BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 3 · Week 9 of 61

Episode 81

Silent Years — Association

Galatians 4:4: Finding Ourselves in All Five Responses

90-minute session Galatians 4:4–7; Hebrews 13:17

For group discussion. Listen to episode 81 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. The Set Time 20 min
  3. Five Responses, Two Sides Each 30 min
  4. The Worst Mix 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 3 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 73 Introduction Session 3 Intro
2 74 Silent Years Synagogue
3 75 Silent Years Welcome to Hellenism
4 76 Silent Years Sadducees
5 77 Silent Years Herodians
6 78 Silent Years Essenes
7 79 Silent Years Zealots
8 80 Silent Years Pharisees
9 81 Silent Years Association
10 82 Reading the Gospels The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why
11 83 Reading the Gospels Gospel Narrative
12 84 The Four Gospels Matthew — Mumzer
13 85 The Four Gospels Mark — Roman Gospel
14 86 The Four Gospels Luke — Ordered
15 87 The Four Gospels John — Grafted
16 88 Matthew 1–4 Setting the Stage
17 89 Matthew 1–4 Written in the Stars
18 90 Matthew 1–4 A Gospel of Two Kingdoms
19 91 Matthew 1–4 Tavilah T'Shuvah
20 92 Matthew 1–4 How to Bring Order Out of Chaos
21 93 Sermon on the Mount Blessed
22 94 Sermon on the Mount Hope of the World
23 95 Sermon on the Mount Abolish or Fulfill
24 96 Sermon on the Mount But I Say Unto You
25 97 Sermon on the Mount Done in Secret
26 98 Sermon on the Mount A Good Eye
27 99 Sermon on the Mount Fruit of Fools
28 100 Matthew 8–12 Healing at Great Cost
29 101 Matthew 8–12 The Other Side
30 102 Matthew 8–12 Son of Man
31 103 Matthew 8–12 Healing in His Wings
32 104 Matthew 8–12 Innocent as Doves
33 105 Matthew 8–12 An Explosive Kingdom
34 106 Matthew 8–12 Jury Duty in Sodom
35 107 Matthew 8–12 Donkeys and Rabbis
36 108 Matthew 8–12 The Fruit of Beelzebul
37 109 Parables (Matthew 13) Which Soil?
38 110 Parables (Matthew 13) Jewish Hermeneutics
39 111 Parables (Matthew 13) A Farmer and a Woman
40 112 Parables (Matthew 13) Explanations That Don’t Explain
41 113 Parables (Matthew 13) Treasures and Pearls
42 114 Parables (Matthew 13) Fish in a Net
43 115 Matthew 14–25 5 Loaves, 2 Fish, and 1 Big Lesson
44 116 Matthew 14–25 She Giggled
45 117 Matthew 14–25 Jesus Resorts to Name Calling
46 118 Matthew 14–25 Eyes That Cannot See
47 119 Matthew 14–25 The Gates of Hell
48 120 Matthew 14–25 Truth and Light
49 121 Matthew 14–25 The Key to Your Own Prison
50 122 Matthew 14–25 A Naked Thing
51 123 Matthew 14–25 The Heat of the Day
52 124 Matthew 14–25 Statement of Triumph
53 125 Matthew 14–25 Are You Talking to Me?
54 126 Matthew 14–25 Trapped by a Question
55 127 Matthew 14–25 Six or Seven?
56 128 Matthew 14–25 Faithful and Wise Steward
57 129 Matthew 26–28 The Final Week
58 130 Matthew 26–28 The Plot to Kill Jesus
59 131 Matthew 26–28 Betrayal
60 132 Matthew 26–28 Go
61 133 Capstone Session 3 Capstone

Last week: We met the Pharisees, whose answer to Rome was “You’re asking the wrong question. Let God deal with Rome.” Jesus spent most of his ministry among them because they had nearly everything God’s people needed except compassion.1

This week: Marty and Brent finish the Silent Years by reviewing all five responses to Hellenism and turning the question on us: not “Which group am I?” but “How do I associate with each of them?”

