BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 8 · Week 22 of 26

Episode 386

Psalms — The Whole Human Experience

Psalms 139 and 51: When the Psalmist Becomes the Man of Blood

90-minute session Psalm 139; Psalm 51; 2 Samuel 11–12; Romans 5:20

For group discussion. Listen to episode 386 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Fully Known, Then a Jarring Turn 25 min
  3. You Are the Man 35 min
  4. Closing 20 min

Where We Are

The Session 8 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 362 Isaiah Prophetic Pathos
2 363 Isaiah Prophetic Imagination
3 364 Isaiah Opening Provocations
4 365 Isaiah Prophet vs. Wizard Priests
5 366 Isaiah Let the Man Cook!
6 367 Isaiah Burdens
7 369 Isaiah The Choice Is Yours
8 370 Isaiah Woes
9 371 Isaiah The Hulk Factor
10 372 Isaiah History and Redaction
11 374 Isaiah When Suffering Is the Way
12 375 Isaiah What Perseverance Produces
13 376 Isaiah Maternal Images of God
14 377 Isaiah The Fruit of Faithfulness
15 379 Psalms Every Season of Life
16 380 Psalms The Hidden Face
17 381 Psalms A Sheep in the Mirror
18 382 Psalms Small, Not Insignificant
19 383 Psalms Praying Hate
20 384 Guest Conversation Centering Jesus (Derek Vreeland)
21 385 Psalms Ultimate Mario Star
22 386 Psalms The Whole Human Experience
23 387 Psalms More Distant Reflections
24 388 Psalms Are You Listening?
25 389 Psalms 23 & Me
26 390 Psalms Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses

Last week: Psalm 91 taught us that God’s refuge does not carry us around suffering but through it, and that those who shelter under God’s wings are called to become shelter for others.

This week: Two psalms attributed to David, read side by side, show the same man as both the hunted and the hunter, and a God who sees the whole of him at once.

About This Session

Reed Dent guides Marty and Brent through Psalm 139, a psalm of comfort about being fully known by God that turns suddenly to hatred of the “bloodthirsty” wicked, and Psalm 51, David’s confession after Nathan confronts him over Bathsheba and the death of Uriah. Reed noticed that the Hebrew word behind “bloodthirsty” in Psalm 139:19 is the same word as “bloodshed” in Psalm 51:14. The man who prayed against men of blood has become one.

From that link the hosts trace mirror-image phrases across the two psalms, warn against turning single verses into fixed doctrines, and question our habit of sorting people into heroes and villains. They lean on Solzhenitsyn’s line that good and evil run through every human heart, while insisting this is not an excuse for harm. Over both psalms stands a God who sees all of a person and still restores those who come home. Some questions today touch hurt and anger, so share only what you choose to.

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a story, film or show where you were sure who the hero and the villain were, and then the story turned. What made it turn, and how did it feel?

Fully Known, Then a Jarring Turn 25 min

Psalm 139 moves from womb-like security to violent language and back again.

Read Psalm 139 aloud, all twenty-four verses.

Q1: The notes describe three movements: verses 1–18 feel “like I’m in the womb,” safe and fully known; verses 19–22 turn to hatred (Robert Alter renders verse 22 “I hate them with complete hatred”); and verses 23–24 return to openness1. Where exactly did you feel the turn as we read it? What words or images change, and what stays the same across all three movements?

Q2: Optional The hosts contrast two ways of reading verses 19–22. A scholar asks whom David meant, which keeps the text at arm’s length. A person praying it has to ask whom they have wished gone or defeated. Marty and Brent admitted milder versions of this, such as “I wish I would never hear from that person again.”2 Which way of reading comes more naturally to you, and what does each one protect you from?

Q3: Marty says honesty about wanting an enemy defeated is part of the Psalms, but “That’s not where the story ends,” because the enemy also bears the image of God. The notes add that finding hatred hard to feel is a good sign, because it means we resist “othering,” putting people in a category of humanity we tell ourselves we don’t belong to3. Where do you see othering happen most easily in your own world, at work, online, in politics or at church? What helps you resist it?

You Are the Man 35 min

A shared Hebrew word shows that David’s role has flipped, not just his mood.

Read 2 Samuel 12:1–7 aloud, then read Psalm 51 aloud.

