BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 3 · Week 8 of 61

Episode 80

Silent Years — Pharisees

Let God Deal with Rome: Devoted Communities and the One Missing Piece

90-minute session Matthew 11:20–24; Matthew 9:9–13

For group discussion. Listen to episode 80 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Five Answers to Rome 20 min
  3. Everything but Compassion 30 min
  4. Cultural Herodians, Religious Pharisees 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 3 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 73 Introduction Session 3 Intro
2 74 Silent Years Synagogue
3 75 Silent Years Welcome to Hellenism
4 76 Silent Years Sadducees
5 77 Silent Years Herodians
6 78 Silent Years Essenes
7 79 Silent Years Zealots
8 80 Silent Years Pharisees
9 81 Silent Years Association
10 82 Reading the Gospels The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why
11 83 Reading the Gospels Gospel Narrative
12 84 The Four Gospels Matthew — Mumzer
13 85 The Four Gospels Mark — Roman Gospel
14 86 The Four Gospels Luke — Ordered
15 87 The Four Gospels John — Grafted
16 88 Matthew 1–4 Setting the Stage
17 89 Matthew 1–4 Written in the Stars
18 90 Matthew 1–4 A Gospel of Two Kingdoms
19 91 Matthew 1–4 Tavilah T'Shuvah
20 92 Matthew 1–4 How to Bring Order Out of Chaos
21 93 Sermon on the Mount Blessed
22 94 Sermon on the Mount Hope of the World
23 95 Sermon on the Mount Abolish or Fulfill
24 96 Sermon on the Mount But I Say Unto You
25 97 Sermon on the Mount Done in Secret
26 98 Sermon on the Mount A Good Eye
27 99 Sermon on the Mount Fruit of Fools
28 100 Matthew 8–12 Healing at Great Cost
29 101 Matthew 8–12 The Other Side
30 102 Matthew 8–12 Son of Man
31 103 Matthew 8–12 Healing in His Wings
32 104 Matthew 8–12 Innocent as Doves
33 105 Matthew 8–12 An Explosive Kingdom
34 106 Matthew 8–12 Jury Duty in Sodom
35 107 Matthew 8–12 Donkeys and Rabbis
36 108 Matthew 8–12 The Fruit of Beelzebul
37 109 Parables (Matthew 13) Which Soil?
38 110 Parables (Matthew 13) Jewish Hermeneutics
39 111 Parables (Matthew 13) A Farmer and a Woman
40 112 Parables (Matthew 13) Explanations That Don’t Explain
41 113 Parables (Matthew 13) Treasures and Pearls
42 114 Parables (Matthew 13) Fish in a Net
43 115 Matthew 14–25 5 Loaves, 2 Fish, and 1 Big Lesson
44 116 Matthew 14–25 She Giggled
45 117 Matthew 14–25 Jesus Resorts to Name Calling
46 118 Matthew 14–25 Eyes That Cannot See
47 119 Matthew 14–25 The Gates of Hell
48 120 Matthew 14–25 Truth and Light
49 121 Matthew 14–25 The Key to Your Own Prison
50 122 Matthew 14–25 A Naked Thing
51 123 Matthew 14–25 The Heat of the Day
52 124 Matthew 14–25 Statement of Triumph
53 125 Matthew 14–25 Are You Talking to Me?
54 126 Matthew 14–25 Trapped by a Question
55 127 Matthew 14–25 Six or Seven?
56 128 Matthew 14–25 Faithful and Wise Steward
57 129 Matthew 26–28 The Final Week
58 130 Matthew 26–28 The Plot to Kill Jesus
59 131 Matthew 26–28 Betrayal
60 132 Matthew 26–28 Go
61 133 Capstone Session 3 Capstone

Last week: We met the Zealots, whose fierce love for God’s honor led them into the myth of redemptive violence, and we heard that God still has a place for the zealous.

This week: The last of the five groups is the Pharisees, who took the same zeal and poured it into devotion and obedience. Jesus spent most of his ministry among them.

