BEMA Podcast Notes

Discussion Guide · Session 8 · Week 3 of 26

Episode 364

Isaiah — Opening Provocations

Isaiah 1–6: A Father's Grief and a Prophet's Call

90-minute session Isaiah 1:1–20; Isaiah 2:1–8; Isaiah 4:2–6; Isaiah 6:1–13

For group discussion. Listen to episode 364 first.

Session plan 90 min

  1. Opening 10 min
  2. A Father and His Comfortable Children 25 min
  3. Backing Into the Future 20 min
  4. Pruned Stumps and a Burning Call 20 min
  5. Closing 15 min

Where We Are

The Session 8 series, week by week
WeekEpisodeSeriesFocus
1 362 Isaiah Prophetic Pathos
2 363 Isaiah Prophetic Imagination
3 364 Isaiah Opening Provocations
4 365 Isaiah Prophet vs. Wizard Priests
5 366 Isaiah Let the Man Cook!
6 367 Isaiah Burdens
7 369 Isaiah The Choice Is Yours
8 370 Isaiah Woes
9 371 Isaiah The Hulk Factor
10 372 Isaiah History and Redaction
11 374 Isaiah When Suffering Is the Way
12 375 Isaiah What Perseverance Produces
13 376 Isaiah Maternal Images of God
14 377 Isaiah The Fruit of Faithfulness
15 379 Psalms Every Season of Life
16 380 Psalms The Hidden Face
17 381 Psalms A Sheep in the Mirror
18 382 Psalms Small, Not Insignificant
19 383 Psalms Praying Hate
20 384 Guest Conversation Centering Jesus (Derek Vreeland)
21 385 Psalms Ultimate Mario Star
22 386 Psalms The Whole Human Experience
23 387 Psalms More Distant Reflections
24 388 Psalms Are You Listening?
25 389 Psalms 23 & Me
26 390 Psalms Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses

Last week: With Brueggemann, we saw the prophet as a spokesperson who criticizes through grief and energizes through hope, and heard that “prophecy without doxology becomes ideology.”1

This week: Marty and Brent begin reading Isaiah itself, taking the opening six chapters through the image of a frustrated father pleading with stubborn children.2

About This Session

The hosts frame Isaiah 1–39 as its own section, tied to the reigns of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz and Hezekiah. They then read a comfortable, prosperous Judah that keeps up its worship while ignoring justice, God’s sincere invitation to “reason together,” and the vision of nations streaming to the mountain of the Lord.2

Two images carry the second half: the rabbinic idea of “backing into the future,” and the netzer (shoot) that grows from a pruned olive stump. The episode ends with Isaiah’s throne-room call in chapter 6, which the hosts read as a picture of prophetic pathos. The hosts also warn against reading Isaiah 1 as being about “those foolish Israelites”; the question is how it speaks to our own comfortable, church-going cultures.3

Opening 10 min

Opening Question: Think of a time when someone you love (a child, a parent, a friend) frustrated you precisely because you loved them. What did that frustration sound like coming out of your mouth?

A Father and His Comfortable Children 25 min

Isaiah opens not with a judge’s verdict but with a parent’s grief over a people who are religious, comfortable and blind to injustice.

Read Isaiah 1:2–4 aloud.

Q1: The hosts point to the contrast in verse 3: the ox and the donkey know their master, but Israel “does not know.” They say the relationship looks less like a cold legal arrangement and more like a scorned spouse or a frustrated parent.4 What words would you use for the tone of these verses? Point to the phrases that give you that impression.

Q2: Optional Marty shares a midrash from Tommy Brown’s The Ache for Meaning. A father carries his child through the market on his shoulders and buys everything the child asks for. At the end of the day the child asks a stranger, “Have you seen my daddy?” The father answers, “You foolish child, you are riding on my shoulders.” The point is that when God becomes the supplier of what we want, we stop recognizing him as Father.5 When has your own faith felt most like a transaction, and what helped you notice?

Read Isaiah 1:10–17 aloud.

Q3: Judah is not irreligious. They keep the new moons, Sabbaths, festivals and offerings, and their worship may even feel sincere to them. Yet God rejects it, because how they live and shape their world contradicts it. Unlike the northern kingdom, the hosts say, Judah as a whole was benefiting from its economic system. The remedy God names is mishpat (justice): seek justice, defend the oppressed, take up the cause of the fatherless and the widow.6 Read as being about us rather than “those Israelites,” what in this passage is hardest for a comfortable, church-going culture like ours to hear?

Q4: The hosts insist that “Come now, let us reason together” (1:18–20) is a sincere invitation, not sarcasm. They describe two sides in today’s polarization: one denies anything is wrong, and the other lives only in the critique of verses 5–14 with no hope. Marty affirms that people’s faith journeys and deconstruction are valid, and asks whether there is room within them for repair.7 Where are you more likely to stall, in denial or in critique without hope? What would one small act of repair look like for you?

Backing Into the Future 20 min

Between the judgments sits a vision of hope, and a striking picture of how God’s people face what is coming.

Q5: Optional In Isaiah 2:1–5, all nations stream to Zion to learn God’s ways and beat their swords into plowshares. The hosts stress that Isaiah does not imagine God giving up on his plan. The hope is Plan A renewed, not a Plan B.8 What difference does it make to think of hope as God’s original purpose restored rather than a backup plan?

Read Isaiah 2:2–8 aloud, and compare how your translations render verse 6.

