BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 3 · Week 59 of 61

Episode 131

Betrayal

Judas and Peter: Two Failures, Two Endings

90-minute session Matthew 26:14–16; Matthew 26:47–50; Matthew 27:3–10; Zechariah 11:12–17; Matthew 26:69–75; Mark 16:7; John 21:15–19

For group discussion. Listen to episode 131 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. The Man From Keriot 20 min
  3. The Other Betrayal 25 min
  4. Is There a Tomorrow? 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 3 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 73 Introduction Session 3 Intro
2 74 Silent Years Synagogue
3 75 Silent Years Welcome to Hellenism
4 76 Silent Years Sadducees
5 77 Silent Years Herodians
6 78 Silent Years Essenes
7 79 Silent Years Zealots
8 80 Silent Years Pharisees
9 81 Silent Years Association
10 82 Reading the Gospels The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why
11 83 Reading the Gospels Gospel Narrative
12 84 The Four Gospels Matthew — Mumzer
13 85 The Four Gospels Mark — Roman Gospel
14 86 The Four Gospels Luke — Ordered
15 87 The Four Gospels John — Grafted
16 88 Matthew 1–4 Setting the Stage
17 89 Matthew 1–4 Written in the Stars
18 90 Matthew 1–4 A Gospel of Two Kingdoms
19 91 Matthew 1–4 Tavilah T'Shuvah
20 92 Matthew 1–4 How to Bring Order Out of Chaos
21 93 Sermon on the Mount Blessed
22 94 Sermon on the Mount Hope of the World
23 95 Sermon on the Mount Abolish or Fulfill
24 96 Sermon on the Mount But I Say Unto You
25 97 Sermon on the Mount Done in Secret
26 98 Sermon on the Mount A Good Eye
27 99 Sermon on the Mount Fruit of Fools
28 100 Matthew 8–12 Healing at Great Cost
29 101 Matthew 8–12 The Other Side
30 102 Matthew 8–12 Son of Man
31 103 Matthew 8–12 Healing in His Wings
32 104 Matthew 8–12 Innocent as Doves
33 105 Matthew 8–12 An Explosive Kingdom
34 106 Matthew 8–12 Jury Duty in Sodom
35 107 Matthew 8–12 Donkeys and Rabbis
36 108 Matthew 8–12 The Fruit of Beelzebul
37 109 Parables (Matthew 13) Which Soil?
38 110 Parables (Matthew 13) Jewish Hermeneutics
39 111 Parables (Matthew 13) A Farmer and a Woman
40 112 Parables (Matthew 13) Explanations That Don’t Explain
41 113 Parables (Matthew 13) Treasures and Pearls
42 114 Parables (Matthew 13) Fish in a Net
43 115 Matthew 14–25 5 Loaves, 2 Fish, and 1 Big Lesson
44 116 Matthew 14–25 She Giggled
45 117 Matthew 14–25 Jesus Resorts to Name Calling
46 118 Matthew 14–25 Eyes That Cannot See
47 119 Matthew 14–25 The Gates of Hell
48 120 Matthew 14–25 Truth and Light
49 121 Matthew 14–25 The Key to Your Own Prison
50 122 Matthew 14–25 A Naked Thing
51 123 Matthew 14–25 The Heat of the Day
52 124 Matthew 14–25 Statement of Triumph
53 125 Matthew 14–25 Are You Talking to Me?
54 126 Matthew 14–25 Trapped by a Question
55 127 Matthew 14–25 Six or Seven?
56 128 Matthew 14–25 Faithful and Wise Steward
57 129 Matthew 26–28 The Final Week
58 130 Matthew 26–28 The Plot to Kill Jesus
59 131 Matthew 26–28 Betrayal
60 132 Matthew 26–28 Go
61 133 Capstone Session 3 Capstone

Last week: We asked who killed Jesus and heard a clear answer: not the Jewish people, who loved him, but a small, corrupt group of chief priests who tried him at night and pushed Pilate into a corner. Misreading this story has cost millions of Jewish lives.1