About This Session

The notes describe the Pharisees as descendants of the Hasidim (“pious ones”) who rejected Hellenism without fleeing to the desert. They settled in the Galilean “triangle” of Chorazin, Capernaum and Bethsaida, built towns around the synagogue, lived communally, and channeled their zeal into “absolute devotion and obedience” to God’s commands.1 The notes call them the Orthodox Judaism of Jesus’s day and point out that after the Temple’s destruction, Pharisaic Judaism became the foundation of Rabbinic Judaism.2 Their answer to Rome was simple: let God deal with Rome; our task is to become the people God asks us to be.3

The episode argues that Jesus focused on the Pharisees because they had nearly everything God’s people needed (devotion to the Text, passion for God, commitment to obedience, knowledge of Scripture) and lacked one thing: compassion.4 The notes take care to say that their harshness toward sinners grew from sincere theological conviction, not simple meanness.5 Most pointedly, the episode turns the lens on us: it is easy to read the Pharisees as “them,” and the episode’s discussion notes ask whether they are actually the group we are meant to see ourselves in.6

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a community you have belonged to that took something very seriously: a team, a choir, a military unit, a church, a family tradition. What did that seriousness make possible, and what did it sometimes cost?

Five Answers to Rome 20 min

Over five weeks we have met five answers to one question: what do you do about Rome?

Q1: The notes review the five groups with a one-line answer each:7

  • Sadducees: “We partner with Rome”
  • Herodians: “We get in bed with Rome”
  • Essenes: “Rome? What’s Rome?”
  • Zealots: “We kill Rome”
  • Pharisees: “You’re asking the wrong question. Let God deal with Rome”

Read the five lines aloud. When you face a culture or a power you disagree with, which of these five instincts shows up first in you? Which one shows up in your church?

Q2: The Pharisees believed that “when they became the people God asked them to be, God would rescue them.”8 The notes describe towns with the synagogue at the center and the bema at the center of the synagogue, practical buildings of rough-cut stone, and a “110% commitment to Scripture.”9 What is admirable in this answer? What risks do you see in tying God’s rescue to the people’s obedience?

Q3: Optional The Pharisees lived in insulae, multifamily dwellings around shared courtyards, which the notes contrast with the modern “your own house, your own car, your own washer and dryer” mentality.10 They believed they could be more obedient as a committed community. What would you gain, and what would you find hardest, about sharing daily life that closely? What is one small way you could live a little more “in common” with others?

Everything but Compassion 30 min

The episode explains both why Jesus spent so much time with the Pharisees and what he challenged in them.

Q4: The notes explain the Pharisees’ view of sinners: if Israel would just be obedient enough, God would deliver them, so tax collectors and prostitutes were seen as the reason Rome stayed in power: “You’re the reason God hasn’t delivered us yet.”11 The notes stress that “This wasn’t mere judgmentalism but a genuine worldview” and that the Pharisees “didn’t wake up wanting to be jerks.”12 Why do you think the episode works so hard to understand the Pharisees’ reasons? How does understanding the reasons change the way you read their conflicts with Jesus?

Read Matthew 9:9–13 aloud.

Q5: Read the passage again. Who is at the table with Jesus? What question do the Pharisees ask, and to whom do they ask it? What does Jesus say in response, and which prophet does he point them to? In light of the Pharisees’ theology of sin and deliverance, why would this meal have been so troubling to sincere, devoted people?

Read Matthew 11:20–24 aloud.

Q6: Read the passage again and notice what Jesus says these towns failed to do. The notes observe that “The passage doesn’t say they didn’t believe the message”; the problem was that “the message didn’t change the way they lived.”13 They describe Tyre and Sidon as prophetic symbols of arrogance and Sodom as a city known for lack of hospitality and failure to protect the foreigner.14 What do these comparisons suggest about the specific failure Jesus is naming? Why might it be harder for devoted, knowledgeable people to repent than for others?

Q7: Optional The notes call Capernaum “the ‘Yale or Harvard’ of the Pharisaic world” and say that when Jesus made it his base, he was intentionally engaging “the most educated and devoted segment of Judaism.”15 What does it say about Jesus that he set up his ministry among the most serious students of Scripture rather than among the compromised or the withdrawn?

Q8: The notes say the Pharisees had “every piece God’s people needed except one,” and that without compassion, “everything else was ruined.”16 They name a modern parallel: churches may emphasize “doctrinal correctness, biblical literacy, and moral standards” while failing in compassion toward “the marginalized, the sinner, the outcast.”17 Where do you have knowledge, conviction or discipline but find compassion harder? Who is one person or group you find it difficult to feel compassion for?

Cultural Herodians, Religious Pharisees 15 min

The episode closes by holding up a mirror.

