BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 3 · Week 23 of 61

Episode 95

Abolish or Fulfill

Matthew 5:17–20: Fulfilling Torah by Reading It Rightly and Walking It Out

90-minute session Matthew 5:17–20; Matthew 3:16–17; Matthew 7:28–29; Luke 24:44; Matthew 28:18

For group discussion. Listen to episode 95 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. What Fulfill Means 25 min
  3. Authority to Interpret 20 min
  4. Reading Everything Through Jesus 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 3 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSectionFocus
1 73 Introduction Session 3 Intro
2 74 Silent Years Synagogue
3 75 Silent Years Welcome to Hellenism
4 76 Silent Years Sadducees
5 77 Silent Years Herodians
6 78 Silent Years Essenes
7 79 Silent Years Zealots
8 80 Silent Years Pharisees
9 81 Silent Years Association
10 82 Reading the Gospels The Text — When, Where, Who, and Why
11 83 Reading the Gospels Gospel Narrative
12 84 The Four Gospels Matthew — Mumzer
13 85 The Four Gospels Mark — Roman Gospel
14 86 The Four Gospels Luke — Ordered
15 87 The Four Gospels John — Grafted
16 88 Matthew 1–4 Setting the Stage
17 89 Matthew 1–4 Written in the Stars
18 90 Matthew 1–4 A Gospel of Two Kingdoms
19 91 Matthew 1–4 Tavilah T'Shuvah
20 92 Matthew 1–4 How to Bring Order Out of Chaos
21 93 Sermon on the Mount Blessed
22 94 Sermon on the Mount Hope of the World
23 95 Sermon on the Mount Abolish or Fulfill
24 96 Sermon on the Mount But I Say Unto You
25 97 Sermon on the Mount Done in Secret
26 98 Sermon on the Mount A Good Eye
27 99 Sermon on the Mount Fruit of Fools
28 100 Matthew 8–12 Healing at Great Cost
29 101 Matthew 8–12 The Other Side
30 102 Matthew 8–12 Son of Man
31 103 Matthew 8–12 Healing in His Wings
32 104 Matthew 8–12 Innocent as Doves
33 105 Matthew 8–12 An Explosive Kingdom
34 106 Matthew 8–12 Jury Duty in Sodom
35 107 Matthew 8–12 Donkeys and Rabbis
36 108 Matthew 8–12 The Fruit of Beelzebul
37 109 Parables (Matthew 13) Which Soil?
38 110 Parables (Matthew 13) Jewish Hermeneutics
39 111 Parables (Matthew 13) A Farmer and a Woman
40 112 Parables (Matthew 13) Explanations That Don’t Explain
41 113 Parables (Matthew 13) Treasures and Pearls
42 114 Parables (Matthew 13) Fish in a Net
43 115 Matthew 14–25 5 Loaves, 2 Fish, and 1 Big Lesson
44 116 Matthew 14–25 She Giggled
45 117 Matthew 14–25 Jesus Resorts to Name Calling
46 118 Matthew 14–25 Eyes That Cannot See
47 119 Matthew 14–25 The Gates of Hell
48 120 Matthew 14–25 Truth and Light
49 121 Matthew 14–25 The Key to Your Own Prison
50 122 Matthew 14–25 A Naked Thing
51 123 Matthew 14–25 The Heat of the Day
52 124 Matthew 14–25 Statement of Triumph
53 125 Matthew 14–25 Are You Talking to Me?
54 126 Matthew 14–25 Trapped by a Question
55 127 Matthew 14–25 Six or Seven?
56 128 Matthew 14–25 Faithful and Wise Steward
57 129 Matthew 26–28 The Final Week
58 130 Matthew 26–28 The Plot to Kill Jesus
59 131 Matthew 26–28 Betrayal
60 132 Matthew 26–28 Go
61 133 Capstone Session 3 Capstone

Last week: Jesus turned to his disciples and called them salt, light and a city on a hill, a gate where the poor outside the walls could find provision and hope.

This week: Jesus pauses to answer the question his blessing on outsiders raises: is he throwing out the Bible?

About This Session

This episode takes on Jesus’s statement that he came not to abolish the Law and the Prophets but to fulfill them. Many Christians were taught that this means Jesus completed the law so we no longer need it. The episode instead explains the words in their rabbinic setting: to “fulfill” Torah is to interpret it correctly and walk it out in life, and to “abolish” it is to misinterpret it or fail to live it.1 In effect, Jesus is inviting people to watch him to see how the Bible should be read and lived.

The episode then introduces s’micha, the authority to offer new interpretations of Torah, and argues that Jesus received it at his baptism from John and from the voice of God.2 That authority is what lets him say, “You have heard it said, but I say to you.” The episode closes with a challenge to read all of Scripture, including its hardest passages, through Jesus’s own lens of loving God and loving others.3

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of someone who taught you a skill mostly by letting you watch them do it: cooking, fixing an engine, teaching a class, raising children. What did you learn from watching that you never could have learned from instructions alone?

What Fulfill Means 25 min

In Jesus’s world, to fulfill Torah was to read it rightly and live it rightly.

Read Matthew 5:17–20 aloud.

Q1: Read the passage slowly, perhaps twice. What do you notice about how Jesus talks about the Law: how long it lasts, how small a commandment he cares about, and what kind of righteousness he expects? Which line surprises you most?

Q2: The notes explain that in the rabbinic world fulfillment requires “Correct intellectual/theological interpretation of Torah” and “Walking out that interpretation through behavior and obedience (halach - one’s walk).”4 Abolishment happens when Torah is interpreted incorrectly, or interpreted correctly but not lived out.5 The notes put Jesus’s meaning simply: “If you want to see how to interpret and live your Bible correctly, watch me.”6 How does reading the passage this way change what Jesus is claiming?