Q4: The Hebrew word damim (“blood” or “bloodshed”) appears in Psalm 139:19, literally “men of blood,” and in Psalm 51:14, “deliver me from the guilt of bloodshed.” In Psalm 139 David is threatened by men of blood; in Psalm 51 he has become one. Reed imagines Uriah, abandoned on the battlefield, praying Psalm 139:19–22, and the man he would have meant is David4. What do you notice when you hold those two verses together? What does Reed’s thought experiment do to the way you hear Psalm 139?

Q5: Optional The hosts found mirror-image phrases in almost every stanza, such as “My frame was not hidden from you” (139:15) beside “Hide your face from my sins” (51:9), and “Search me, God, and know my heart” (139:23) beside “Create in me a pure heart” (51:10)5. With a partner, find one more pair the group has not named yet and report what the contrast shows. Marty suggests David may have pulled out an old favorite and written an “anti-psalm” in reply. Why might someone in their lowest moment write against the grain of a psalm they once loved?

Q6: Optional The hosts warn against lifting single verses out and turning them into fixed doctrines, and they name Psalm 51:5 (“sinful from the time my mother conceived me”) as an example. Read next to Psalm 139:13, each line comes from a different moment in David’s life, and both are true because both come from real experience6. Our traditions in this room have read Psalm 51:5 in different ways. Without settling that, how does reading it as a cry from a particular moment change what it says to you?

Q7: Asked whether David is a victim or a perpetrator, a hero or a villain, the notes say the honest answer is “yes.” Solzhenitsyn put it this way: “The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either, but right through every human heart.” Marty adds that in a given moment one person can be plainly the offender, as David was, but over a whole life everyone has been both7. Reed says that if you live long enough you will probably have a “Uriah,” someone who could rightly say, “Look what he did to me.”8 Share only if you wish. How does seeing that “I am my enemy, and my enemy is me” change the way you hold anger toward someone, without excusing real harm?

Closing 20 min

Psalm 139 and Psalm 51 come from opposite places in one man’s life. In the first, David rests in being fully known and prays against the men of blood who hunt him. In the second, after Nathan’s “You are the man,” he confesses that he has become one. Together they take away the comfortable sorting that makes “complete hatred” easy, without pretending that harm does not matter. Over both stands a God who sees the whole of each person at once, from the womb to our worst choices, and who answers not with hatred but by restoring the joy of salvation to those who come home. “Where sin increased, grace increased all the more.”9

Closing Question: Going around the room in one sentence each, with no comments until everyone has spoken: which of the two psalms sounds more like your season right now, and why?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 387 — Psalms — More Distant Reflections (51:38): Brent and Reed set Psalm 32 beside Psalm 51 and suggest both come from the same event. Psalm 51 is raw and urgent, written in the moment; Psalm 32 sounds like an older David looking back calmly on the same failure. The hosts trace hiding, bones, silence and confession across the psalms, and talk about the cost of hiding, the work of restoration, and how God redeems brokenness for the good of others10.

What to bring next week: Try the episode’s suggested practice: read Psalm 139 and Psalm 51 side by side on at least three days this week and notice which parts fit your current season. Also read Psalm 32 once before we meet.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings, with co-host Reed Dent. “Psalms — The Whole Human Experience.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 386. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/386. The three movements of Psalm 139 and Alter’s translation of verse 22. ↩

  2. Ep. 386 notes. The scholar’s approach versus praying the psalm, and the hosts’ everyday examples. ↩

  3. Ep. 386 notes. Marty on honesty and the image of God, and resisting “othering.” ↩

  4. Ep. 386 notes. The shared word damim, the reversal of David’s role, and Reed’s Uriah thought experiment. ↩

  5. Ep. 386 notes. The table of mirror-image phrases and Marty’s “anti-psalm” suggestion. ↩

  6. Ep. 386 notes. The warning against absolutizing single verses such as Psalm 51:5. ↩

  7. Ep. 386 notes. Victim and perpetrator, Solzhenitsyn (quoted via Fleming Rutledge’s The Crucifixion), and Marty’s nuance. ↩

  8. Ep. 386 notes. Reed on “the Uriah in your life,” and the point that this is not an excuse for wrongdoing. ↩

  9. Ep. 386 notes. The picture of God in both psalms and Romans 5:20. ↩

  10. Brent Billings with co-host Reed Dent. “Psalms — More Distant Reflections.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 387. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/387. Psalm 32 as a later reflection paired with Psalm 51. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.