Q9: The original notes put Marty’s challenge bluntly: the church struggles most because “we are cultural herodians and religious pharisees.” In other words, “We want to consume everything and live in all of the luxury,” and “We also lack all compassion when it comes to our religion.”18 The notes add that many of us have neither the Pharisees’ devotion nor their compassion, which makes this “The Worst Cocktail.”19 What is your honest reaction to that statement? Where does it ring true, and where would you push back?

Q10: Optional The episode’s discussion notes point to an addendum about “how we talk about pharisees and what that means historically” and ask whether we read the Pharisees as just “another group of people” or as the group “we are supposed to associate with.”20 In the church where you first learned the Gospels, how were the Pharisees usually portrayed? How might that portrayal have shaped the way you think about Judaism, and the way you think about yourself?

Q11: The original notes capture the confession this way: “I have everything else but I lack compassion for those that God cares about most.”21 The discussion notes ask what happens when we “start acting like God’s gatekeepers.”22 Where in your life are you most tempted to act as a gatekeeper? What is one specific act of compassion you could practice this week toward someone on the other side of that gate?

Closing 15 min

The Pharisees were not the villains we were often taught to imagine. They were the most devoted people in Israel: communities built around the Text, sharing life, pouring all their zeal into obedience and waiting for God to deal with Rome. Jesus spent his ministry among them precisely because they had nearly every piece God’s people needed. What they lacked was compassion, and without it, everything else was ruined. The episode asks us to stop reading the Pharisees as someone else and to see ourselves in them. The question is not whether we know the message, but whether it is changing the way we live.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: which of the five groups have you seen most in yourself over these weeks, and what is one thing you want to do about it?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 81 — Silent Years — Association (36:08): The final episode on the silent years asks why Galatians 4:4 says Jesus came at “the fullness of time,” and suggests it was the moment when all five Jewish responses to Hellenism were in full conversation. Marty and Brent walk back through the Sadducees, Herodians, Essenes, Zealots and Pharisees, naming a positive contribution and a negative tendency in each, and invite listeners to recognize how they embody all five in different parts of their lives.

What to bring next week: Read Galatians 4:4–7. Make a simple five-row chart with one strength and one weakness for each group, and put a mark beside the strength you most want to grow in and the weakness you most see in yourself.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Silent Years — Pharisees.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 80. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/80. The Pharisees emerged from the Hasidim, settled in the Galilean triangle and channeled their zeal into obedience. ↩

  2. Ep. 80 notes. The Pharisees as the Orthodox Judaism of Jesus’s day and the foundation of Rabbinic Judaism after AD 70. ↩

  3. Ep. 80 notes. The Pharisaic answer to Rome. ↩

  4. Ep. 80 notes. Jesus focused on the Pharisees because they had every piece except compassion. ↩

  5. Ep. 80 notes. Pharisaic harshness toward sinners as theological conviction. ↩

  6. Ep. 80 notes, Discussion section. Whether we read the Pharisees as a group to associate with. ↩

  7. Ep. 80 notes. The five responses to Rome reviewed. ↩

  8. Ep. 80 notes. The Pharisees’ belief that obedience would lead to rescue. ↩

  9. Ep. 80 notes. Textual centrality and practical simplicity in Pharisaic towns. ↩

  10. Ep. 80 notes. Communal living in insulae. ↩

  11. Ep. 80 notes. Pharisaic theology of sin and deliverance. ↩

  12. Ep. 80 notes. The sincerity of the Pharisees’ worldview. ↩

  13. Ep. 80 notes. The critique of Matthew 11:20–24 concerns repentance, not belief. ↩

  14. Ep. 80 notes. Tyre, Sidon and Sodom as condemning witnesses. ↩

  15. Ep. 80 notes. Capernaum as the intellectual center and Jesus’s base. ↩

  16. Ep. 80 notes. Compassion as the one missing piece. ↩

  17. Ep. 80 notes. Missing compassion in contemporary churches. ↩

  18. Ep. 80 notes, Original Notes section. Cultural Herodians and religious Pharisees. ↩

  19. Ep. 80 notes. The “worst cocktail” of Herodian and Pharisaic weaknesses. ↩

  20. Ep. 80 notes, Discussion section. The addendum on how we talk about the Pharisees and whether we associate with them. ↩

  21. Ep. 80 notes, Original Notes section. Lacking compassion for those God cares about most. ↩

  22. Ep. 80 notes, Discussion section. Acting as God’s gatekeepers. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.