This week: We turn to the two disciples who failed Jesus on his last night, Judas and Peter, and ask what really separates their stories.2

About This Session

The episode speaks of the betrayals of Jesus, plural. It explores Judas Iscariot’s name as “man from Keriot,” a place the notes connect to the Zealots, and suggests Judas may have believed he was forcing Jesus’ hand to start a revolution rather than betraying him. It also traces how closely Judas’s actions follow Zechariah 11.3 Then it makes a surprising claim: from a rabbinical perspective, Peter’s public denial of his rabbi was the more serious betrayal.4

The heart of the episode is its ending. The difference between Judas and Peter “is not the severity of their mistakes, but whether they believed there could be a tomorrow after their failure.”5 This story includes Judas’s death by suicide. Some of us carry losses or struggles that make this hard to hear, and the notes themselves ask how the church can teach it with “pastoral sensitivity.”6 Please be gentle with one another, and feel free to pass on any question.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of someone you once misunderstood badly: you were sure you knew what they meant or wanted, and you turned out to be wrong. What finally showed you the truth?

The Man From Keriot 20 min

Judas may have heard what he wanted to hear.

Read Matthew 26:14–16 and Matthew 26:47–50 aloud.

Q1: The notes explain that “Iscariot” comes from the Hebrew ish Keriot, “man from Keriot,” and that Keriot may have been a Zealot compound. Seen this way, Judas’s concern for the poor, his role as treasurer, and even his taking from the money bag with a “Robin Hood mentality” fit a Zealot outlook.7 After a week of Jesus confronting the chief priests, the notes picture Judas “champing at the bit,” likely believing “he was forcing Jesus’s hand to kickstart the revolution, not betraying him.”8 As you hear these verses, what details fit that picture, and what details resist it?

Read Zechariah 11:12–13 aloud, then read Matthew 27:3–10 aloud.

Q2: The notes show how closely Judas’s actions mirror Zechariah 11: a prophecy against corrupt shepherds, thirty pieces of silver, the silver thrown “to the potter at the house of the Lord,” and a closing word, “Woe to the worthless shepherd, who deserts the flock.” They suggest Judas may have taken that last condemnation onto himself.9 What parallels do you notice between the two passages? What does it suggest that Judas may have known Scripture this well and still misread his teacher?

Q3: Optional The notes stress that all the disciples, not just Judas, seem to have misread Jesus as leading a Zealot-style revolution; even after the resurrection they asked, “Are you going to restore the Kingdom now?”10 They add that “People can know a teacher well, hear their teachings repeatedly, and still completely misunderstand their intent.”11 Where might you be filtering Jesus’ words through an agenda of your own?

The Other Betrayal 25 min

A rabbinical reader would have pointed to a different disciple.

Read Matthew 26:69–75 aloud.

Q4: Follow Peter through the three denials. What changes from the first to the third, in who is asking, where he is, and what he says?

Q5: The notes say that a disciple trying to do the right thing and making a terrible mistake is part of the learning process, but that publicly disassociating from one’s rabbi was “unheard of in rabbinical discipleship, the truest form of a slap to the face of his teacher.” Peter understood this; he went back to fishing “because he knew his time as a disciple was over.”12 The notes add that the Gospel writers call Judas “the betrayer” so often, “awkwardly often,” precisely because first-century Jewish readers would naturally have pointed to Peter.13 How does this change the way you see Peter’s tears in verse 75?

Read Mark 16:7 aloud, then read John 21:15–19 aloud.

Q6: The notes point out that the message at the empty tomb is to “tell his disciples and Peter,” because Peter would no longer have been counted a disciple, and that without John’s Gospel we would have almost no record of Peter’s reinstatement on the beach. That reinstatement was “necessary for Peter to later become the leader seen in Acts.”14 What do you notice in the way Jesus restores Peter? Why might it matter that the restoration is named, specific, and public?

Q7: Optional Peter heard his name singled out after the worst failure of his life. Who in your life might need to hear their name spoken, the way “and Peter” was spoken, to know they are still wanted?

Is There a Tomorrow? 20 min

The two stories end differently, and the episode says that is the whole point.