About This Session

The episode begins with Galatians 4:4 and the “set time” of Jesus’ coming. Marty proposes that the timing was perfect because Judaism was in the middle of a living argument about how to respond to Hellenism, with five different answers in dialogue with one another.2 The hosts then walk back through the Sadducees, Herodians, Essenes, Zealots and Pharisees, naming a real strength and a real danger in each, and insisting that every group has something God wants to use.3

The tone is personal. Marty and Brent are candid about their own habits (screens, entertainment, judgment), and Marty offers a sharp critique of American evangelicalism as “the worst mix” of Herodian culture and Pharisaic religion.4 The goal is self-awareness rather than labels: embracing each group’s strengths while guarding against each group’s weaknesses.5

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: On his first Israel trip, Marty met a group of Amish travelers carrying MP3 players and laptops. When he asked about it, they laughed: “There’s three orders of Amish. There’s the New Order, there’s the Old Order, and we are what’s called the Out-of-Order.”6 Where in your life are you a little “out of order,” holding a conviction you don’t quite live consistently? Keep it light; a small example is perfect.

The Set Time 20 min

Before looking at the five groups again, the episode asks why Jesus came when he did.

Read Galatians 4:4–7 aloud.

Q1: The notes compare three translations of verse 4: “when the set time had fully come” (NIV), “when the fullness of time had come” (ESV), and “when the appointed time arrived” (CJB).7 Read the verse in the translations people brought. What does each wording emphasize, and what else in verses 4–7 tells you this moment was deliberate?

Q2: Marty argues the “perfect timing” was the cultural moment when Judaism was actively wrestling with how to respond to Hellenism, with all five responses in full dialogue.8 Thinking back over the last eight weeks, what about that argument made it a fitting stage for Jesus’ ministry and message?

Q3: Optional The original notes say the moment mattered because of Hellenism’s effect on people’s worldview, “Especially how they interact with others who believe differently than they do.”9 Where in your own life is the question of how to stay faithful among people who believe differently most alive right now?

Five Responses, Two Sides Each 30 min

Every group gets both a strength and a danger, and the episode refuses to let us pick a team.

Q4: The notes give each group a positive contribution and a negative tendency:10

  • Sadducees: living out the priestly role / complete corruption
  • Herodians: fluency in the culture, positioned to redeem it / compromise and idolatry
  • Essenes: “Complete and utter devotion to the Text” / isolation and separatism
  • Zealots: passionate action that moves from learning to doing / grabbing the wrong tools and weapons
  • Pharisees: passionate devotion to God’s commandments / lacking compassion

Which positive contribution surprised you most, given how these groups are usually talked about? What would the body of Christ lose without it?

Q5: Marty says he has shifted how he teaches this material. Instead of asking which single group we belong to, he asks, “How do I associate with each of these groups in different areas of my life?”11 Marty associates most with the Essenes yet admits strong Herodian habits; Brent identifies as a Pharisee who struggles to see potential in people.12 Choose one area of your life (work, money, screens, politics, church) and describe which group’s strength and which group’s weakness show up there.

Q6: Optional Read Hebrews 13:17 aloud. The notes observe that many Protestants reject the idea of priesthood while more liturgical traditions embrace it, and that Israel was a kingdom of priests that also had a whole tribe set apart for priestly work.13 How has your own tradition taught you to think about formal leaders (elders, ministers, pastors, priests) alongside the priesthood of all believers? The episode’s question for any leader is, “In what places am I using what God has set up for my own personal gain?”14 What would honest attention to that question look like in a church you know?

Q7: Brent names the particular Zealot danger: “They stopped seeing potential in people because they see the Roman soldier, and they just say, ‘Well, that is a foregone conclusion. There is nothing good there. I’m going to get rid of that to meet my goal.’”15 For the Pharisee side, the episode borrows a question from Brené Brown: “Do we really believe that everybody everywhere is trying to do their best?”16 Without naming them, think of someone you have quietly written off as a foregone conclusion. What would it look like this week to look for potential in that person?

