BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 3 · Week 17 of 61

Episode 89

Written in the Stars

Matthew 1:18–2:12: A Scandalous Birth and Pagan Stargazers

90-minute session Matthew 1:18–25; Matthew 2:1–12; Luke 2:7; Numbers 24:15–19; Isaiah 7:14; Mark 1:9–11; Mark 15:37–39

For group discussion. Listen to episode 89 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. A Scandalous Pregnancy 25 min
  3. Magi and a Rising Star 20 min
  4. Tearing the Heavens 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 3 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 73 Introduction Session 3 Intro
2 74 Silent Years Synagogue
3 75 Silent Years Welcome to Hellenism
4 76 Silent Years Sadducees
5 77 Silent Years Herodians
6 78 Silent Years Essenes
7 79 Silent Years Zealots
8 80 Silent Years Pharisees
9 81 Silent Years Association
10 82 Reading the Gospels The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why
11 83 Reading the Gospels Gospel Narrative
12 84 The Four Gospels Matthew — Mumzer
13 85 The Four Gospels Mark — Roman Gospel
14 86 The Four Gospels Luke — Ordered
15 87 The Four Gospels John — Grafted
16 88 Matthew 1–4 Setting the Stage
17 89 Matthew 1–4 Written in the Stars
18 90 Matthew 1–4 A Gospel of Two Kingdoms
19 91 Matthew 1–4 Tavilah T'Shuvah
20 92 Matthew 1–4 How to Bring Order Out of Chaos
21 93 Sermon on the Mount Blessed
22 94 Sermon on the Mount Hope of the World
23 95 Sermon on the Mount Abolish or Fulfill
24 96 Sermon on the Mount But I Say Unto You
25 97 Sermon on the Mount Done in Secret
26 98 Sermon on the Mount A Good Eye
27 99 Sermon on the Mount Fruit of Fools
28 100 Matthew 8–12 Healing at Great Cost
29 101 Matthew 8–12 The Other Side
30 102 Matthew 8–12 Son of Man
31 103 Matthew 8–12 Healing in His Wings
32 104 Matthew 8–12 Innocent as Doves
33 105 Matthew 8–12 An Explosive Kingdom
34 106 Matthew 8–12 Jury Duty in Sodom
35 107 Matthew 8–12 Donkeys and Rabbis
36 108 Matthew 8–12 The Fruit of Beelzebul
37 109 Parables (Matthew 13) Which Soil?
38 110 Parables (Matthew 13) Jewish Hermeneutics
39 111 Parables (Matthew 13) A Farmer and a Woman
40 112 Parables (Matthew 13) Explanations That Don’t Explain
41 113 Parables (Matthew 13) Treasures and Pearls
42 114 Parables (Matthew 13) Fish in a Net
43 115 Matthew 14–25 5 Loaves, 2 Fish, and 1 Big Lesson
44 116 Matthew 14–25 She Giggled
45 117 Matthew 14–25 Jesus Resorts to Name Calling
46 118 Matthew 14–25 Eyes That Cannot See
47 119 Matthew 14–25 The Gates of Hell
48 120 Matthew 14–25 Truth and Light
49 121 Matthew 14–25 The Key to Your Own Prison
50 122 Matthew 14–25 A Naked Thing
51 123 Matthew 14–25 The Heat of the Day
52 124 Matthew 14–25 Statement of Triumph
53 125 Matthew 14–25 Are You Talking to Me?
54 126 Matthew 14–25 Trapped by a Question
55 127 Matthew 14–25 Six or Seven?
56 128 Matthew 14–25 Faithful and Wise Steward
57 129 Matthew 26–28 The Final Week
58 130 Matthew 26–28 The Plot to Kill Jesus
59 131 Matthew 26–28 Betrayal
60 132 Matthew 26–28 Go
61 133 Capstone Session 3 Capstone

Last week: We stood with the hosts on Mount Arbel, saw five very different worldviews packed around the Sea of Galilee, and heard why Jesus’s move to Capernaum was an act of courage rather than retreat.

This week: The story itself begins. The episode reads Matthew’s account of Jesus’s birth through a first-century lens and asks what the Christmas story looked like before we tidied it up.

