BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 8 · Week 26 of 26

Episode 390

Psalms — Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses

Closing the Psalms: Done with Decorum, Aimed at God

90-minute session Psalm 13; Psalm 100; Psalm 4; Psalm 8:3–4; Psalm 104:1–2; Psalm 118:24

For group discussion. Listen to episode 390 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. Done with Decorum 25 min
  3. Aimed at God 25 min
  4. Living with the Psalms 15 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 8 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 362 Isaiah Prophetic Pathos
2 363 Isaiah Prophetic Imagination
3 364 Isaiah Opening Provocations
4 365 Isaiah Prophet vs. Wizard Priests
5 366 Isaiah Let the Man Cook!
6 367 Isaiah Burdens
7 369 Isaiah The Choice Is Yours
8 370 Isaiah Woes
9 371 Isaiah The Hulk Factor
10 372 Isaiah History and Redaction
11 374 Isaiah When Suffering Is the Way
12 375 Isaiah What Perseverance Produces
13 376 Isaiah Maternal Images of God
14 377 Isaiah The Fruit of Faithfulness
15 379 Psalms Every Season of Life
16 380 Psalms The Hidden Face
17 381 Psalms A Sheep in the Mirror
18 382 Psalms Small, Not Insignificant
19 383 Psalms Praying Hate
20 384 Guest Conversation Centering Jesus (Derek Vreeland)
21 385 Psalms Ultimate Mario Star
22 386 Psalms The Whole Human Experience
23 387 Psalms More Distant Reflections
24 388 Psalms Are You Listening?
25 389 Psalms 23 & Me
26 390 Psalms Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses

Last week: A second walk through Psalm 23 found God answering sin, fear and scarcity with rest and closeness: a table set in front of our enemies and goodness that chases us down.

This week: The Psalms series wraps up with two big ideas: the Psalms free us to bring our whole selves to God, and they always aim that honesty at God.

About This Session

This episode closes the Psalms series, with Brent, Reed Dent and Elle Grover Fricks (Marty is absent). Reed draws out two main points. First, the Psalms free us from “decorum,” so we can speak what we feel rather than what we think we ought to say, and that works in both directions, for lament and for joy. Second, that expression is never just for its own sake, because every psalm is aimed at God. Elle explains why we hold back, why bringing everything to God is an act of trust, and why venting without turning toward truth can backfire.

Elle also gives the academic answer to the series’ opening question, “What is poetry?”: Hebrew poetry shares structures like parallelism and chiasm with other ancient poetry, it is brief, and it uses special vocabulary. Reed reads from three modern poets who still write in a psalm-like way, and the hosts close with practical ways to keep living with the Psalms. Before all that, they check in on a running joke from the series: did the podcast ever actually explain “life psalms”? (It remains unresolved.)

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Elle and Brent talked about songs and poems that say what they feel better than they can, from choir pieces to a worship song that once carried Brent somewhere no recording has matched1. Name a song, hymn or poem that has done that for you. When did it first reach you?

Done with Decorum 25 min

The Psalms give permission to drop the act, in both directions.

Read Psalm 13 aloud, then read Psalm 100 aloud.

Q1: Reed says some people need Psalm 13 (“How long, O Lord?”) to admit they doubt, while others need Psalm 100 (“Shout for joy to the Lord”) to let themselves celebrate. He admits he is in the second group: he doesn’t dance at wedding receptions because unfiltered joy feels exposing2. What do you notice about the two psalms side by side? Which one would be harder for you to pray honestly, and why?

Q2: Optional The notes say you can fake feelings in either direction. Gushing, sugary praise can be fake, and so can dramatic, edgy complaining. The goal is sincerity, not provocation3. Where have you seen worship or prayer slip into performance in one direction or the other? What helps you tell the difference in your own prayers?

Q3: Elle traces both performing and staying silent to the same root: “a fear of being seen, or a wish to control how we are seen,” and sometimes a fear of losing control of ourselves. Bringing it all to God, rather than venting alone, is a statement of trust that God can hear it and work through it with us4. She compares it to marriage: a spouse may read your body language, but the relationship is still stronger when you say plainly how you are doing and why5. What feeling do you most often keep from God, and what would it look like to say it plainly this week?

Aimed at God 25 min

The Psalms never treat feelings as the final word; they keep turning back to God.

Read Psalm 8:3–4 aloud, then read Psalm 4 aloud.

