Session plan 90 min
- Opening 10 min
- What a Prophet Is, and Is Not 20 min
- The Dominant Culture and the Prophetic Alternative 20 min
- Grief, Hope and Doxology 25 min
- Closing 15 min
Where We Are
| Week | Episode | Series | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 362 | Isaiah | Prophetic Pathos |
| 2 | 363 | Isaiah | Prophetic Imagination |
| 3 | 364 | Isaiah | Opening Provocations |
| 4 | 365 | Isaiah | Prophet vs. Wizard Priests |
| 5 | 366 | Isaiah | Let the Man Cook! |
| 6 | 367 | Isaiah | Burdens |
| 7 | 369 | Isaiah | The Choice Is Yours |
| 8 | 370 | Isaiah | Woes |
| 9 | 371 | Isaiah | The Hulk Factor |
| 10 | 372 | Isaiah | History and Redaction |
| 11 | 374 | Isaiah | When Suffering Is the Way |
| 12 | 375 | Isaiah | What Perseverance Produces |
| 13 | 376 | Isaiah | Maternal Images of God |
| 14 | 377 | Isaiah | The Fruit of Faithfulness |
| 15 | 379 | Psalms | Every Season of Life |
| 16 | 380 | Psalms | The Hidden Face |
| 17 | 381 | Psalms | A Sheep in the Mirror |
| 18 | 382 | Psalms | Small, Not Insignificant |
| 19 | 383 | Psalms | Praying Hate |
| 20 | 384 | Guest Conversation | Centering Jesus (Derek Vreeland) |
| 21 | 385 | Psalms | Ultimate Mario Star |
| 22 | 386 | Psalms | The Whole Human Experience |
| 23 | 387 | Psalms | More Distant Reflections |
| 24 | 388 | Psalms | Are You Listening? |
| 25 | 389 | Psalms | 23 & Me |
| 26 | 390 | Psalms | Feeling Dumb with a Great Cloud of Witnesses |
Last week: Through Heschel’s The Prophets, we met the prophet as someone who feels what God feels (pathos) and stands with the people, and we heard that God’s wrath is meant to correct, not destroy.1
This week: Reed Dent leads a second introduction: what a prophet actually is and does, read through Walter Brueggemann’s short book The Prophetic Imagination.2
About This Session
The first half of the episode sets the popular picture of a prophet as a fortune teller against the biblical picture of a spokesperson who stands with God and confronts a whole community in the present. The second half works through Brueggemann’s framework: a “dominant culture” built on a religion of triumphalism and a politics of oppression, answered by a prophetic alternative of God’s freedom, justice and compassion.2
The heart of the episode is Brueggemann’s pairing of criticism that begins in grief with energizing that begins in hope. The hosts argue that each one goes sour without the other, and that both need to be rooted in worship. Some questions invite you to look at your own church background and community; share as much or as little as you like.
Opening 10 min
Opening Question: What picture comes to mind when you hear the word “prophet,” and where do you think that picture came from?
What a Prophet Is, and Is Not 20 min
The hosts start with a simple model from Exodus: a prophet carries someone else’s voice.
Read Exodus 6:28–7:2 aloud.
Q1: Moses says he has “faltering lips,” so God appoints Aaron to speak for him, and Moses will be “like God to Pharaoh.” Brent jokes that Aaron had it easy, since he only spoke for Moses while Moses carried the weight of speaking for God. Marty hears in the phrase a link to Heschel’s pathos: the prophet has been with God and carries that experience to others.3 Trace the chain of voices in the passage. Who speaks for whom, and what does each person in the chain need in order to do the job?
Q2: Optional Reed grew up in a charismatic church where visiting “prophets” would “speak into your life.” He sees some truth in it but thinks the emphasis was misplaced. The biblical prophets, he says, spoke to a community rather than an individual, about the present rather than the future, and about what God requires of you rather than what God will do for you.4 Which of those contrasts is most different from the picture of prophecy you grew up with, in whatever tradition you come from?
Q3: Frederick Buechner jokes that “there is no evidence to suggest that anyone ever asked a prophet home for supper more than once.” The hosts note that comforting prophets (“peace, peace, when there is no peace,” Jeremiah 6:14) get invited back, and that the poster verse Jeremiah 29:11 came from a prophet thrown into a cistern and left for dead.5 Think of a time someone told you something true you did not want to hear. How did you treat them afterward, and what would it take for you to invite that kind of voice back?
The Dominant Culture and the Prophetic Alternative 20 min
Brueggemann’s model is Pharaoh’s Egypt: the prophet speaks to a people who were rescued and called, and whose calling has been tamed.
Read Exodus 5:6–18 aloud.
Q4: Brueggemann names two pillars of the dominant culture. A religion of triumphalism says “we are here to win, conquer, prosper, and remake the world in our image.” A politics of oppression treats those who fall behind as dead weight, like Pharaoh’s demand for bricks without straw. Brueggemann argues that the first directly produces the second.6 From the passage, what does Pharaoh assume about the workers, and how does a culture built on “winning” end up treating people that way?