Q8: The notes put it plainly: “Both made huge mistakes - one misjudged his teacher’s mission, the other publicly denied any connection.” Judas “decided his mistakes could not be overcome,” while Peter “was willing to face his greatest fears and insecurities, trusting Jesus to give him a new tomorrow.”15 The episode concludes that “The only true betrayal of Jesus is believing there’s no coming back, no second chance, no hope.”16 What do you make of that claim? What does it say about what Jesus most wants from people who have failed him?

Q9: Optional The episode links this story to Genesis. Peter’s question about forgiving “70 times 7” echoes Lamech in Cain’s line, and God’s word to Cain, “If you do what’s right, you’ll be accepted,” parallels Jesus’ message to Peter. The notes say “The pattern of not being defined by one’s biggest mistakes runs throughout Scripture.”17 Where else in our study have you seen God refuse to let someone be defined by their worst moment?

Q10: The notes describe this as a story of “Jesus’s ministry of second chances, bottomless grace, and wasteful love.”18 Think of a failure, old or recent, that you still carry. Without needing to name it aloud, what would it look like to let Jesus give you a tomorrow after it? Share as much or as little as you wish.

Closing 15 min

On the same night, two disciples failed their rabbi. Judas, perhaps a Zealot who thought he was forcing a revolution, handed Jesus over for thirty pieces of silver. Peter, the bold one, swore three times that he did not know him, a deeper break by the standards of his day. Both stories could have ended there. One did. The other heard “and Peter,” met Jesus on a beach, and was given a new tomorrow. The episode leaves us with this: the only true betrayal is believing there is no way back.19

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one word you want to say to someone (perhaps yourself) about second chances this week?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 132 — Go (30:06): The final teaching episode of the Gospels walks through Matthew 28. It presents the resurrection as God’s definitive answer that the order of life defeats the order of death, argues that the Great Commission was likely given on a mountain in Galilee, notices that Jesus commissioned his followers even though “some doubted,” and offers a challenging reading of what it means to “make disciples.”20

What to bring next week: Read Matthew 28 slowly. Pay attention to verse 17 and write down what you think it means that some doubted, right before Jesus sends them out.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “The Plot to Kill Jesus.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 130. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/130. The Jewish people did not kill Jesus; a corrupt group of chief priests orchestrated his execution, and the false narrative has caused immense harm. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Betrayal.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 131. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/131. The betrayals of Jesus by Judas and Peter. ↩

  3. Ep. 131 notes. Judas as a likely Zealot and the Zechariah 11 connection. ↩

  4. Ep. 131 notes. Peter’s denial as the more serious betrayal from a rabbinical perspective. ↩

  5. Ep. 131 notes. The key difference between Judas and Peter. ↩

  6. Ep. 131 notes. Areas for further exploration on depression, suicide, and biblical narratives. ↩

  7. Ep. 131 notes. Judas as a Zealot from Keriot. ↩

  8. Ep. 131 notes. The Zealot misreading of Jesus’ mission. ↩

  9. Ep. 131 notes. The Zechariah 11 connection. ↩

  10. Ep. 131 notes. All the disciples misreading Jesus’ mission. ↩

  11. Ep. 131 notes. Modern application on misreading Jesus. ↩

  12. Ep. 131 notes. Peter’s denial as the true betrayal. ↩

  13. Ep. 131 notes. The Gospel writers’ repeated labelling of Judas as the betrayer. ↩

  14. Ep. 131 notes. The reinstatement protocol: “tell his disciples and Peter” and John’s account of the beach. ↩

  15. Ep. 131 notes. The theology of second chances. ↩

  16. Ep. 131 notes. The only true betrayal of Jesus. ↩

  17. Ep. 131 notes. The Cain and Abel connection. ↩

  18. Ep. 131 notes. Key takeaway on second chances, grace, and love. ↩

  19. Ep. 131 notes. Personal summary contrasting the endings of Judas’s and Peter’s stories. ↩

  20. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Go.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 132. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/132. The resurrection, the Great Commission in Galilee, doubt, and discipleship. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.