Q4: Reed points out how the Psalms turn experience toward God. Not “nature is cool,” but God stretching out the heavens like a tent (Psalm 104). Not “I am sad,” but “How long, O Lord?” (Psalm 13). Not abstract thinking about human nature, but “what is mankind that you are mindful of them?” (Psalm 8). Because they speak in first person to “you,” praying them as written “forces us to the table” with God6. Look at Psalm 4 again. Where do you see the psalmist speaking about God, and where speaking to God? What changes at the turn in the last verses?

Q5: Optional Elle explains that brevity and special vocabulary are marks of Hebrew poetry, and that the Psalms don’t follow a fixed prayer formula. She mentions being taught an ordered pattern of thanksgiving, adoration, confession and so on, and notes that overly formal, hedged prayer (“if it be within your sovereign will…”) can be as performative as anything else7. Our traditions pray in different ways, some with set forms and some without. Without ranking them, what has your tradition’s way of praying given you, and where has it made honesty harder?

Q6: Elle warns that every time we retell a story we strengthen it in memory, so “just getting it out of my system” can lock in a harmful story. As a teenager she filled journals with angsty prayers and came away more anxious, because she never got around to reminding herself what was true about God. Psalm 4 complains for several verses and then turns to “In peace I will lie down and sleep.”8 Share only what you are comfortable sharing. What story have you retold so often that it may be holding you, and what truth about God would you need to preach to yourself to make the turn?

Living with the Psalms 15 min

The psalm-writing tradition is still alive, and there are simple ways to join it.

Q7: Optional Reed reads three modern poets who write “psalmically,” including Franz Wright, whose poem ends with God answering: “though your own heart condemn you / I do not condemn you.” Reed’s ministry ends each semester by asking, “What did God see?”9 The notes call imagining God’s reply a creative practice anyone can use. If God answered the prayer you named in Q3 or Q6, what do you imagine God might say?

Q8: The hosts offer practical paths forward: let the Psalms be your prayer life for a season by praying one every day for a month; write your own psalm using Psalm 8 or Psalm 51 as a template, or write a psalm on one half of a page and your response on the other; put psalms up in your home; and let psalms mark key moments, so your Bible becomes a “road map” of where God showed up10. Which of these practices will you try in the coming month, and what psalm will you start with?

Closing 15 min

This session’s Psalms series has carried us from the refuge of Psalm 91, through Psalms 139, 51 and 32, to the silent heavens of Psalm 19 and the table of Psalm 23, and this final episode gathers it into two things to carry. First, we don’t have to perform for God. Whether we are stuck in anger and doubt or can’t let ourselves feel joy, there is a psalm that can draw out what we have been holding back, and offering it to God is an act of trust. Second, the Psalms never treat feelings as the final word; they keep pointing us back to God, invite God to answer, and often carry us from complaint to a renewed sense of who God is. As Elle put it, you are never just feeling down alone in your room. You’re feeling down “with a great cloud of witnesses.”11

Closing Question: Going around the room in one sentence each, with no comments until everyone has spoken: share the psalm line you brought tonight and the season of your life it now marks.

Looking Ahead

Ep. 391 — Tommy Brown — The Ache for Meaning (44:38): The next episode in Session 8. It has no notes yet, and neither does the rest of Session 8, which includes the Talmudic Matthew series, Practical Shabbat, guest conversations and the Session 8 Capstone.

What to bring next week: Choose one psalm to pray every day this week, as the hosts suggest. Bring one line you prayed and a sentence about what happened when you prayed it.

References

  1. Brent Billings, with Reed Dent and Elle Grover Fricks. “Psalms — Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 390. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/390. Elle and Brent on music and choral pieces that work like psalms. ↩

  2. Ep. 390 notes. Different people need different psalms, and Reed’s own discomfort with unfiltered joy. ↩

  3. Ep. 390 notes. Faking feelings in either direction, and sincerity as the goal. ↩

  4. Ep. 390 notes. Elle on fear, control and trust. ↩

  5. Ep. 390 notes. Elle’s marriage comparison for why speaking matters even though God already knows. ↩

  6. Ep. 390 notes. Reed on how the Psalms tie experience back to God, with Psalms 104, 13, 8 and 118. ↩

  7. Ep. 390 notes. Elle on brevity, special vocabulary and the absence of a fixed prayer formula. ↩

  8. Ep. 390 notes. Elle on retelling stories, her teenage journals, and Psalm 4 as a model of reorientation. ↩

  9. Ep. 390 notes. Reed’s reading of Franz Wright’s “The Only Animal” and his ministry’s question “What did God see?” ↩

  10. Ep. 390 notes. Practical paths for praying, writing and living with the Psalms. ↩

  11. Ep. 390 notes. The episode’s two main points, its look back over the psalms of the series, and Elle’s closing line. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.