Q3: Optional The notes describe a common teaching that Jesus fulfilled the law by “Accomplishing all 613 commandments perfectly,” like “Beating all the ‘levels’ of the Torah ‘video game,’” so that we “no longer need to follow Old Testament law.”7 Our traditions have taught the relationship between the Old Testament and the New in different ways, and each has reasons. What has the way you were taught helped you see, and what does the rabbinic reading add or challenge?

Q4: If “fulfill” means interpreting rightly and then walking it out, think about the last week of your life. If someone had only watched how you lived, without hearing a word you said, what would they conclude you believe the Bible is about?

Authority to Interpret 20 min

The crowds noticed that Jesus taught as someone with authority, and the episode explains why that mattered.

Read Matthew 3:16–17 and Matthew 7:28–29 aloud.

Q5: The notes explain that s’micha is “the rabbinic term for authority to teach and interpret Torah in new ways,” and that “S’micha was conferred by two rabbis who already possessed it, through public laying on of hands.”8 The episode argues Jesus received it at his baptism from two sources: John the Baptist and “God’s voice from heaven declaring Jesus as his beloved Son.”9 Look at the crowd’s reaction at the end of the sermon. What do you think they were wrestling with, and how does the baptism scene answer their question?

Q6: Optional The notes say fulfilling the Prophets means “living out the prophetic vision with his life,” pointing to Isaiah 53’s suffering servant and Amos’s call to “let justice roll.”10 They also note that Jesus says “the Law and the Prophets” here, while Luke 24:44 adds the Psalms.11 Read Luke 24:44 aloud. What difference does it make to think of prophecy as something Jesus lived out rather than only something he checked off?

Q7: The notes say that at the heart of the Beatitudes, Jesus connects hunger for righteousness with mercy, and that this was “counterintuitive to a community living under Roman oppression who might have expected a message of righteous vengeance.”12 Think of someone who has wronged you or people you love. What would hungering for righteousness look like there if it came out as mercy instead of vengeance?

Reading Everything Through Jesus 20 min

If all authority belongs to Jesus, then his lens governs how we read the rest of the Bible.

Read Matthew 28:18 aloud.

Q8: The notes draw out the implication: “followers of Jesus do not have s’micha,” so “Christians must read all of scripture through the lens Jesus provides: love God and love others.”13 They cite Brian McLaren’s observation: “Christians have made Jesus their savior, but Paul their Lord,” meaning we often let Paul interpret Jesus rather than letting Jesus interpret Paul.14 In the traditions you have known, which way has the interpreting usually gone, and what difference would it make to reverse it?

Q9: Optional The notes apply this lens to the conquest stories in Joshua: whatever that book teaches, it must “Be aligned with Jesus’s command to love God and love others,” “Make us more loving toward people,” and “Teach something about loving people, not justify violence.”15 How might this lens help you with a passage of Scripture that troubles you, and what questions does it leave open?

Q10: The notes close by saying “every part of scripture - including difficult passages about violence, conquest, or exclusion - must be read through Jesus’s framework of loving God and loving others.”16 Name one passage you have avoided or struggled with. What would it look like to reread it this week, asking how it teaches you to love God and love people?

Closing 15 min

When Jesus announced God’s favor on outsiders, his disciples wondered whether he was throwing out the Bible. His answer was the opposite. In the language of his day, to fulfill Torah was to interpret it correctly and walk it out faithfully, and Jesus was inviting everyone to watch him. With the authority affirmed at his baptism, he would go on to teach as no other teacher did, with mercy at the center of righteousness. All authority belongs to him, so every part of Scripture is read through his lens: love God and love others.

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one part of the Bible you want to “watch Jesus” interpret for you in the weeks ahead?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 96 — But I Say Unto You (38:15): The episode works through the rest of Matthew 5, where Jesus gives six examples of what fulfilling Torah looks like: murder, adultery, divorce, oaths, retaliation and love for enemies. It argues that Jesus is not raising the bar but revealing what the commandments were always meant to do, and it rereads “be perfect” as a call to be set apart by love.

What to bring next week: Read Matthew 5:21–48. Each time Jesus contrasts what people have heard with what he says, write down one word that names what that teaching is really about.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Abolish or Fulfill.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 95. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/95. In rabbinic tradition, fulfilling Torah means interpreting it correctly and living it out, while abolishing it means misinterpreting it or failing to walk it. ↩

  2. Ep. 95 notes. S’micha as interpretive authority, received by Jesus at his baptism. ↩

  3. Ep. 95 notes. Reading all of Scripture through the lens of loving God and loving others. ↩

  4. Ep. 95 notes. The two elements of fulfillment in rabbinic context. ↩

  5. Ep. 95 notes. The two ways Torah is abolished. ↩

  6. Ep. 95 notes. Jesus teaching through words and embodied example. ↩

  7. Ep. 95 notes. The common Christian reading of fulfillment as completing a checklist. ↩

  8. Ep. 95 notes. The meaning of s’micha and how it was conferred. ↩

  9. Ep. 95 notes. The two sources of Jesus’s s’micha at his baptism. ↩

  10. Ep. 95 notes. Fulfilling the Prophets as living out the prophetic vision. ↩

  11. Ep. 95 notes. “The Law and the Prophets” and Luke 24:44. ↩

  12. Ep. 95 notes. Righteousness through mercy for a people under Roman oppression. ↩

  13. Ep. 95 notes. Followers of Jesus do not have s’micha and must read through his lens. ↩

  14. Ep. 95 notes. Brian McLaren’s observation about Jesus and Paul. ↩

  15. Ep. 95 notes. Applying Jesus’s lens to the conquest narratives in Joshua. ↩

  16. Ep. 95 notes. Every part of Scripture read through Jesus’s framework of love. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.