BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 8 · Week 1 of 26

Episode 362

Isaiah — Prophetic Pathos

Heschel's Prophet: Feeling What God Feels

90-minute session Isaiah 5:1–7; Isaiah 7:1–9

For group discussion. Listen to episode 362 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Why Isaiah, and How Not to Read It 20 min
  3. The Prophet Who Feels Fiercely 25 min
  4. Ahaz, History and Two Pairs That Belong Together 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 8 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 362 Isaiah Prophetic Pathos
2 363 Isaiah Prophetic Imagination
3 364 Isaiah Opening Provocations
4 365 Isaiah Prophet vs. Wizard Priests
5 366 Isaiah Let the Man Cook!
6 367 Isaiah Burdens
7 369 Isaiah The Choice Is Yours
8 370 Isaiah Woes
9 371 Isaiah The Hulk Factor
10 372 Isaiah History and Redaction
11 374 Isaiah When Suffering Is the Way
12 375 Isaiah What Perseverance Produces
13 376 Isaiah Maternal Images of God
14 377 Isaiah The Fruit of Faithfulness
15 379 Psalms Every Season of Life
16 380 Psalms The Hidden Face
17 381 Psalms A Sheep in the Mirror
18 382 Psalms Small, Not Insignificant
19 383 Psalms Praying Hate
20 384 Guest Conversation Centering Jesus (Derek Vreeland)
21 385 Psalms Ultimate Mario Star
22 386 Psalms The Whole Human Experience
23 387 Psalms More Distant Reflections
24 388 Psalms Are You Listening?
25 389 Psalms 23 & Me
26 390 Psalms Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses

Last week: Session 7 closed with Marty back from a 100-day sabbatical, saying rest does not have to produce something profound and that different views among the hosts are healthy (“of course they see it differently”). It ended with a preview of the coming study of Isaiah.1

This week: We begin a long series on Isaiah. Before reading the book itself, the hosts set up a way to read the prophets, with Abraham Joshua Heschel’s The Prophets as a guide.2

About This Session

This episode is not a verse-by-verse study. Marty, Brent and Reed Dent explain why Isaiah still matters after studying Jesus, name two common mistakes in reading the prophets, and introduce Heschel’s central idea: pathos, the prophet’s sharing in God’s own feelings about the world while standing with the people.2

Along the way they cover the crisis King Ahaz faced in Isaiah 7, Heschel’s phrase “few are guilty, all are responsible,” God’s wrath as something meant to correct rather than destroy, and the way the prophets join personal moral responsibility to social responsibility. Some of this touches on politics and church tradition. The goal is to notice our own habits, not to settle who is right.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of someone you have watched care so much about something that it showed on their face or in their voice. What did their feeling teach you that a calm explanation could not have?

Why Isaiah, and How Not to Read It 20 min

The hosts begin by asking why anyone should slow down for Isaiah, and how readers usually go wrong with the prophets.

Q1: Isaiah is the book Jesus quotes most from the Prophets, just as he quotes Deuteronomy most from the Torah and Psalms most from the Writings. The hosts say coming to Jesus does not make Isaiah unnecessary; Isaiah helps us understand Jesus.3 What lines or images from Isaiah do you already carry with you, and where did you first meet them (a sermon, a song, a Christmas program, your own reading)?

Q2: Optional Marty says most books on the prophets fall into one of two traps. One reads the prophets mainly as forecasts of the future. The other dissects the text as literature and leaves it “lifeless.” Marty points to Dr. Ephraim Radner’s call to “take Scripture seriously” as the middle path.4 Which of the two pulls have you felt most in the churches or classes you have been part of? What did that approach help you see, and what might it have kept you from seeing?

Q3: Brent asks the question many listeners have: if Jesus fulfilled Isaiah, why go back? The hosts answer that the Bible is an ongoing conversation you keep wrestling with.5 What would it look like for you to come to Isaiah this season as a conversation partner rather than a book you already know the answers to?

The Prophet Who Feels Fiercely 25 min

Heschel’s word for the heart of prophecy is pathos: the prophet feels what God feels and speaks from inside that experience.

Read Isaiah 5:1–7 aloud.

Q4: Heschel describes the first movement of God’s chastisement as a “failure of freedom,” pictured in the vineyard of Isaiah 5 that God planted, cleared and walled.6 As you listen to the passage, notice the verbs: what does the owner do for the vineyard, and what feelings come through in his voice by the end? Report what you hear before discussing what it means.

Q5: Reed contrasts two pictures of how God responds to sin. One is a “holiness whack-a-mole,” where God waits with a hammer to smash each sin as it pops up. The other is a spurned husband or a father whose children will not listen, saying both “I love you so much” and “you are driving me crazy.”7 The hosts add that every honest parent knows the difference between a parent who gets angry and an angry parent.8 Which picture of God did you absorb growing up, and how does the second picture change the way you hear the vineyard song?