About This Session

This episode strips away the golden-straw version of Christmas. Mary’s pregnancy during betrothal would have brought real shame on two families, and Joseph, a man faithful to the law, chose to end the betrothal quietly to protect her.1 The episode reads the “no room” detail as a family guest room rather than a full inn, which points to rejection rather than bad luck.2

The second half widens the frame to the night sky. The Magi were likely astrologers from Babylon or Persia who knew Balaam’s ancient prophecy of a star rising out of Jacob.3 The episode sets their visit against Mithraism, a fast-growing religion in the Roman world built around a cosmic intervener, and shows how Mark’s “torn” heavens and torn veil would have spoken to Roman readers.4 Running through it all is Matthew’s theme that God works through outsiders and unlikely people, well outside the boundaries we draw.5

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of the nativity scene, Christmas pageant or holiday card picture you remember best from childhood. What did it look like, and what parts of real family life did it leave out?

A Scandalous Pregnancy 25 min

The first Christmas was messier, and more hopeful, than the version on our mantels.

Read Matthew 1:18–25 aloud.

Q1: The notes explain that in first-century Jewish culture “betrothal (engagement) was legally equivalent to marriage,” so Joseph “needed a formal divorce to break the betrothal covenant, not just a canceled engagement.”6 They describe him as “faithful to the law” yet compassionate.7 Walk back through the passage. What choices does Joseph make, in what order, and what does each one cost him?

Q2: The notes point out that “Few people would have believed Mary’s story about the Holy Spirit.”8 They read Luke’s word kataluma as “guest room” rather than inn, and conclude that in a culture of hospitality, “putting a pregnant woman in the lower level with animals was a deliberate act of social rejection.”9 Read Luke 2:7 aloud. How does picturing a family that would not make room, instead of a hotel with no vacancy, change the way you feel about this scene?

Q3: Optional Matthew quotes Isaiah 7:14 about Emmanuel. The notes say that in its original setting the prophecy “referred to Isaiah’s time, possibly about Hezekiah,” and that Matthew is doing pattern recognition rather than simple prediction: “Those same oppressive days Isaiah spoke about are happening again, and here is God with us.”10 Read Isaiah 7:14 aloud. Our traditions have taught us to read Matthew’s “fulfilled” language in different ways. What has your tradition’s reading helped you see, and what does this pattern reading add or raise questions about for you?

Q4: The notes put it sharply: “The sanitized version offers comfort to the comfortable; the real version offers hope to the hurting.”11 Who do you know, perhaps yourself, who is living through family rejection, shame or circumstances they never chose, and what would it mean for them to hear the real version of this story?

Magi and a Rising Star 20 min

Some of the first people to honor Jesus were foreign astrologers reading an old Hebrew prophecy.

Read Numbers 24:15–19 and Matthew 2:1–12 aloud.

Q5: The notes describe Balaam as “a Babylonian astrologer/prophet hired by King Balak of Moab to curse Israel” who blessed Israel instead.12 They say the Magi likely came from Babylon or Persia and that “The Magi’s statement ‘We saw his star when it rose’ directly echoes this ancient prophecy.”13 Put the two passages side by side. What words, images or ideas do you notice that connect them?

Q6: Optional The notes record that the Magi “would have had access to both ancient astronomical records and Hebrew Scriptures” and combined the two.14 They also mention a debate about what the star was, including the possibility that “the star stopped over the place” refers to astrological positioning rather than a literal moving star.15 What do you make of God meeting these men through the very practice they already knew?

Q7: The notes observe that “God sent dreams to pagan astrologers to guide them,” and that “We have no record they became believers or started churches.”16 They call this a reminder that “God’s activity extends far beyond our comfortable religious boundaries.”17 Where have you seen God at work in someone or somewhere you did not expect, and how did you respond at the time?

Tearing the Heavens 20 min

Mark tells the story in words that a Roman audience shaped by Mithraism would have recognized.

Read Mark 1:9–11 and Mark 15:37–39 aloud.

Q8: The notes explain that Mithraism was “The fastest-growing religion in the first-century Roman Empire,” and that its story told of a deity who “came into the cosmic universe and altered its course,” marked by a cross for “the ‘tear’ where Mithra entered the cosmic sea.”18 Its birth story had Mithra “born in a cave, attended by shepherds.”19 Look at the verbs Mark uses at the baptism and at the death of Jesus. What do you notice, and what might a Roman reader have heard?

