Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- Poetry, Not Proof Texts 20 min
- A Vocabulary for the Soul 25 min
- Orientation, Disorientation, New Orientation 20 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Series | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 362 | Isaiah | Prophetic Pathos |
| 2 | 363 | Isaiah | Prophetic Imagination |
| 3 | 364 | Isaiah | Opening Provocations |
| 4 | 365 | Isaiah | Prophet vs. Wizard Priests |
| 5 | 366 | Isaiah | Let the Man Cook! |
| 6 | 367 | Isaiah | Burdens |
| 7 | 369 | Isaiah | The Choice Is Yours |
| 8 | 370 | Isaiah | Woes |
| 9 | 371 | Isaiah | The Hulk Factor |
| 10 | 372 | Isaiah | History and Redaction |
| 11 | 374 | Isaiah | When Suffering Is the Way |
| 12 | 375 | Isaiah | What Perseverance Produces |
| 13 | 376 | Isaiah | Maternal Images of God |
| 14 | 377 | Isaiah | The Fruit of Faithfulness |
| 15 | 379 | Psalms | Every Season of Life |
| 16 | 380 | Psalms | The Hidden Face |
| 17 | 381 | Psalms | A Sheep in the Mirror |
| 18 | 382 | Psalms | Small, Not Insignificant |
| 19 | 383 | Psalms | Praying Hate |
| 20 | 384 | Guest Conversation | Centering Jesus (Derek Vreeland) |
| 21 | 385 | Psalms | Ultimate Mario Star |
| 22 | 386 | Psalms | The Whole Human Experience |
| 23 | 387 | Psalms | More Distant Reflections |
| 24 | 388 | Psalms | Are You Listening? |
| 25 | 389 | Psalms | 23 & Me |
| 26 | 390 | Psalms | Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses |
Last week: Isaiah closed with a renewed world of justice and welcome, and with Marty’s picture of a father who disciplines his son and then invites him to “say yes to building a new world with Dad.”1
This week: Reed Dent opens a new series on the Psalms, arguing that they are poetry meant to be experienced and that they give us honest words for every season of life.2
About This Session
The episode starts with a confession: Marty and Brent both find the Psalms hard to connect with, because years of study have trained them to dissect rather than experience. Reed’s answer is to read the Psalms as poetry, which “applies greater pressure per word,” and not as a source of proof texts. He sets Psalm 51:5 beside Psalm 139:13–14 to show why single lines should not be turned into doctrine.3
Reed then describes the Psalms as a vocabulary for the soul, giving words for grief and doubt and, in a cynical age, for joy and praise as well. He offers two ways of grouping the Psalms, ending with Walter Brueggemann’s framework of orientation, disorientation and new orientation, which will guide the rest of the series. The main point is that God is the right conversation partner in every season.4
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: Reed remembers playing one album on repeat on his brother’s Discman in 1996–97.5 Name a song that is tied to a particular season of your life. What season was it, and what happens in you when you hear it now?
Poetry, Not Proof Texts 20 min
The Psalms are poetry from start to finish, and poetry works differently from explanation or argument.
Read Proverbs 29:11 aloud in every translation the group has on hand.
Q1: The episode compares four translations of this verse, from the NIV to Robert Alter’s. As a teenager Reed took it as a reason always to stay rational and calm, which later made a psalm like Psalm 137 feel uncomfortable. Through college apologetics he became “a brain in a jar,” and reading poetry helped reconnect him with his emotions.6 What differences do you notice between the translations you just heard? What happens when one wisdom principle like this is applied to every part of life?
Q2: Thomas Long, quoting Laurence Perrine, says poetry has “a higher voltage than other literary forms” and “applies greater pressure per word.” Long adds that poems change us “by making finely tuned adjustments at deep and critical places in our imagination.” The notes put it simply: prose is discursive and propositional, while poetry is evocative and expressive.7 If the Psalms are meant to create experiences rather than make claims, how might that change the way you read them?
Q3: Optional Brent says that once he opens his Bible he goes into “study mode,” and that studying the Psalms on a podcast is a bit like “dissecting a swallow.”8 What mode do you tend to go into when you open the Bible, and where did you learn it? What is one thing that helps you experience a text rather than only study it?
A Vocabulary for the Soul 25 min
The Psalms do not supply answers so much as ways to ask the questions.
Read Psalm 51:5 aloud. Then read Psalm 139:13–14 aloud.
Q4: The notes call this “the Psalm 51 vs. Psalm 139 tension.” Psalm 51:5 is often used as a proof text for original sin, while Psalm 139 praises God for being “fearfully and wonderfully made.” Rather than asking which one is “true,” Reed suggests each honestly expresses what the psalmist is living through, and that the two gain more by speaking to each other.9 What do you notice when you hear these two lines back to back? What might each psalmist have been going through to say what they said?
Q5: The traditions in this room have taught Psalm 51:5 in different ways, and some have built a great deal on it. Marty separates theology in the broad sense, “the study and expression of experiencing God,” from doctrine built by proof-texting, and says the Psalms belong to theology rooted in concrete experience.10 How was Psalm 51:5 used in the church you grew up in, if it was used at all? What would change, and what would stay the same, if you heard it first as an honest cry from one moment of a life?
Read Psalm 13:1–2 aloud.
