Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- Caesar’s Coin 20 min
- Resurrection and the Weightiest Command 20 min
- Who Is My Neighbor? 25 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Section | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 73 | Introduction | Session 3 Intro |
| 2 | 74 | Silent Years | Synagogue |
| 3 | 75 | Silent Years | Welcome to Hellenism |
| 4 | 76 | Silent Years | Sadducees |
| 5 | 77 | Silent Years | Herodians |
| 6 | 78 | Silent Years | Essenes |
| 7 | 79 | Silent Years | Zealots |
| 8 | 80 | Silent Years | Pharisees |
| 9 | 81 | Silent Years | Association |
| 10 | 82 | Reading the Gospels | The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why |
| 11 | 83 | Reading the Gospels | Gospel Narrative |
| 12 | 84 | The Four Gospels | Matthew — Mumzer |
| 13 | 85 | The Four Gospels | Mark — Roman Gospel |
| 14 | 86 | The Four Gospels | Luke — Ordered |
| 15 | 87 | The Four Gospels | John — Grafted |
| 16 | 88 | Matthew 1–4 | Setting the Stage |
| 17 | 89 | Matthew 1–4 | Written in the Stars |
| 18 | 90 | Matthew 1–4 | A Gospel of Two Kingdoms |
| 19 | 91 | Matthew 1–4 | Tavilah T'Shuvah |
| 20 | 92 | Matthew 1–4 | How to Bring Order Out of Chaos |
| 21 | 93 | Sermon on the Mount | Blessed |
| 22 | 94 | Sermon on the Mount | Hope of the World |
| 23 | 95 | Sermon on the Mount | Abolish or Fulfill |
| 24 | 96 | Sermon on the Mount | But I Say Unto You |
| 25 | 97 | Sermon on the Mount | Done in Secret |
| 26 | 98 | Sermon on the Mount | A Good Eye |
| 27 | 99 | Sermon on the Mount | Fruit of Fools |
| 28 | 100 | Matthew 8–12 | Healing at Great Cost |
| 29 | 101 | Matthew 8–12 | The Other Side |
| 30 | 102 | Matthew 8–12 | Son of Man |
| 31 | 103 | Matthew 8–12 | Healing in His Wings |
| 32 | 104 | Matthew 8–12 | Innocent as Doves |
| 33 | 105 | Matthew 8–12 | An Explosive Kingdom |
| 34 | 106 | Matthew 8–12 | Jury Duty in Sodom |
| 35 | 107 | Matthew 8–12 | Donkeys and Rabbis |
| 36 | 108 | Matthew 8–12 | The Fruit of Beelzebul |
| 37 | 109 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Which Soil? |
| 38 | 110 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Jewish Hermeneutics |
| 39 | 111 | Parables (Matthew 13) | A Farmer and a Woman |
| 40 | 112 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Explanations That Don’t Explain |
| 41 | 113 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Treasures and Pearls |
| 42 | 114 | Parables (Matthew 13) | Fish in a Net |
| 43 | 115 | Matthew 14–25 | 5 Loaves, 2 Fish, and 1 Big Lesson |
| 44 | 116 | Matthew 14–25 | She Giggled |
| 45 | 117 | Matthew 14–25 | Jesus Resorts to Name Calling |
| 46 | 118 | Matthew 14–25 | Eyes That Cannot See |
| 47 | 119 | Matthew 14–25 | The Gates of Hell |
| 48 | 120 | Matthew 14–25 | Truth and Light |
| 49 | 121 | Matthew 14–25 | The Key to Your Own Prison |
| 50 | 122 | Matthew 14–25 | A Naked Thing |
| 51 | 123 | Matthew 14–25 | The Heat of the Day |
| 52 | 124 | Matthew 14–25 | Statement of Triumph |
| 53 | 125 | Matthew 14–25 | Are You Talking to Me? |
| 54 | 126 | Matthew 14–25 | Trapped by a Question |
| 55 | 127 | Matthew 14–25 | Six or Seven? |
| 56 | 128 | Matthew 14–25 | Faithful and Wise Steward |
| 57 | 129 | Matthew 26–28 | The Final Week |
| 58 | 130 | Matthew 26–28 | The Plot to Kill Jesus |
| 59 | 131 | Matthew 26–28 | Betrayal |
| 60 | 132 | Matthew 26–28 | Go |
| 61 | 133 | Capstone | Session 3 Capstone |
Last week: Jesus told three parables aimed at the corrupt priestly leadership of the temple, and the episode drew a careful line between his patient years among the Pharisees and his one week confronting the Sadducees, asking whether we are missing the party God is already throwing.
