 34 | 106 | Matthew 8–12 | Jury Duty in Sodom |
| 35 | 107 | Matthew 8–12 | Donkeys and Rabbis |
| 36 | 108 | Matthew 8–12 | The Fruit of Beelzebul |
| 37 | 109 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Which Soil? |
| 38 | 110 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Jewish Hermeneutics |
| 39 | 111 | Parables (Matthew 13) | A Farmer and a Woman |
| 40 | 112 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Explanations That Don’t Explain |
| 41 | 113 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Treasures and Pearls |
| 42 | 114 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Fish in a Net |
| 43 | 115 | Matthew 14–25 | 5 Loaves, 2 Fish, and 1 Big Lesson |
| 44 | 116 | Matthew 14–25 | She Giggled |
| 45 | 117 | Matthew 14–25 | Jesus Resorts to Name Calling |
| 46 | 118 | Matthew 14–25 | Eyes That Cannot See |
| 47 | 119 | Matthew 14–25 | The Gates of Hell |
| 48 | 120 | Matthew 14–25 | Truth and Light |
| 49 | 121 | Matthew 14–25 | The Key to Your Own Prison |
| 50 | 122 | Matthew 14–25 | A Naked Thing |
| 51 | 123 | Matthew 14–25 | The Heat of the Day |
| 52 | 124 | Matthew 14–25 | Statement of Triumph |
| 53 | 125 | Matthew 14–25 | Are You Talking to Me? |
| 54 | 126 | Matthew 14–25 | Trapped by a Question |
| 55 | 127 | Matthew 14–25 | Six or Seven? |
| 56 | 128 | Matthew 14–25 | Faithful and Wise Steward |
| 57 | 129 | Matthew 26–28 | The Final Week |
| 58 | 130 | Matthew 26–28 | The Plot to Kill Jesus |
| 59 | 131 | Matthew 26–28 | Betrayal |
| 60 | 132 | Matthew 26–28 | Go |
| 61 | 133 | Capstone | Session 3 Capstone |
Last week: Jesus called the most devoted towns of the Galilee to repent for failing those in need, then offered rest to the weary in words that echoed God, Moses and the ancient path of Torah.
This week: Two Sabbath controversies open Matthew 12. Jesus does not set Torah aside; he shows how to read it when two good commands seem to pull in different directions.
About This Session
The episode begins with a distinction: Torah, the five books of Moses with their 613 commandments, and halakhah (from the Hebrew for “walk”), the oral tradition about how to walk Torah out in daily life.1 The notes argue that Jesus never broke Torah; he challenged particular interpretations when they missed the heart of God’s law.2 They also ask us to see the rabbinic “fence around Torah” with charity, as an act of devotion rather than legalism.3
Every rabbi had a “yoke,” an interpretive lens, and the episode describes the two great schools of Jesus’s day, Hillel and Shammai.4 Through grain picked on the Sabbath, a man with a shriveled hand and an old debate about a donkey in a pit, the episode asks which commandment is weightier when two collide. It closes with Matthew’s portrait of Jesus as Isaiah’s gentle servant.5
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Think of a rule or tradition you grew up with, in your family, school or church, that was meant to protect something good. What was it protecting, and how do you feel about that rule now?
Grain on the Sabbath 25 min
Jesus’s disciples pick grain on the Sabbath, and the Pharisees call it harvesting.
Read Matthew 12:1–8 aloud, then 1 Samuel 21:1–6.
Q1: Jesus answers the Pharisees with three arguments. Find them in verses 3–7 and name them in your own words. The notes summarize them as David’s example, the priests’ example, and “God’s priority.”6 What do the three have in common?
Q2: The notes explain that after the exile, Jewish teachers built a “fence around Torah,” later written down in the Mishnah and Talmud, and that “The motivation was not legalism but devotion.”7 Marty tells of Moshe, a Jerusalem shop owner who bought twenty oranges when his pregnant wife wanted one, and who said: “My obedience as a Jew following all these oral commands and traditions is not because I’m a legalist, it’s because it’s my gift to Adonai.”8 The notes say this “helps modern readers understand the Pharisees with greater charity.”9 How does Moshe’s story change the way you picture the people who questioned Jesus here?
Q3: The notes warn that when Christians say “Jesus broke the law,” they “misunderstand this critical distinction” between Torah and halakhah, and in a Jewish setting would undercut Jesus’s sinless life.10 Our traditions have talked about Jesus and the law in different ways. What have you been taught about whether Jesus broke the law, and how does the Torah and halakhah distinction sit with what you learned?
Q4: Optional The notes list what Sabbath reminds us of, drawing on Genesis and Session 1: “We have enough,” “We can rest,” “We can play,” “No work,” and “God loves us.”11 Which of those five reminders do you most need to hear right now, and what would one Sabbath-shaped hour look like for you this week?