Q5: Optional The hosts contrast an American idea of justice that tends to be punitive (balancing the scales) with a prophetic idea of justice that is restorative. Marty describes mishpat (justice) and tzedakah (righteousness) as right relationship, a straight line rather than a crooked one. The prophets keep returning to the “quartet of the vulnerable”: the poor, the widow, the orphan and the sojourner.7 Which of those four is hardest to see from where you live and worship, and why?
Q6: Brueggemann says a people’s calling can be “domesticated” in more than one way: through prosperity, as with the wealthy Israel Amos confronts, or through fear, as when Ahaz turns to Assyria for protection. The hosts suggest economic success, national power, progress or political tribalism as possible modern versions.8 This is a question for honest self-examination, not for diagnosing other churches. Where might something like that be quietly taming the calling of your own community, or your own life?
Grief, Hope and Doxology 25 min
The prophet works through two linked moves: criticism that begins in grief, and energizing that begins in hope.
Read Amos 5:24 aloud.
Q7: Brueggemann writes: “Real criticism begins in the capacity to grieve because grief is the most visceral announcement that things are not right. Only in the empire are we pressed and urged and invited to pretend that things are all right.” Amos 5:24 is the hosts’ example of energizing, pointing toward where things can go.9 In your own words, why would grief have to come before criticism? What changes in criticism that does not start there?
Q8: Optional Criticism alone produces what Reed calls “ironic hipster” cynicism, and Marty notes this is a common weakness in deconstruction conversations. Energizing alone produces sentimentality; Reed’s brother-in-law struggled in churches that offered only happy songs and no grief.10 When you drift, which way do you tend to drift, toward cynicism or toward sentimentality? What usually pulls you there?
Q9: The hosts say numbing yourself to grief also numbs your capacity for hope and joy, because you cannot choose where the numbness stops. They add Brueggemann’s line that “prophecy without doxology becomes ideology”: critique and hope cut off from worship collapse into partisan positions on the left or right.11 Sharing here is optional. Where might you have numbed a grief in order to cope, and what would one small act of lament, rooted in worship, look like for you this week?
Closing 15 min
The biblical prophets were not mystics reading personal destinies. They were spokespeople who shared God’s heart and stood up in public to remind a rescued people of their calling, which is why they were rarely invited back for supper. Empires run on triumphalism and oppression; God’s people are called to a different world shaped by God’s freedom, justice and compassion. The prophet criticizes through grief and energizes through hope, and both are needed. Beneath it all is doxology, and the message moves through indictment and a call to repentance toward God’s own act of restoration, when God will “swallow up death forever” (Isaiah 25:8).12
Closing Question: In one sentence each, going around the room: name one place in your life where you need either more grief or more hope.
Looking Ahead
Ep. 364 — Isaiah — Opening Provocations (53:32): Marty and Brent turn to the text itself and read Isaiah 1–6 through the image of a frustrated father pleading with stubborn children. They look at worship that ignores justice, God’s invitation to “reason together,” the rabbinic idea of “backing into the future,” the netzer (shoot) from a pruned olive stump, and Isaiah’s throne-room call.
What to bring next week: Read Isaiah 1 and Isaiah 6. As you read Isaiah 1, ask the two questions from this week: where is the grief, and where is the hope?
References
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings, with Reed Dent. “Isaiah — Prophetic Pathos.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 362. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/362. Heschel’s idea of pathos, the prophet’s solidarity, and wrath as corrective. ↩
-
Marty Solomon and Brent Billings, with co-host Reed Dent. “Isaiah — Prophetic Imagination.” BEMA Discipleship Podcast, Episode 363. bemadiscipleship.com. Episode notes: bema-podcast-notes.github.io/ep/363. The episode defines the prophet as spokesperson and works through Brueggemann’s The Prophetic Imagination. ↩ ↩2
-
Ep. 363 notes. The Exodus model of Moses and Aaron, Brent’s observation, and Marty’s link to Heschel’s pathos. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Reed’s charismatic background and the table contrasting popular caricature with biblical prophecy. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Buechner’s definition from Peculiar Treasures, false prophets in Jeremiah 6:14, and the context of Jeremiah 29:11. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Brueggemann’s two pillars of the dominant culture, Pharaoh’s bricks without straw, and triumphalism producing oppression. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Punitive versus restorative justice, mishpat and tzedakah as right relationship, and the quartet of the vulnerable. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Domestication through prosperity (Amos) and fear (Ahaz), and the suggested modern examples. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Brueggemann’s quotation on grief (p. 11) and Amos 5:24 as energizing. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Criticism alone as cynicism, energizing alone as sentimentality, and the examples given by Reed and Marty. ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. Numbness to grief and hope, and “prophecy without doxology becomes ideology.” ↩
-
Ep. 363 notes. The personal summary and the three-part prophetic arc ending in divine restoration (Isaiah 25:8). ↩
Was this guide helpful?
Thanks for the feedback.
This discussion guide was developed using these notes and is aligned with the content and approach of the BEMA Discipleship Podcast (opens in a new tab) by Marty Solomon and Brent Billings.