This week: Groups that rarely agree on anything join forces to trap Jesus with questions. Each time, Jesus turns the question back on the questioners, and along the way he pushes the meaning of “neighbor” further than anyone expected.
About This Session
The episode notes the unusual cooperation of Pharisees, Sadducees, and Herodians in trying to trap Jesus. The first question, about paying tribute to Caesar, is presented as a question about idolatry rather than taxes, because the tribute coin carried Caesar’s image and a claim to divinity. The second, from the Sadducees, uses a woman married to seven brothers to mock the resurrection. The third asks for the greatest commandment, which the episode explains as a question about a rabbi’s “yoke,” the lens through which he reads Torah.
The episode then brings in Luke’s parable of the Good Samaritan, where Jesus breaks the expected pattern of a story and echoes an account in 2 Chronicles 28 of Samaritans caring for captured people of Judah. It ends with Jesus’ own question about how the Messiah can be both David’s son and David’s Lord. Some of this touches on allegiance to nation and party, and on what to do when commands seem to conflict, so expect honest differences in the room.
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Think of a time someone asked you a question that was really a trap, where any answer would get you in trouble. How did you respond?
Caesar’s Coin 20 min
A question about money turns out to be a question about worship.
Read Matthew 22:15–22 aloud.
Q1: Notice who comes together to ask this question. The notes say the cooperation of Pharisees, Sadducees, and Herodians “demonstrates the intensity of their desire to trap and discredit Jesus.”1 The episode explains that the Greek word kensos (“tribute”) refers not to general taxes but to a coin that served as proof of worship to Caesar, bearing his image and an inscription proclaiming his divinity.2 What do you notice about the questioners’ opening flattery and Jesus’ request to see the coin? How does knowing what was on the coin change the question?
Q2: Optional The notes lay out the positions of the day. The Herodians saw worship as external motions; the Sadducees prized political stability; the Essenes withdrew to the desert; the Zealots said anyone who pays deserves death; Shammai’s Pharisees called it idolatry; and Hillel’s Pharisees argued that God had given authority to Rome, so buying the coin returned to Caesar what God already gave him.3 Which of these instincts do you recognize in yourself or in Christians today when faith meets politics?
Q3: The episode says Jesus follows Hillel’s reasoning but goes further, in effect saying: “Give Caesar his coin, but don’t you dare give him your worship.”4 The notes ask what in our world demands that kind of devotion: “Nation, political party, economic system, social status—all may demand the worship we owe to God alone.”5 Without pointing at anyone else, what in your own life competes most for the allegiance that belongs to God?
Resurrection and the Weightiest Command 20 min
Jesus answers from his questioners’ own Scriptures and names the lens through which he reads them.
Read Matthew 22:23–33 aloud.
Q4: Optional The Sadducees, who did not believe in the bodily resurrection the Pharisees taught, tried to show its absurdity. The notes say Jesus reframed the question, since marriage is not a category in the resurrection, and then cited the Torah the Sadducees accepted, where God calls himself the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, the God “of the living.”6 What do you notice about the way Jesus chooses his evidence?
Read Matthew 22:34–40 aloud.
Q5: The episode explains that asking for the greatest commandment was asking for a rabbi’s “yoke,” his interpretive lens. Shammai paired love of God with keeping Sabbath (shorthand for obedience); Hillel paired love of God with love of neighbor. “Jesus clearly sides with Hillel, making love the weightiest commandment upon which ‘all the Law and the Prophets hang.’”7 If love is the peg everything hangs on, what difference does that make when you read a hard passage?