The Donkey in the Pit 25 min
In the synagogue, the Pharisees bring a man with a shriveled hand and a question meant as a trap.
Read Matthew 12:9–14 aloud.
Q5: Compare the question the Pharisees ask in verse 10 with the conclusion Jesus states in verse 12. What word changes? The notes observe that Jesus “elevated the question from technical compliance to moral purpose.”12 What difference does that change of word make?
Q6: The notes describe the yoke of Shammai, whose second greatest commandment was to obey the Sabbath, and the yoke of Hillel, whose second greatest commandment was “Love your neighbor as yourself.”13 A yoke works like a pair of glasses for reading all of Torah, and the notes say Jesus consistently adopted Hillel’s yoke, with one exception about divorce that comes later.14 The donkey in the pit was one of the great rabbinic debates, and both schools agreed the donkey must be rescued.15 How does knowing about these yokes help you hear Jesus’s argument in verses 11–12?
Q7: Optional The notes offer a modern case: Christians hiding Jews during the Holocaust, asked at the door whether they had Jews inside. Rather than saying “Whatever you do, you’ll break a commandment,” Jesus’s yoke says: “Don’t look at it as breaking a command, look at it as fulfilling the right command.”16 The notes also caution against using this principle “to dismiss commands we find inconvenient.”17 How would you tell the difference between choosing the weightier command and simply choosing the easier one?
Q8: The notes ask, “What yoke do we bring to Scripture? Do we read through a lens of love or mere obligation?”18 Think of a recent situation where you had to decide what faithfulness required. Which lens did you reach for, and what did it lead you to do?
A Bruised Reed 15 min
After the confrontation, Jesus withdraws, and Matthew reaches for Isaiah.
Read Matthew 12:15–21 aloud.
Q9: List what Isaiah’s servant will not do, and then what he will do. The notes point out that “Jesus withdraws rather than promoting Himself or winning arguments.”19 What strikes you about how Jesus responds after being plotted against in verse 14?
Q10: Optional The notes leave an unresolved thread: Jesus had just called John “a reed blown by the wind,” Isaiah’s servant will not break “a bruised reed,” and Isaiah 42:7 speaks of releasing “from the dungeon those who sit in darkness” while John sat in prison.20 What possibilities do you see in Matthew placing these texts so close together?
Q11: Who in your life right now is a bruised reed or a smoldering wick, and what would gentleness toward them look like this week?
Closing 15 min
Jesus did not break Torah. He read it through the yoke of love for God and neighbor, the yoke of Hillel, and he asked which command weighs more when two seem to collide. The priest who fed David, the priests who work on the Sabbath, and the donkey everyone agrees to rescue all point the same way: “I desire mercy, not sacrifice.” The people who questioned him were often sincerely devoted, and the issue was not their devotion but their priorities. Then, after the argument, Jesus withdrew, the servant who does not break a bruised reed.
Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one place this week where you will choose mercy as the weightier command?
Looking Ahead
Ep. 108 — The Fruit of Beelzebul (32:33): The Pharisees accuse Jesus of driving out demons by the power of Beelzebul. The episode unpacks Jesus’s reply, what he means by blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, the sign of Jonah, and his startling answer when his mother and brothers come looking for him.
What to bring next week: Read Matthew 12:22–50. Write down one example of good fruit you have seen recently in someone who would not use your church’s vocabulary.
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Donkeys and Rabbis.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 107. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/107. The distinction between Torah and halakhah. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. Jesus honored Torah while challenging interpretations that missed the heart of God’s law. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The fence around Torah motivated by devotion. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. Rabbinic yokes and the schools of Hillel and Shammai. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The weightiness of the law and Isaiah 42 as a portrait of the gentle servant. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. Jesus’s three arguments: David, the priests and Hosea 6:6. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The fence around Torah, the Mishnah and Talmud, and devotion as motive. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. Moshe and the oranges. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. Understanding the Pharisees with greater charity. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The claim that Jesus broke the law and Jesus’s sinlessness. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The purpose of Sabbath. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. “Lawful to heal” reframed as “lawful to do good.” ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The yokes of Shammai and Hillel. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The yoke as interpretive lens and Jesus’s consistent adoption of Hillel’s yoke except on divorce. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The donkey in the pit as one of eight great rabbinic debates. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The Holocaust dilemma and fulfilling the right command. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes (Potential Areas for Further Exploration). Avoiding misuse of the weightiness principle. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes (Personalized Summary). Examining our own interpretive yoke. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. Jesus withdraws as Isaiah’s gentle servant. ↩
-
Ep. 107 notes. The unresolved connection between Isaiah 42 and John the Baptist. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.