Q6: Optional Heschel’s phrase “few are guilty, all are responsible” sums up the prophetic call. The prophet counts himself among the guilty and speaks “as one of you,” not like a street preacher pointing fingers. His anger comes from compassion and solidarity, not from feeling morally superior.9 Where is it easiest for you to stand outside a problem and point at it? What would it change to speak about that problem as someone inside it?

Ahaz, History and Two Pairs That Belong Together 20 min

In Isaiah’s day, the question was who really controls history. The hosts also name two pairs our culture tends to split apart.

Read Isaiah 7:1–9 aloud.

Q7: Pekah of Israel and Rezin of Aram had allied against Judah, with Assyria looming behind them. Ahaz assumed powerful kings were shaping history; Isaiah insists that “the world was in the hands of God,” so that “what seemed a terror to Ahaz was a trifle to Isaiah.”10 From the passage, what exactly is Ahaz afraid of, and what does Isaiah ask him to do with that fear?

Q8: Optional At Reed’s church, two back-to-back sermons on Amos (a time of prosperity) and Isaiah (a time of threat) led to an observation: scarcity and abundance both lead people to set God aside. In abundance we forget who provided; in scarcity we reach for “Assyria, please help us.”11 Which of the two is the bigger danger for you right now, and how can you tell?

Q9: The prophets hold together personal moral responsibility and social responsibility, which today are usually split between conservative and progressive politics. They also treat idolatry and injustice as cause and effect: what you worship shapes how you treat others. Marty asks how you could pursue social responsibility without personal morality, and how personal morality could be real if it produced no social good.12 Without naming anyone else’s politics, where do your own loyalties tend to lean on one side of these pairs? What is one concrete step that would help you hold both this month?

Closing 15 min

The prophets were not mainly fortune-tellers, and they were not only literary artists. In Heschel’s picture they felt what God feels (grief, longing, anger and disappointment) and spoke from inside that experience while standing with the people. That picture turns God from a cold judge with a hammer into a grieving parent or a wounded spouse, whose anger is real but meant to correct. “No word is God’s last word”: even judgment is followed by a future and hope. Whether we live in fear or in comfort, Isaiah asks us what it asked Ahaz: will we trust that history is in God’s hands?13

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what do you hope to feel, not only learn, as we read Isaiah together?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 363 — Isaiah — Prophetic Imagination (50:04): Reed Dent leads a second introductory conversation on what a prophet is (a spokesperson, not a fortune teller) and works through Walter Brueggemann’s The Prophetic Imagination. It pairs criticism that begins in grief with energizing that begins in hope, which gives us two questions to carry into every chapter of Isaiah.

What to bring next week: Read Isaiah 1 once through and mark one line that sounds like grief and one that sounds like hope. Also think of an ordinary person in your life who said a hard truth others avoided.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Session 7 Capstone.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 360. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/360. Marty’s sabbatical reflections, the value of differing views, “of course” thinking, and the preview of Isaiah. ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings, with Reed Dent. “Isaiah — Prophetic Pathos.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 362. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/362. The episode opens the Isaiah series with Heschel’s The Prophets and his idea of pathos, the history around Isaiah, wrath as corrective, and the joining of personal and social responsibility. ↩ ↩2

  3. Ep. 362 notes. Jesus’ most-quoted books in each part of the Tanakh, and Isaiah as a help for understanding Jesus. ↩

  4. Ep. 362 notes. The two traps (fundamentalist forecasting and lifeless textual-critical reading) and Radner’s call to take Scripture seriously. ↩

  5. Ep. 362 notes. Brent’s question about returning to Isaiah and the answer that the Bible is an ongoing conversation. ↩

  6. Ep. 362 notes. Heschel’s three movements of chastisement, with the vineyard of Isaiah 5 as the “failure of freedom.” ↩

  7. Ep. 362 notes. Reed’s contrast between “holiness whack-a-mole” and God as spurned husband or frustrated father. ↩

  8. Ep. 362 notes. The parenting example distinguishing a parent who gets angry from an angry parent. ↩

  9. Ep. 362 notes. “Few are guilty, all are responsible,” and the prophet’s solidarity with the people. ↩

  10. Ep. 362 notes. The crisis under Ahaz (Isaiah 7) and Heschel’s lines on God’s control of history. ↩

  11. Ep. 362 notes. Emily’s observation from the Amos and Isaiah sermons that scarcity and abundance both lead people to set God aside. ↩

  12. Ep. 362 notes. The two pairs that are not really opposites, and Marty’s questions about personal morality and social good. ↩

  13. Ep. 362 notes. The personalized summary: pathos, God as grieving parent, wrath as corrective, “no word is God’s last word,” and Ahaz’s question of trust. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.