Q6: Reed, a campus minister, describes a student who feels “God is nowhere” but was taught God is always present. Praying Psalm 13 turns those forbidden feelings into prayer. The episode borrows King Lear’s line that the Psalms invite us to “speak what we feel, not what we ought to say,” because God already knows what is going on inside us.11 What feelings have you, at some point, believed you were not allowed to bring to God? Share only what you are comfortable sharing.
Q7: Optional Reed argues that in a cynical culture, where any hopeful statement draws an instant “yeah, but,” the Psalms of praise and wonder may now be the harder and more necessary voice. In his words, honesty includes being honest about hope.12 Right now, which is harder for you to say honestly to God: lament or joy? Why do you think that is?
Orientation, Disorientation, New Orientation 20 min
Brueggemann’s three modes describe seasons of life rather than tidy categories of content.
Q8: Reed gives each mode a seasonal image. Orientation is a summer evening on the porch with lemonade; disorientation is winter, “when it plunges below zero”; new orientation is the first warm day after a long winter. He also insists that no categories capture the Psalms neatly. They form “a really big, messy Venn diagram,” just as human life does.13 Which of these images feels closest to the season you are in now? What makes it hard to place yourself in only one?
Read Psalm 8:3–4 aloud.
Q9: Psalm 8 is one of Reed’s examples of reflection and wonder. Psalms of orientation remind us that it is “okay to be okay.” Marty admits that “How are you doing?” frustrates him when life is simply fine, and the Psalms of orientation give that season its own song.14 What do you notice about the tone of these verses compared with Psalm 13? Why might people of faith feel they need to explain away a season when life is simply good?
Q10: Optional New orientation is “not just a return to the old normal” but a changed outlook shaped by having been rescued, pictured as the “Mario star”: nothing can touch me now. Reed also suggests that moving into disorientation mirrors crucifixion, and moving into new orientation mirrors resurrection. Two simple practices come up in the episode: praying one psalm a day, and reading things that aren’t the Bible, especially poetry.15 Which of those two practices could you try this week, and what would make it realistic?
Closing 15 min
The Psalms are poetry, words that carry greater pressure per word and reach places in us that argument cannot. They do not hand us doctrines to defend so much as honest words for grief, doubt, anger, hope, praise and joy. Whether we are on the summer porch, stuck in a bitter winter, or feeling the first warm day of spring, there is a psalm for that season. The deepest invitation is that God is the right conversation partner in all of them, and that we can bring God what we actually feel.
Closing Question: In one sentence, name the season you are in right now and one honest word you want to say to God about it.
Looking Ahead
Ep. 380 — Psalms — The Hidden Face (1:01:15): Brent, Reed and Josh Bossé walk slowly through Psalm 13, a short, raw lament that opens with “How long, O Lord?” They look at a Hebrew word for “forget” that suggests being misplaced rather than rejected, trace the idea of God’s “hidden face” through Scripture, and talk about how to care for people who feel abandoned by God.16
What to bring next week: Read Psalm 13 slowly twice this week and mark the verse where its tone changes. Bring to mind a time you felt overlooked or forgotten (you will not be asked to share it).
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings. “Isaiah — The Fruit of Faithfulness.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 377. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/377. Isaiah’s renewed world of hope and Marty’s review of the book through a father disciplining his son. ↩
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings, with co-host Reed Dent. “Psalms — Every Season of Life.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 379. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/379. Reed opens the Psalms series by treating the Psalms as poetry that gives words for every human experience. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, Title and Source Summary and Key Takeaways. Marty and Brent’s difficulty with the Psalms, poetry’s “greater pressure per word,” and the warning against proof texts. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, Title and Source Summary and “Walter Brueggemann’s Framework.” The Psalms as words for every experience, the two groupings, and God as conversation partner in every season. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, Examples and Applications, “Music and memory.” Reed’s memory of an album on his brother’s Discman and the link between music and emotion. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Why the Psalms Are Hard for Some Readers” and “Translation and the Problem of Hebrew Poetry.” The four translations of Proverbs 29:11 and Reed’s story. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “What Poetry Is (and Isn’t).” Long and Perrine on poetry, and prose contrasted with poetry. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Why the Psalms Are Hard for Some Readers.” Brent’s “study mode” and the image of dissecting a swallow. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Theology and the Psalms.” Psalm 51:5 and Psalm 139:13–14 as honest expressions from different moments rather than competing doctrines. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Theology and the Psalms.” Marty’s distinction between theology and doctrine formed by proof-texting. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “The Psalms as a Vocabulary for the Soul,” Key Takeaways, and Examples and Applications, “Campus ministry.” Praying Psalm 13 and the King Lear line. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Honesty About Hope in a Cynical Age.” Cynicism, the harder voice of praise, and honesty about hope. ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Walter Brueggemann’s Framework” and Key Takeaways. Reed’s seasonal images and the “messy Venn diagram.” ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Content Categories,” “Walter Brueggemann’s Framework,” and Examples and Applications. Psalm 8 as reflection, “okay to be okay,” and Marty on “How are you doing?” ↩
-
Ep. 379 notes, “Walter Brueggemann’s Framework” and Examples and Applications. New orientation, the Mario star, the crucifixion and resurrection reading, daily psalms and reading poetry. ↩
-
Brent Billings, with co-hosts Reed Dent and Josh Bossé. “Psalms — The Hidden Face.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 380. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/380. A slow reading of Psalm 13, the word for “forget,” the hidden face of God, and pastoral care. ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.