Q6: The NIV and NET add “Lord” in verse 6 (“You, Lord, have abandoned your people”), and the NET admits the word was supplied; the ESV reads “you have rejected your people.” Following Robert Alter, Marty suggests the “you” is the nation itself: Judah has abandoned its calling, its identity and its story, looking east for superstitions and west to the Philistines for divination.9 What does your translation say? Read the verses again assuming the people are the ones doing the abandoning. What changes?

Q7: “In the last days” (2:2) can be read more literally as “in the behind days.” In rabbinic thought, pagan nations tried to predict the future through divination, while God’s people walk backward into a future only God can see, with their eyes on what God has already done.10 The hosts suggest this as a practice for uncertain times. What is one thing God has already done, in Scripture or in your own story, that you need to keep your eyes on right now?

Pruned Stumps and a Burning Call 20 min

Judgment in Isaiah is real, but it serves renewal, and Isaiah’s own call comes out of an encounter he cannot unsee.

Q8: Netzer means a shoot or branch, and Nazareth likely comes from the same root (“shoot town”). Marty was taught that every few centuries an olive trunk is cut flat below the branches, and a new shoot grows from the stump; without pruning the tree grows wild and useless. Christians rightly connect the branch with Jesus, but Marty suggests Isaiah’s primary concern was the remnant of his own people.11 What does the pruning image suggest about the purpose of God’s judgment in Isaiah 4?

Read Isaiah 6:1–13 aloud.

Q9: Optional The hosts read “Here am I, send me” two ways. Brent hears someone just restored and eager to go. Marty hears someone who may be terrified but answers anyway, overwhelmed by an encounter that leaves no real alternative. Brent also hears in “For how long, Lord?” an echo of Abraham bargaining in Genesis 18, except Isaiah never negotiates.12 Which reading rings truer to you as you listen to the whole chapter, and why?

Q10: The hosts compare Isaiah’s yes to Frodo at the Council of Elrond: a reluctant, costly yes to a burden he cannot put down. The answer to “how long” is ruin, yet “the holy seed will be the stump in the land.”13 When have you said yes to something hard because, having seen what you saw, you could not do otherwise? What is God asking you to keep saying yes to now?

Closing 15 min

Isaiah begins with a father’s grief, not a judge’s verdict. His audience was comfortable, prosperous and religious, keeping the festivals while their hands were “full of blood” from injustice. Yet Isaiah does not stop at critique: God says “Come now, let us reason together” and holds out a vision of swords turned into plowshares, the original plan renewed. Backing into the future and the shoot rising from a pruned stump both point to trust in what God has already done and in pruning that serves new life. Isaiah’s “Here am I, send me,” whether spoken in eagerness or in fear, models a faithfulness that answers God’s presence even when the road looks like ruin.14

Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: what is one thing God has already done that you want to keep your eyes on this week?

Looking Ahead

Ep. 365 — Isaiah — Prophet vs. Wizard Priests (1:01:16): Brent, Elle Grover Fricks and Josh Bossé slow down on Isaiah 6:1–7. They look at the Hebrew of “let us reason together,” what a prophet’s “thus says the Lord” really carries, the meaning of King Uzziah’s name, and how Isaiah’s “unclean lips” and burning coal reverse the rituals of Assyrian diviner-priests.

What to bring next week: Read 2 Chronicles 26, the story of King Uzziah, and then reread Isaiah 6:1–7. Come ready to say what the two passages have to do with each other.

References

  1. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings, with co-host Reed Dent. “Isaiah — Prophetic Imagination.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 363. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/363. Brueggemann’s criticism and energizing, and “prophecy without doxology becomes ideology.” ↩

  2. Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Isaiah — Opening Provocations.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 364. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/364. The episode frames Isaiah 1–39 and reads chapters 1–6 through the image of a frustrated father. ↩ ↩2

  3. Ep. 364 notes. The warning against reading Isaiah 1 as “those foolish Israelites,” which can slide toward antisemitism. ↩

  4. Ep. 364 notes. Isaiah 1:2–3 and the relational frame of spouse or parent. ↩

  5. Ep. 364 notes. The marketplace midrash from Tommy Brown’s The Ache for Meaning. ↩

  6. Ep. 364 notes. Judah’s comfortable, benefiting nation and worship without justice in Isaiah 1:10–17. ↩

  7. Ep. 364 notes. Isaiah 1:18–20 as sincere invitation, the two sides of polarization, and room for repair within deconstruction. ↩

  8. Ep. 364 notes. The mountain of the Lord (Isaiah 2:1–5) as Plan A renewed. ↩

  9. Ep. 364 notes. Translation choices in Isaiah 2:6 and Robert Alter’s reading. ↩

  10. Ep. 364 notes. “The behind days” and the rabbinic idea of backing into the future. ↩

  11. Ep. 364 notes. The netzer, olive pruning, Nazareth, and the remnant. ↩

  12. Ep. 364 notes. Brent’s and Marty’s readings of “Here am I, send me,” and the echo of Genesis 18. ↩

  13. Ep. 364 notes. The Frodo parallel and the stump of Isaiah 6:13. ↩

  14. Ep. 364 notes. The personal summary of the episode. ↩

This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.

My Notes

Jot down your answers and thoughts as you prepare or discuss. Notes save automatically and stay in this browser only — they aren't uploaded anywhere, and clearing your browser's site data will erase them.

Tip: back up your notes, or move them to another browser, from Settings.