Q9: Optional The notes argue that Romans would only have known the outer temple veil, which “According to Josephus, the outer veil displayed the Zodiac,” so Mark creates “a cosmic bookend: Jesus tears into the world (baptism) and tears out (crucifixion).”20 They insist the birth-story parallels “aren’t coincidental plagiarism but show God’s providential timing.”21 How does this way of reading Mark sit with you, and what questions does it raise?

Q10: The notes summarize the early Christian approach this way: “You’re looking for this kind of savior? Let us tell you about the true one.”22 They call Mark’s choice “brilliant contextualization - he’s speaking their language.”23 Think about the people you spend time with. What are they hoping will change their world, and how could you speak about Jesus in a language they already understand?

Closing 15 min

The birth of Jesus did not happen in a tidy, sunlit stable. It happened in the middle of a scandal, to a young woman few believed and a righteous man who chose mercy over his own reputation, in a home that may not have made room for them. The first people from outside Israel to honor the child were foreign stargazers who had read Balaam’s old promise of a rising star. Mark would later tell the story so that Romans, watching the skies for a savior, could see who truly tore into the world. From the very first chapter, God was working well outside the lines we draw.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: where do you most need the messy, real version of the Christmas story this year?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 90 — A Gospel of Two Kingdoms (23:42): The episode concludes the birth narratives by setting Jesus beside the most powerful rulers of his day, Herod the Great in Matthew and Caesar Augustus in Luke. It asks what it means that the King of the universe arrived in poverty, in the shadow of one of Herod’s palaces, and returns to the Empire versus Shalom theme that has run through BEMA since Session 1.

What to bring next week: Read Matthew 2:13–23 and Luke 2:1–14. Make two short lists: every powerful person named in these passages, and every powerless or overlooked person.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Written in the Stars.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 89. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/89. Mary’s pregnancy during betrothal brought cultural shame, and Joseph chose to divorce her quietly out of faithfulness and compassion. ↩

  2. Ep. 89 notes. The kataluma as a guest room and the implication of family rejection. ↩

  3. Ep. 89 notes. The Magi as Babylonian or Persian astrologers who knew Balaam’s prophecy in Numbers 24:17. ↩

  4. Ep. 89 notes. Mithraism as the fastest-growing religion of the Roman world and Mark’s use of torn heavens and a torn veil. ↩

  5. Ep. 89 notes. Matthew’s mamzer (outcast) theme and God working outside the boundaries we create. ↩

  6. Ep. 89 notes. Betrothal as legally equivalent to marriage, requiring a formal divorce. ↩

  7. Ep. 89 notes. Joseph as faithful to the law yet compassionate. ↩

  8. Ep. 89 notes. The disbelief and shame surrounding Mary’s pregnancy. ↩

  9. Ep. 89 notes. Kataluma means guest room, and placing Mary with the animals signaled social rejection. ↩

  10. Ep. 89 notes. Matthew’s use of Isaiah 7:14 as pattern recognition rather than simple prediction and fulfillment. ↩

  11. Ep. 89 notes. The real Christmas story offers hope to people experiencing rejection and shame. ↩

  12. Ep. 89 notes. Balaam as a Babylonian astrologer and prophet who blessed Israel instead of cursing it. ↩

  13. Ep. 89 notes. The Magi’s words echo Balaam’s prophecy of a star coming out of Jacob. ↩

  14. Ep. 89 notes. The Magi combined astronomical records with knowledge of Hebrew Scripture. ↩

  15. Ep. 89 notes. The debate over the nature of the star and the possibility of an astrological reading. ↩

  16. Ep. 89 notes. God guided the Magi through dreams, with no record of their conversion. ↩

  17. Ep. 89 notes. God’s activity extends beyond our religious boundaries. ↩

  18. Ep. 89 notes. The origins and narrative of Mithraism, including the cross as the tear into the cosmic sea. ↩

  19. Ep. 89 notes. Mithra’s birth narrative of a cave and shepherds. ↩

  20. Ep. 89 notes. The outer temple veil, Josephus, and the cosmic bookend of Mark’s Gospel. ↩

  21. Ep. 89 notes. The Mithra parallels as a sign of providential timing rather than plagiarism. ↩

  22. Ep. 89 notes. Early Christians presented Jesus as the true savior the Roman world was looking for. ↩

  23. Ep. 89 notes. Mark’s torn veil as contextualization for a Roman audience. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.