Q6: The notes connect this to “weight,” kavod, which helps when commandments conflict. Rahab lied to protect the Israelite spies, choosing “the weightier command to protect the foreigner,” and she is honored in Hebrews 11. The notes compare this to people who hid Jews from the Nazis.8 Our traditions may weigh truth-telling and protection differently, and that is a fair thing to explore. Without needing to agree, when have you faced two good commands pulling in opposite directions, and how did you decide which carried more weight?
Who Is My Neighbor? 25 min
Jesus pushes love past even Hillel’s boundary, and Scripture had already shown the way.
Read Luke 10:25–37 aloud.
Q7: The notes say Jewish parables commonly followed a template: a priest (who does wrong), a Levite (stuck in the system, who does wrong), and a Pharisee (who does right). Jesus replaces the Pharisee with a Samaritan, “the most hated group in Jewish society.” The neighbor debate had clear lines: for Shammai, only fellow Jews; for Hillel, Jews and even Romans, “but NOT Samaritans.”9 Who did the original audience expect to walk down the road third? Who would that third person be in a story told to your community today?
Read 2 Chronicles 28:8–15 aloud.
Q8: The episode says the parable alludes to this passage, where Samaritans who had defeated Judah clothed the naked prisoners, gave them food and drink, healed them, put the weak on donkeys, and returned them to Jericho. “Scripture already demonstrated Samaritans caring for Jews at Jericho.”10 List the parallels you notice between the two stories. What does it add that Jesus’ shocking story was already in the Scriptures his audience knew?
Q9: Optional Jesus ends the day with his own question: if the Messiah is David’s son, why does David call him “Lord” in Psalm 110? The notes say this suggests the Messiah must be “more than merely a human descendant of David.”11 Read Psalm 110:1. What do you make of the question, and why do you think it silenced the opposition?
Q10: The notes offer two possible centers to the structure of 2 Chronicles 28: the three Samaritan names, showing that those who act rightly are the true neighbors, or the question “Aren’t you also guilty?”, showing our common humanity.12 The episode adds that the priest and Levite probably had correct theology but failed in practice, so “Orthopraxy (right practice) matters as much as orthodoxy (right belief).”13 Who are the “Samaritans” in your life, the people you are tempted to place beyond the reach of God’s love? What would neighborly love toward one of them look like this week?
Closing 15 min
Jesus’ opponents set three traps, and each time he turned the question back on them. He told them to give Caesar his coin but never their worship, answered the Sadducees from the Torah they accepted, and named love as the weightiest commandment. Then he pushed love past even Hillel’s boundary by making a Samaritan the hero, echoing a story where Samaritans had already cared for wounded people of Judah. The question was never only “Who is my neighbor?” but whether we will do what a neighbor does.
Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one concrete act of neighbor love you will practice this week, and toward whom?
Looking Ahead
Ep. 127 — Six or Seven? (28:31): In Matthew 23, Jesus pronounces woes on the Pharisees while affirming their devotion to Scripture. The episode explores the Greek word behind “hypocrite,” which it explains as “actor,” and argues that Jesus adds a seventh woe to Isaiah’s six to make a point about self-righteousness.
What to bring next week: Read Isaiah 5:8–23 and count the woes. Write down, in a phrase, what kind of person Isaiah is describing.
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Trapped by a Question.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 126. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/126. The cooperation of Pharisees, Sadducees, and Herodians in trying to trap Jesus. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. Kensos as a tribute coin proclaiming Caesar’s divinity. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. The positions of the Herodians, Sadducees, Essenes, Zealots, and the schools of Shammai and Hillel on tribute. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. Jesus follows Hillel’s reasoning while forbidding worship of Caesar. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. Modern allegiance and idolatry. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. The Sadducees’ resurrection question and Jesus’ answer from Torah. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. The greatest commandment as a rabbi’s yoke and Jesus’ alignment with Hillel. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. Kavod (weight), Rahab’s choice, and the World War II analogy. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. The priest-Levite-Pharisee parable template and the neighbor debate. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. The remez to 2 Chronicles 28 in the parable of the Good Samaritan. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. Jesus’ question about Psalm 110 and the Messiah’s identity. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. The two possible centers of the chiasm in 2 Chronicles 28. ↩
-
Ep. 126 notes. Orthopraxy and orthodoxy in the priest and Levite. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.