The Worst Mix 15 min

Marty turns the lens on the modern church, and the historical Pharisees come off better than we might expect.

Q8: Marty’s critique is that American evangelicalism takes the worst of the Herodians and the worst of the Pharisees and combines them: spiritually Pharisaic (rigid about who is in and out, lacking compassion) and culturally Herodian (consuming culture, living comfortably).17 He adds that the historical Pharisees were at least consistent; their villages had no marble streets, no paved roads, no ornate city gates.18 Where does this assessment ring true in your experience of church, and where would you want to push back or add nuance?

Q9: Optional When Brent asked Marty, “Do you spend more time in scripture or more time in movies and TV?” Marty had to pause, which led to the insight: “We create space for the things we want to create space for.”19 If someone looked at your last month’s calendar and screen time, what would they conclude you have made space for? Name one small space you could create this week for the Text, prayer or service.

Closing 15 min

Paul says God sent his Son when the set time had fully come, and this episode suggests that part of what made the time right was a people arguing about how to live faithfully under a powerful, seductive culture. Each of the five answers carried something God could use and something that could ruin it. We are not asked to choose one team. We are asked to notice where each of these voices lives in us, to keep the devotion, the leadership, the cultural fluency and the zeal, and to remember that the whole project exists for people who are trying to do their best with what they have.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: which group’s strength do you most want to borrow this week, and which group’s weakness do you most need to watch?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 82 — The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why (49:21): The Silent Years are finished, and the session turns to the Bible itself. The episode explores Israel as an oral culture, the exile as a catalyst for writing Scripture down, the Bible as a table of many voices in conversation, and how the dating of Daniel changes the force of Jesus calling himself “Son of Man.” It is a demanding episode that invites honest questions about how Scripture came to be.

What to bring next week: Read Daniel 7:13–14 and write down what the “son of man” figure receives. Come ready to share what you were taught, growing up, about who wrote the books of the Bible and when.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Silent Years — Pharisees.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 80. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/80. The Pharisees’ response to Rome, and Jesus’ focus on them because they had every piece except compassion. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Silent Years — Association.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 81. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/81. The “perfect timing” of Galatians 4:4 as the moment Judaism was wrestling with five responses to Hellenism. ↩

  3. Ep. 81 notes. Each group brought both positive contributions and negative tendencies, and every group has something God wants to use. ↩

  4. Ep. 81 notes. The hosts’ vulnerability and Marty’s critique of American evangelicalism as “the worst mix.” ↩

  5. Ep. 81 notes. The goal is to embrace the strengths while guarding against the weaknesses of all five approaches. ↩

  6. Ep. 81 notes. The story of the Amish travelers on Marty’s first Israel trip. ↩

  7. Ep. 81 notes. Three translations of Galatians 4:4. ↩

  8. Ep. 81 notes. The incarnation occurred when the five responses were in full dialogue. ↩

  9. Ep. 81 notes (original notes). Hellenism’s impact on how people interact with those who believe differently. ↩

  10. Ep. 81 notes. The positive contribution and negative tendency of each of the five groups. ↩

  11. Ep. 81 notes. The principle of association rather than identification. ↩

  12. Ep. 81 notes. Marty’s and Brent’s self-assessments. ↩

  13. Ep. 81 notes (original notes). Protestant and liturgical views of priesthood; Israel as a kingdom of priests with a priestly tribe. ↩

  14. Ep. 81 notes. The question for spiritual leaders drawn from the Sadducees. ↩

  15. Ep. 81 notes. Brent on the Zealots’ failure to see potential in people. ↩

  16. Ep. 81 notes. The question drawn from Brené Brown’s Rising Strong, as cited in the notes. ↩

  17. Ep. 81 notes. American evangelicalism as spiritually Pharisaic and culturally Herodian. ↩

  18. Ep. 81 notes. The consistency of the historical Pharisees and the plain villages of Chorazin, Capernaum and Bethsaida. ↩

  19. Ep. 81 notes. Brent’s question to Marty and the insight about creating space. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.